America is still segregated. We need to be honest about why | Richard Rothstein

Little has been done to desegregate neighborhoods because we think it is the result of private prejudice instead of explicit government policy. That is a myth

Residential segregation exacerbates many national problems. In education, a black-white achievement gap persists largely because the poorest pupils are concentrated in racially homogenous schools where instruction is overwhelmed by children’s out-of-school challenges; these schools are segregated because their neighborhoods are segregated.

Growing inequality partly reflects a racial wealth gap. Middle-class white Americans are more likely to live in neighborhoods with rising home values (and thus, family equity) while their middle-class black counterparts are more likely to rent, or live in neighborhoods with stagnant values.

Hostile, sometimes fatal confrontations between police and African American youth might be rarer if the poorest young people were not concentrated in neighborhoods lacking well-resourced schools, good jobs and transportation to better opportunities. In integrated neighborhoods with substantial middle class populations, police perform as public servants, not as an occupying force.

We’ve done little to desegregate neighborhoods, believing their racial homogeneity is “de facto”, tied to private prejudice, personal choices, realtor discrimination or income differences that make middle-class suburbs unaffordable to most African Americans. Under our constitutional system, if neighborhoods are segregated by private activity, we can do little about it.

Only if neighborhoods are segregated “de jure”, by explicit government policy, is remedial action permitted. Indeed, the constitution requires remedies for de jure segregation.

In truth, de facto segregation is largely a myth. As my new book, The Color of Law, recounts, racially explicit government policy in the mid-twentieth century separated the races in every metropolitan area, with effects that endure today.

The New Deal created our first civilian public housing, intended to provide lodging mostly for lower-middle class white families during the Depression. The Roosevelt administration built a few projects for black families as well, but almost always segregated. At the time, many urban neighborhoods were integrated because workers of both races lived in walking distance of downtown factories. The Public Works Administration (PWA) demolished many such integrated neighborhoods – deemed slums – to build segregated housing instead, creating segregation where it had never before existed.

In his autobiography, The Big Sea, the poet and novelist Langston Hughes described going to high school in an integrated Cleveland neighborhood where his best friend was Polish and he dated a Jewish girl. The PWA cleared the area to build one project for whites and another for African Americans. Previously integrated neighborhoods in Cambridge, Atlanta, St Louis, San Francisco and elsewhere also gave way to segregated public housing, structuring patterns that persisted for generations.

During the second world war, white and black Americans flocked to jobs in defense plants, sometimes in communities that had no tradition of segregated living. Yet the government built separate projects for black and white citizens, determining future residential boundaries. Richmond, California, was the nation’s largest shipbuilding center. It had few African Americans before the war; by its end, some 15,000 were housed in a federal ghetto along the railroad tracks.

By the mid-1950s, projects for white Americans had many unoccupied units while those for African Americans had long waiting lists. The contrast became so conspicuous that all public housing was opened to African Americans. As industry relocated to suburbs, jobs disappeared and public housing residents became poorer. A program that originally addressed a middle-class housing shortage became a way to warehouse the poor.

Why did white housing projects develop vacancies while black ones had long waiting lists? It largely resulted from a Federal Housing Administration (FHA) program that guaranteed loans to builders of suburban subdivisions, on the explicit condition that black families be excluded and that house deeds prohibit resale to them. In the late 1940s, William Levitt could never independently have amassed capital to construct 17,000 houses in what became Levittown, east of New York City. He could do so only because the FHA relieved banks of risk in making development loans, provided homes were for whites only.

Urban public housing, originally for middle-class white Americans and later for lower-income African Americans, combined with FHA subsidized suburbanization of whites, created a “white noose” around urban black families that persists to this day.

In 1968, the Fair Housing Act permitted African Americans to access previously white neighborhoods. But it prohibited only future discrimination, without undoing the previous 35 years of government-imposed segregation. In suburbs like Levittown that sprouted nationwide in the 1940s and 50s, houses sold for about $100,000 (in today’s currency), twice the national median income.

FHA-amortized mortgages were affordable for working-class families of either race, although only whites were allowed. Today, these houses sell for $400,000, seven times national median income, unaffordable to working-class families. Meanwhile, whites who suburbanized with federal protection gained $300,000 in equity to use for children’s college tuition, care for aging parents, or medical emergencies. Black families remaining as renters gained no such security.

Our belief in “de facto” segregation is paralyzing. If our racial separation stems from millions of individual decisions, it is hard to imagine the millions of different choices that could undo it. But if we remember that residential segregation results primarily from forceful and unconstitutional government policy, we can begin to consider equally forceful public action to reverse it. Learning this history is the first step we can take.


Richard Rothstein

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Yes, America is still segregated. But there's hope in an unlikely quarter | Myron Orfield
The most integrated schools are found in America’s suburbs. That’s because they are at the cutting edge of racial, ethnic and even political change in the country

Myron Orfield

19, May, 2016 @1:00 PM

Article image
America faces a colossal college dropout problem. Here's what to do about it | David Kirp
Foster kids are often consigned to remedial classes because of weak preparation, reducing their chances of graduating – but some schools are rewriting this script

David Kirp

21, Aug, 2019 @10:00 AM

Article image
Nikole Hannah-Jones stands on the shoulders of Black intellectuals who struggled for decades | Dr Natalie Hopkinson
HBCUs have always punched above their weight while carrying a disproportionate share of the burdens of racism in the US

Dr Natalie Hopkinson

13, Jul, 2021 @7:08 PM

Article image
It’s not all about the culture war – Democrats helped shaft the working class | Robert Reich
Results in Virginia and New Jersey do not make Republican dog-whistle politics the future. The left must do more to help

Robert Reich

07, Nov, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
My elite, segregated education changed me – but not in the way you'd think
Well-meaning people tell me I’m wrong when I say my success has largely been determined by circumstance. But I’m right: it was luck that brought me here

Stephanie Jimenez

06, May, 2017 @10:00 AM

Article image
America is spiritually bankrupt. We must fight back together | Cornel West
The undeniable collapse of integrity, honesty and decency in our public and private life has fueled racial hatred and contempt

Cornel West

14, Jan, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
America is still a deeply racist country | Chris Arnade

Chris Arnade: Gone is the overt, violent, and legal racism of my childhood in the 1960s. It's been replaced by a subtler, still ugly version

Chris Arnade

12, Jan, 2014 @12:30 PM

Article image
Want to beat Trump? Learn from workers in Republican states | Eric Blanc
Americans in ‘conservative’ states are leading the fight for public education, healthcare and social services

Eric Blanc

11, Jun, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
The West Virginia teachers' strike is what real resistance looks like | Jeff Biggers
This kind of resistance does not allow onlookers to look away, especially in an age of social media. It brings the story to those who have refused to read it

Jeff Biggers

10, Mar, 2018 @3:34 PM

Article image
Confronting racism is not about the needs and feelings of white people | Ijeoma Oluo
Too often whites at discussions on race decide for themselves what will be discussed, what they will hear, what they will learn. And it is their space. All spaces are

Ijeoma Oluo

28, Mar, 2019 @6:00 AM