Jean-Baptiste Moreau gets one over on ‘fake meat’ | Rebecca Nicholson

French MP says substitutes for the real thing can’t be allowed to use meaty or dairy names

In what seems to be a rather extreme reaction to the blight of fake news, French MP and farmer Jean-Baptiste Moreau successfully proposed a measure last week to ban vegetarian and vegan meat or dairy substitutes from calling themselves meat- or dairy-based names. “It is important to combat false claims,” he tweeted. “Our products must be designated correctly: the terms of #cheese or #steak will be reserved for products of animal origin!”

Ironically, Moreau shares a position with a number of vegans and vegetarians I know, many of whom find the idea of “fake meat” repulsive. Why would you give up chicken, then spend ages trying to find something that resembles chicken in every way, shape and form? There’s an ongoing debate to that effect swirling around the Impossible Burger, which is said to taste like meat, which “bleeds” (beetroot) when bitten into.

I can understand a certain squeamishness, but I am a firm believer in fake meats. I have tried many “interpretations” of bacon because before I gave it up I enjoyed the taste enormously. I just don’t like it enough, now, to buy into the horrors of industrial meat farming. I’m also fascinated by the ingenuity and invention that goes into making “fake” foods, the point being that they’re cruelty-free, some of which are genuinely delicious, some of which less so. I once tried making a carrot into “smoked salmon”, based on a very convincing internet recipe, the result of which tasted like a raw carrot had been dragged over a bunsen burner and left out on the pavement for a few days to warm through.

I realise that labelling food is mired in the endless complexity of French language and identity, but the rule does leave me perplexed as to who it’s protecting. Surely people are capable of differentiating between a burger made of lentils and one made of beef? One thing is clear: Moreau is yet to sample the delights of vegan cheese, as there is absolutely no way he’d get it confused with the real thing.

• Rebecca Nicholson is an Observer columnist


Rebecca Nicholson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
If we can grow cruelty-free meat in a lab, what is there to beef about? | Barbara Ellen
Science is forcing vegans and vegetarians who demand others join them to think again

Barbara Ellen

05, Dec, 2020 @6:00 PM

Article image
Jonathan Safran Foer: I’ve got no beef with his plan to save the planet | Rebecca Nicholson
The US novelist has come up with a way to wean people off their taste for animal products

Rebecca Nicholson

05, Oct, 2019 @2:30 PM

Article image
The trouble with fake meat
From beetroot burgers to hoisin ‘duck’, imitation meats are everywhere. But are these substitutes any healthier for us to eat?

Bee Wilson

27, Jan, 2019 @5:59 AM

Article image
Calm down, carnivores: fake meat with real flavour is good for all of us | Aine Carlin
Plant-based ‘burgers’ – now so tasty they deserve to be sold alongside the real thing – are not just for vegetarians and vegans, says the food writer Aine Carlin

Aine Carlin

12, Jun, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
May I have a word about… flexitarian diets | Jonathan Bouquet
I’ve got nothing against people eating less meat or dairy, but what, pray, is the point of a fishless fillet?

Jonathan Bouquet

06, Jan, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
From tofu lamb chops to vegan steak bakes: the 1,000-year history of fake meat
Plant-based burgers are all the rage in 2020, but meat substitutes date back to at least 965. Will we ever invent the perfect proxy – or should we forget about meat altogether?

Elle Hunt

12, Jan, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Stop telling me not to eat meat: we should all be flexitarians | Toby Moses
There are compelling reasons to forgo meat – but it’s delicious. Campaigns such as Meat Free Monday show a realistic way forward

Toby Moses

12, Oct, 2016 @11:12 AM

Vegans, carnivores, whatever… feel free to just eat in peace | Catherine Bennett
We are in danger of becoming a nation of intolerants, ever eager to decry other people’s dietary choices

Catherine Bennett

05, Jan, 2018 @8:19 PM

Article image
Letters: securing our food supplies is more vital than diets | Observer letters
It’s easier than ever to go vegan, but there are other ways to reduce the impact of what we eat

02, Jan, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Laura Kuenssberg’s successor must be immune to likes and follows | Tim Adams
Dullness and a total disinterest in their media profile are desirable traits in the BBC’s next political editor

Tim Adams

23, Oct, 2021 @2:00 PM