The Guardian view on the Balkans: hold out a hand | Editorial

A renewed effort to reach out to the countries that make up the EU’s poor and worrying south-eastern flank is long overdue

The European Union’s task of enlargement remains starkly incomplete: the bloc’s south-eastern flank is largely in limbo. Almost 20 years after the Balkans wars ended, there’s a gaping hole on the map, bounded by members including Croatia, Romania and Greece. In 2015, the refugee crisis exposed how swiftly nationalist passions could return to the region. As hundreds of thousands of people trekked northwards, volunteers helped provide food and clothing to desolate refugees. But tensions flared among governments, and troops were even deployed at some borders. Two years on, the Balkan route is mostly closed, but the region’s problems are still vivid.

The question of how to stabilise the Balkans, anchor democracy there, and bring the region closer to EU institutions remains an immense challenge, given insufficient attention. Balkan civil society activists are increasingly concerned about unemployment, corruption, and a brain drain as young, educated people leave for jobs elsewhere in Europe. They say it is crucial to reboot the prospect of EU membership for Serbia, Bosnia, Macedonia, Albania and Montenegro, to encourage much needed reforms. They are right. The Balkans matter to Europe not just because of the migration issue, but also for energy routes, security, and the fight against organised crime. Little has been done to address underlying problems.

The good news is that awareness of this seems to be growing. The president of the European commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, said recently that if the EU wants to ensure more stability in its own neighbourhood, “then it must maintain a credible enlargement perspective for the western Balkans”. In 2018, the UK is due to host a special summit on the western Balkans – an initiative presented by the government as evidence that “Britain is leaving the EU but not Europe”. And when the French president, Emmanuel Macron, laid out his plans for Europe’s future, he said that “the EU will have to open itself up to the Balkan countries” once they meet the conditions, because that will help consolidate “peace and stability on our continent”. At stake, he added, is the need to prevent Balkan nations from “turning their backs on Europe and moving towards either Russia or Turkey, or towards authoritarian powers”.

For the Balkans question is as much about broader international competition as it is about values. The EU is confronted with strong competition from external powers seeking to secure footholds on its doorstep and capitalise on the region’s weaknesses. Russia plays on orthodox and Slavic ties, and Turkey seeks to promote a “neo-Ottoman” vision. But more distant actors, including China and Saudi Arabia, are increasingly active. One civil society activist in Belgrade describes this as “an unbelievable geopolitical game that would have been unimaginable in 1989”, when the communist bloc started crumbling.

As the EU speaks of reinvigorating its 60-year-old project, it needs to build a stable regional architecture for the Balkans. Years of deferring the prospects of membership have taken a toll. Studies show public support for the EU has dropped among the region’s citizens. This only helps fuel polarisation and populism, with corrupt regimes benefiting and the economy suffering. Normalising the relationship between Serbia and Kosovo hinges on what Europe can offer. More EU funds should be directed towards the region as enticement.

Churchill once said that “the Balkans produce more history than they can consume”. If left unaddressed, bad governance and old feuds could backfire on everyone. The consequences would be felt beyond the region. The lesson from its history is surely that the rest of Europe has a key interest in making sure the Balkans are not left to become a backwater simmering with tensions, but are helped to modernise, and are one day brought into the club.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Europe is facing a potential crisis in the Balkans. It has to act soon | Ivan Krastev
The promise of EU membership for states in the region is welcome, but the influence of Russia, China and Turkey could create instability, says Ivan Krastev, chairman of the Sofia-based Centre for Liberal Strategies

Ivan Krastev

21, Feb, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Serbia president lauds Russia ties at EU Balkans summit
Aleksandar Vučić’s comments come as EU leaders ditch proposal to put 2030 deadline for six western Balkan nations to join bloc

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

06, Oct, 2021 @2:28 PM

Article image
The west must not just abandon the Balkans to Russia’s embrace | Ivor Roberts
The proposal to honour the late Serbian war criminal Slobodan Milošević with a statue in Belgrade reflects a wider power play, says former ambassador Ivor Roberts

Ivor Roberts

05, Apr, 2018 @11:08 AM

Article image
No time soon: EU dashes membership hopes of Balkan states
Concerns over rule of law and corruption, plus enlargement fatigue, meant the six countries got little from Sofia summit

Shaun Walker in Sofia

18, May, 2018 @4:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on the EU and migration: let’s stop the Balkans being part of the problem | Editorial
Editorial: The EU has been ignoring south-east Europe for too long. We should act now to head off trouble later


27, Aug, 2015 @6:59 PM

Article image
Russian destabilisation of Balkans rings alarm bells as EU leaders meet
Top MEP David McAllister says bloc must be more visible in the region to counter Kremlin’s growing influence

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

09, Mar, 2017 @9:20 AM

Balkan journalists face threats and intimidation, says report
Human Rights Watch urges EU to intervene in countries seeking membership

Roy Greenslade

15, Jul, 2015 @8:04 AM

Article image
'The LGBT community is invisible': using data to fight hate crime in the Balkans
In Kosovo, Serbia and Bosnia, NGOs are collecting hate crime data and leveraging the countries’ EU ambitions to push for rights

Morgan Meaker

30, Mar, 2016 @12:33 PM

Article image
Rumbling Balkans threaten foreign policy headache for Trump
In Kosovo, Serbia, Bosnia and Macedonia, signs of ethnic tension are on the rise again

Andrew MacDowall in north Kosovo and the Preševo valley

27, Feb, 2017 @2:38 PM

Article image
A lesson from Serbia | Misha Glenny
Misha Glenny: As the Balkan economies struggle, the temptation for nationalist solutions will grow. Europe must take note

Misha Glenny

23, May, 2012 @7:30 PM