Demolishing the Calais camp has just made refugees’ lives harder | Clare Moseley

With food handouts banned, charities like mine face an even more heartbreaking workload. These measures go against the basic principles of humanity

The demolition of the Calais refugee camp last October did nothing to improve the lives of so many desperate refugees, who now find themselves living destitute on the streets of France and are arriving back in Calais every day. These refugees, many unaccompanied minors, are now living in far worse conditions – the latest punishment inflicted on those living in the streets being the ban on the distribution of food.

The Calais mayor supports the ban on food distribution in key areas of the town, “even if it is difficult to say so, on a human level”, according to the French press. Earlier this month, a French farmer and activist known for helping and providing shelter to refugees was given a suspended €3,000 fine for aiding illegal arrivals. In Italy a man has been prosecuted for “aiding illegal immigration” when he attempted to drive a pregnant asylum seeker and her family across the border into France.

In Paris, too, there are reports of bans on food distribution in areas of the city, as voluntary organisations are told to move on from certain places. The message is clear – refugees, and those who give up their time and resources to help them, are not welcome. Volunteers’ desire to help will now see them fined or prosecuted, as we witness the criminalisation of aiding the most vulnerable members of society.

The state is not only turning its back on those who need our support most – it can now even be criminal for the public to offer food and shelter. This is the latest in a series of austere measures that go against the basic principles of humanity.

As the charities in Calais know, food distribution points serve more than one purpose. Refugees also receive clothes and blankets from our volunteers so that they can survive the freezing nights. They are advised on asylum and immigration, and children receive crucial information about their rights. Refugees with medical issues are given the help they are denied elsewhere.

This is not the time to take a hard line on those ready to help refugees in France and Britain. The obstacles put in the way of dedicated volunteers in Calais and elsewhere highlight the role the UK should be – but is not – playing in helping those in dire need. The UK government has a moral and legal responsibility to follow the Dubs scheme, which was agreed and passed by MPs last year. Yet we have seen the government fail to honour its commitment to take in 3,000 lone children from European refugee camps, only accepting 350 under the scheme.

The UK must play its part to ensure sustainable and long-term solutions are in place for refugees, and that this humanitarian crisis does not worsen. We must not stand by as the most vulnerable people are deprived of the basic human rights to food and safety, when we have the means to help them.

Organisations such as my own, Care4Calais, provide on-the-ground, life-saving support to refugees, and estimate that up to 200 are sleeping rough on the streets of Calais. Every day, our volunteers are confronted with heartbreaking moments when refugees share their hopes for a better life. They see Calais as a springboard to a safer home. Many want to reach Britain as their final destination – some because they have family there; while others have fought with the British army in Afghanistan.

Charities warned the authorities that the demolition of the Calais camp would never be a long-term, sustainable solution to this crisis. The past few months have proved us right. Demolition was not a deterrent to refugees who, by definition, have no choice but to flee their homes; rather, it caused them to live in worse squalor on the streets of the town.

The reason charities such as Care4Calais still exist and work hard every day is that the government’s argument about pull factors has been proved wrong. When fleeing war or persecution, it does not matter if refugees are fleeing to a camp haphazardly housing thousands, or a town that criminalises helping them. Anything is better than the prospect of death.

Demolishing the camp has not caused refugees to stop striving for a better life, and nor will banning volunteers from providing them with vital necessities. It will just cause more unnecessary suffering to those in need. It is our collective responsibility to secure the dignity and future of those who depend on us.


Clare Moseley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
I work with child refugees in Calais. Theresa May’s deception is a cruel act | Benny Hunter
The Dubs children abandoned by Britain now sleep under bushes, at the mercy of people smugglers and riot police. This is how we care for their best interests

Benny Hunter

09, Feb, 2017 @1:59 PM

Article image
The child refugees I help in Calais remind me of the boy rescued in Aleppo | Clare Moseley
Since the donations fell away, we’ve been running out of many vital things. But what the camp children need most is hope

Clare Moseley

19, Aug, 2016 @8:30 AM

Article image
People who welcome refugees are the true British patriots | Abi Wilkinson
Forget the nasty headlines. What makes me proud to be British are the nurses, charity workers and volunteers working to help those seeking sanctuary on our shores

Abi Wilkinson

19, Oct, 2016 @2:57 PM

Article image
Calais minors lured from camp then abandoned by authorities
UK and France accused of breaching human rights as children forced to sleep in makeshift conditions for second night

Lisa O'Carroll in Calais, Amelia Gentleman and Alan Travis in London

27, Oct, 2016 @7:47 PM

Article image
Hundreds of Calais child refugees have UK asylum claims rejected
Home Office criticised over failure to give written reasons for decision as children are advised to lodge applications in France

Diane Taylor

16, Dec, 2016 @6:32 PM

Article image
Calais camp demolition begins as charities call for protection of minors
Crews move in with diggers and electric saws as Unicef UK says it is ‘unacceptable’ for process to start while children remain

Alan Travis, Lisa O'Carroll in Calais and Caroline Davies

25, Oct, 2016 @6:14 PM

Article image
UK to take small group of children from Calais refugee camp
French officials say Britain has agreed no ‘deal for larger-scale plan’ but will accept 20 unaccompanied minors this week

Jasper Jackson and agencies

16, Oct, 2016 @4:22 PM

Article image
France and UK rush to process Calais minors as camp demolition nears
Charities fear children could get caught up in ‘herding’ of adult migrants on to buses when dismantling of refugee camp begins

Alexandra Topping, Angelique Chrisafis and Lisa O'Carroll

23, Oct, 2016 @7:24 PM

Article image
For the Calais refugees, this is the destruction of hope as well as home | Maria Margaronis
Razing the Calais camp will serve politics – but not, as I saw in Greece, the needs of people on the move

Maria Margaronis

25, Oct, 2016 @3:51 PM

Article image
House of Lords votes to let lone child refugees come to Britain
Peers warn that government must act fast amid complaints about conditions endured by child migrants in Calais

Amelia Gentleman and Karen McVeigh

21, Mar, 2016 @8:42 PM