The Guardian view on the press and Trump: speaking truth to power | Editorial

On Thursday, hundreds of US news organisations are publishing editorials opposing the president’s attacks on the press. The Guardian stands with them

Press freedom was not invented in the United States, but there are few nations in which the importance of an independent press has been so closely woven into its long history. This great American tradition of civic respect for truth and truth-telling is now under threat. Donald Trump is not the first US president to attack the press or to feel unfairly treated by it. But he is the first who appears to have a calculated and consistent policy of undermining, delegitimising and even endangering the press’s work.

On Thursday, following an initiative by the Boston Globe, it is expected that some 350 editorial boards in news organisations across the United States will publish their own editorial comments on this issue. There is, of course, a risk in this initiative, and there will be differing press views about it. For some, including Mr Trump, it will feed the narrative that there is a partisan war between the press and the president. But the breadth of the response to the Boston Globe’s suggestion – and the fact that each editorial will be separately and independently written – suggests something different: that those who report and comment, day in and day out, in as professional and objective a manner as we can, are concerned that public respect for journalistic truth, reason and civility are under a new and present threat against which we must stand as best we can. As one editor has put it: we’re not at war with the Trump administration, we’re at work.

Mr Trump’s sweeping abuse of the press is grimly familiar now. He calls the US press “enemies of the people”. He accuses it – the instances now run into hundreds – of producing “fake news” and being “frankly disgusting”. He recently called the press “dangerous and sick”, and charged that they can “cause war”. He has called journalists “the lowest form of humanity”. The former FBI chief James Comey, later fired by Mr Trump, said the president asked him to consider jailing journalists for publishing leaks. His administration has removed reminders to respect press freedom from its internal manuals. He singles out four news organisations in particular – CNN, MSNBC, the New York Times and the Washington Post – insulting them in public (as he did at his Chequers press conference) and recently barring a CNN reporter from White House media events.

Inescapably, this campaign has consequences. Public opinion, especially among Mr Trump’s most committed supporters, has become harsher in its views. Almost half of Republican voters (44%) believe the president should be able to close news organisations for “bad behaviour”, according to a recent poll. In another poll this week a majority of Republican voters (51%) say that the news media are “the enemy of the people”. The anti-media mood at some Trump rallies has been intimidating. Social media trolling, violent abuse and threats to journalists (especially sexual threats to women journalists) have reached unprecedented levels. The United Nations human rights commissioner warned this week that Mr Trump’s attacks on the press are “very close to incitement to violence”. In June, five staff members at the Capital Gazette in Maryland were shot dead by a local man with a local grievance. They may not be the last.

It is not the press’s job to save the United States from Mr Trump. It is the press’s job to report, delve, analyse and scrutinise as best it can and without fear. The press has many faults. It can be self-regarding. Far worse, in Mr Trump’s America, some parts of the media are partisan outlets which show a cavalier disregard for truth: the president has embraced these. But a free press must call out intimidation and incitement when it exists. And it must do what it can to preserve respect for the facts and for balanced judgment. In short, it must do its job. Mr Trump’s insults and incitements are a calculated danger to that, and to the respect, civility and dialogue that should exist between the press and its readers. The Guardian stands with the US press in its efforts to maintain the objectivity and the moral boundaries that this president – like so many others in much more dangerous parts of the world – is doing so much to destroy.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Battle against Trump’s Acosta ban should mark a turning point
Fox News support for CNN journalist could mark the start of a subtle shift in the phoney war

Emily Bell

18, Nov, 2018 @1:59 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the US pipe bombs: rage and resistance | Editorial
Editorial: The targeting of senior Democrats and critics of the president is another alarming indication of the political climate


25, Oct, 2018 @5:48 PM

Article image
Quiz: who should have won Trump's most dishonest and corrupt media awards?
‘#FakeNews CNN’, the ‘Failing @NYTimes’ – or the US president, who has often been economical with the truth?

Martin Belam

18, Jan, 2018 @12:46 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the killing of journalists: the truth in peril | Editorial
Editorial: The murders of reporters in the EU and fears for a Saudi columnist highlight the growing threat to those in the media


09, Oct, 2018 @5:39 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on media freedom: democracies must defend it | Editorial
Editorial: Police raids in Australia remind us that threats to journalistic independence are not confined to authoritarian states


05, Jun, 2019 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on media freedom: it must be defended | Editorial
Editorial: Killed, jailed and bullied, journalists are under growing pressure worldwide. Brave individuals such as Maria Ressa in the Philippines need our support


13, Feb, 2019 @6:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Jamal Khashoggi’s murder: Saudi Arabia and its friends | Editorial
Editorial: One way to honour Khashoggi is to celebrate his life. Another is to recognise the lessons of his death


19, Jun, 2019 @5:32 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Russia’s hostage-taking: free Evan Gershkovich | Editorial
Editorial: The charges against the Wall Street Journal reporter are a chilling and unprecedented move


11, Apr, 2023 @5:40 PM

Article image
Trump's attacks on media raise threat of violence against reporters, UN experts warn
President condemned for ‘strategic’ attacks as Sarah Sanders refuses to disagree with Trump’s view of the press as the enemy

Sabrina Siddiqui and David Smith Washington

02, Aug, 2018 @6:52 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on press freedom: a connective tissue of society | Editorial
Editorial: Journalists defy dangers because they understand that their role is a necessary check on the ambition and vanity of the rich and powerful. Protecting reporters has never been so necessary


01, May, 2018 @5:32 PM