The truth about the US ‘opioid crisis’ – prescriptions aren’t the problem | Marc Lewis

The overdose epidemic is unmistakable. But it’s driven by illicit use of drugs. If moral panic results in more patients in pain, that would be a disaster

The news media is awash with hysteria about the opioid crisis (or opioid epidemic). But what exactly are we talking about? If you Google “opioid crisis”, nine times out of 10 the first paragraph of whatever you’re reading will report on death rates. That’s right, the overdose crisis.

For example, the lead article on the “opioid crisis” on the US National Institutes of Health website begins with this sentence: “Every day, more than 90 Americans die after overdosing on opioids.”

Is the opioid crisis the same as the overdose crisis? No. One has to do with addiction rates, the other with death rates. And addiction rates aren’t rising much, if at all, except perhaps among middle-class whites.

Let’s look a bit deeper.

The overdose crisis is unmistakable. I reported on some of the statistics and causes in the Guardian last July. I think the most striking fact is that drug overdose is the leading cause of death for Americans under 50. Some people swallow, or (more often) inject, more opioids than their body can handle, which causes the breathing reflex to shut down. But drug overdoses that include opioids (about 63%) are most often caused by a combination of drugs (or drugs and alcohol) and most often include illegal drugs (eg heroin). When prescription drugs are involved, methadone and oxycontin are at the top of the list, and these drugs are notoriously acquired and used illicitly.

Yet the most bellicose response to the overdose crisis is that we must stop doctors from prescribing opioids. Hmmm.

Yes, there has been an upsurge in the prescription of opioids in the US over the past 20 to 30 years (though prescription rates are currently decreasing). This was a response to an underprescription crisis. Severe and chronic pain were grossly undertreated for most of the 20th century. Even patients dying of cancer were left to writhe in pain until prescription policies began to ease in the 70s and 80s. The cause? An opioid scare campaign not much different from what’s happening today. (See Dreamland by Sam Quinones for details.)

Certainly some doctors have been prescribing opioids too generously, and a few are motivated solely by profit. But that’s a tiny slice of the big picture. A close relative of mine is a family doctor in the US. He and his colleagues are generally scared (and angry) that they can be censured by licensing bodies for prescribing opioids to people who need them. And with all the fuss in the press right now, the pockets of overprescription are rapidly disappearing.

But the news media rarely bother to distinguish between the legitimate prescription of opioids for pain and the diverting (or stealing) of pain pills for illicit use. The statistics most often reported are a hodge-podge. Take the first sentence of an article on the CNN site posted on 29 October: “Experts say the United States is in the throes of an opioid epidemic, as more than two million of Americans have become dependent on or abused prescription pain pills and street drugs.”

First, why not clarify that most of the abuse of prescription pain pills is not by those for whom they’re prescribed? Among those for whom they are prescribed, the onset of addiction (which is usually temporary) is about 10% for those with a previous drug-use history, and less than 1% for those with no such history. Note also the oft-repeated maxim that most heroin users start off on prescription opioids. Most divers start off as swimmers, but most swimmers don’t become divers.

Second, wouldn’t it be sensible for the media to distinguish street drugs such as heroin from pain pills? We’re talking about radically different groups of users.

Third, virtually all experts agree that fentanyl and related drugs are driving the overdose epidemic. These are many times stronger than heroin and far cheaper, so drug dealers often use them to lace or replace heroin. Yet, because fentanyl is a manufactured pharmaceutical prescribed for severe pain, the media often describe it as a prescription painkiller – however it reaches its users.

It’s remarkably irresponsible to ignore these distinctions and then use “sum total” statistics to scare doctors, policymakers and review boards into severely limiting the prescription of pain pills.

By the way, if you were either addicted to opioids or needed them badly for pain relief, what would you do if your prescription was abruptly terminated? Heroin is now easier to acquire than ever, partly because it’s available on the darknet and partly because present-day distribution networks function like independent cells rather than monolithic gangs – much harder to bust. And, of course, increased demand leads to increased supply. Addiction and pain are both serious problems, serious sources of suffering. If you were afflicted with either and couldn’t get help from your doctor, you’d try your best to get relief elsewhere. And your odds of overdosing would increase astronomically.

It’s doctors – not politicians, journalists, or professional review bodies – who are best equipped and motivated to decide what their patients need, at what doses, for what periods of time. And the vast majority of doctors are conscientious, responsible and ethical.

Addiction is not caused by drug availability. The abundant availability of alcohol doesn’t turn us all into alcoholics. No, addiction is caused by psychological (and economic) suffering, especially in childhood and adolescence (eg abuse, neglect, and other traumatic experiences), as revealed by massive correlations between adverse childhood experiences and later substance use. The US is at or near the bottom of the developed world in its record on child welfare and child poverty. No wonder there’s an addiction problem. And how easy it is to blame doctors for causing it.

• Marc Lewis is a neuroscientist and author on addiction


Marc Lewis

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
XXXTentacion’s brutal life points to the problem with UK drug policy | Suzanne Moore
The murdered 20-year-old rapped about prescription drug addiction but we debate the merits of legalising cannabis, says the Guardian columnist Suzanne Moore

Suzanne Moore

20, Jun, 2018 @3:05 PM

Article image
Synthetic opioid use booms worldwide amid Africa 'crisis', UN says
Deaths in the US are still rising due to fentanyl addiction, but report highlights alarming take-up of painkiller tramadol in Africa

Staff and agencies

26, Jun, 2019 @12:57 AM

Article image
Meet Carl Hart: parent, Columbia professor – and heroin user
In a startling new book, Drug Use for Grown-Ups, the Ivy League professor argues that the dangers of recreational drug use have been wildly overstated

Andrew Anthony

06, Feb, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Online market 'is turning drug dealers from goons to geeks'
Customer service skills and a way with words are replacing muscles and a tough reputation, says European drugs agency

Damien Gayle

11, Feb, 2016 @1:33 PM

Article image
Will fentanyl deaths be the tipping point for our broken drugs policies? | John Harris
Synthetic opioids are an escalating tragedy, but treatment for addicts doesn’t have to be a dead end, says the Guardian columnist John Harris

John Harris

18, Feb, 2018 @5:49 PM

Article image
If Labour is really progressive, it will pledge to decriminalise drugs | Michael Segalov
Years of DIY-testing the dubious stashes of festival-goers have convinced me that urgent reform is needed to keep people safe, says freelance journalist Michael Segalov

Michael Segalov

22, Jun, 2018 @8:42 AM

Article image
I blame Fabric’s closure on this country’s backward drugs policy
After two deaths there this year, the London nightclub’s licence has been revoked. But wouldn’t it have been better to keep the venue open, and safe?

David Nutt

08, Sep, 2016 @9:07 AM

Article image
America’s opioid catastrophe has lessons for us all, about greed and racial division | Kenan Malik
Big pharma saw huge profits in medicalising the social stress of the white working class

Kenan Malik

01, Sep, 2019 @5:19 AM

Article image
Drug addiction is a tragedy. But we could stop so many people dying | Karen Tyrell
We know exactly what works to prevent drug-related deaths – and yet the numbers are still rising, says Karen Tyrell, executive director of the charity Addaction

Karen Tyrell

07, Aug, 2018 @11:15 AM

Article image
Obama unveils new federal initiative to combat America’s heroin crisis
The president traveled on Wednesday to West Virginia to detail his plan to take action on the opioid crisis that has ravaged communities across the US

Sabrina Siddiqui in Washington

21, Oct, 2015 @10:39 PM