Now Theresa May can stand up to Rupert Murdoch. But will she? | Tom Watson

If the Sky bid is blocked it will be the first example of May doing what she promised to do – take on the rich and powerful

There was one reason for the recommendation that Rupert Murdoch’s bid for Sky should be blocked: the media empire he runs in the UK simply has too much power and influence. It is refreshing to hear a regulator acknowledge that fact in admirably straightforward language. The Competition and Markets Authority’s (CMA) ruling is a victory for campaigners who have highlighted the influence Murdoch has wielded over successive governments and prime ministers.

It now falls to the culture secretary, Matt Hancock, to show that era is finally drawing to a close by accepting the authority’s decision and blocking Fox’s bid to acquire the 61% of Sky it doesn’t already own. Technically, he can ignore its ruling. Politically, it would be foolish to do so. Perhaps most tellingly of all, the risk attached to blocking the bid is far smaller than it once would have been.

The last general election showed that the power of Murdoch’s papers, and the Sun in particular, is waning. Its coverage of the Labour party was arguably the most biased since the 1992 election, when the paper infamously claimed it had prevented Neil Kinnock entering Downing Street. Even if it was The Sun Wot Won It – and many think it wasn’t – it is a claim the paper could never make now.

Theresa May still refuses to publish a full account of her secret meeting with Murdoch in New York in 2016. The CMA has been braver and bolder than the prime minister by making it clear that it’s unhealthy for a single person or company to control such a huge swath of the UK news industry.

Murdoch’s hegemony corroded our political system and bent it out of shape. In the past, rules that applied to his competitors were not applied to him. News Corporation used its dominant position in the newspaper market to lobby successfully for legislation to be changed so Sky had the right to buy Channel 5, had it chosen to do so. Murdoch’s personal relationship with Margaret Thatcher meant he received the assurances he needed from her to move his newspapers to Wapping. Competitors who had a right to expect a level playing field found that Murdoch’s power had tilted it in his favour.

Those who felt Murdoch had become untouchable had good reason to do so. It was in this context that a corporate culture emerged in which executives were able to collude in and then cover up criminality at his newspapers. The Sun is still fighting civil cases brought by victims of phone-hacking in the UK and the scandal had a sequel in the US, where senior figures at Fox News were involved in payoffs in order to conceal allegations of sexual harassment. Late last year I met a group of Fox News journalists who have been treated appallingly by the company. That’s one reason I don’t agree with the CMA’s finding that Fox hasn’t breached broadcasting standards – and neither will they.

The phone-hacking affair forced Murdoch to abandon his last attempt to take control of Sky in 2011. But is worth remembering that Jeremy Hunt, who was culture secretary at the time, had already cleared it after Sky promised to spin off Sky News.

This time round the company threatened to close it if the deal was blocked, a move that would have resulted in thousands of job losses. Journalists and production staff would have paid a heavy price for the company’s petulance had the threat been carried out. That is now unlikely to happen because Fox’s entertainment assets – including Sky – are being sold off to the much larger Disney, which is hardly the fairytale ending the Murdoch had envisaged.

If the bid is indeed blocked, it will be the first example of May standing up to the rich and powerful since she first promised to do so on the steps of Downing Street 18 months ago. She probably wasn’t thinking of Murdoch when she said it, but events have a way of overtaking this prime minister. Now they are overtaking the Murdochs too.

• Tom Watson is Labour MP for West Bromwich East and deputy leader of the Labour party


Tom Watson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Rupert Murdoch wins government clearance for Sky takeover
21st Century Fox gets go-ahead to buy the 61% of the business it does not already own

Mark Sweney

12, Jul, 2018 @10:48 AM

Article image
Spun-off Sky News would not be independent, say rivals
Rupert Murdoch faces backlash from newspaper owners amid fears £8bn BSkyB buyout will lead to NewsCorp domination

Dan Sabbagh

22, Mar, 2011 @12:01 AM

Article image
Rupert Murdoch unlikely to spin off Sky News in takeover battle
It is understood 21st Century Fox believes conditions associated with failed 2011 bid are no longer necessary because industry landscape has changed

Mark Sweney

13, Dec, 2016 @8:00 PM

Article image
Rupert Murdoch finally gets green light for BSkyB takeover – but at a price

News Corporation may pay £1.9bn more than original offer after delay brought about by eight-month inquiry

Dan Sabbagh, James Robinson and Mark Sweney

30, Jun, 2011 @7:19 PM

Rupert Murdoch: Empire of the Sun | Editorial
Editorial: No well-functioning democracy should allow one man to frame its window on the world


30, Jun, 2011 @7:29 PM

Article image
Rupert Murdoch | MediaGuardian 100 2013

Job: chairman and chief executive 21st Century Fox, executive chairman News Corporation
Age: 82
Industry: publishing, broadcasting, digital media
2012 ranking: 11

01, Sep, 2013 @9:47 PM

Article image
Ken Clarke: Tories had deal with Rupert Murdoch for 2010 election
Former minister suggests deal involved appointment by prime minister David Cameron of Andy Coulson, former News of the World editor, to position at No 10

Graham Ruddick Media editor

23, Nov, 2017 @7:34 PM

Article image
Rupert Murdoch | MediaGuardian 100 2012

Job: chairman and chief executive, News Corporation
Age: 81
Industry: broadcasting, publishing, digital media
2011 ranking: 6

16, Sep, 2012 @9:40 PM

Article image
Murdoch’s dominance is insidious. He must not be allowed to buy Sky | Polly Toynbee
Politicians already kowtow to the News Corp owner. Someone must stand up to his bullying and stop the spread of his brand of toxic vitriol

Polly Toynbee

15, Dec, 2016 @1:11 PM

Article image
Murdoch 'must increase Sky News budget to £100m'
Culture secretary says Sky takeover requires 15-year commitment to news unit

Mark Sweney

19, Jun, 2018 @4:07 PM