Al-Jazeera gave Arab youth a voice. Gulf regimes must not silence it | Wadah Khanfar

The network gave young people the chance to express themselves freely. No wonder Saudi Arabia and its allies now demand it is closed down

Many states at different times have tried to contain al-Jazeera or force it to tone down its coverage. But with last week’s call to shut the network down, the Saudis and Emiratis have surpassed themselves.

The demand, one of a list of conditions put forward by Saudi Arabia and its Gulf allies as the price for ending their embargo of Qatar, which funds the broadcaster, is an attempt to suffocate the Middle East and to kill off the last hope for a stable, democratic future.

Al-Jazeera, where I served as director general from 2006 to 2011, has never been loved by the leaders of the so-called free world. Its bureaux have been bombed twice by US forces, once during the Afghanistan war and the second time during the Iraq war, when a correspondent in Baghdad was killed and others injured. More than 20 journalists working for the network have been arrested in Iraq by coalition forces. At one point in the Iraq war, George Bush and Tony Blair reportedly disagreed over whether to bomb the headquarters in Doha.

But the most consistent attacks on al-Jazeera have come from authoritarian Arab regimes. Al-Jazeera’s bureaux have been shut down, journalists arrested and imprisoned on trumped up charges, and the signal has been jammed.

Every attempt has been made to smear and defame the network – even mutually contradictory ones: we were told that al-Jazeera was not only the creation of Israel’s Mossad but also the mouthpiece of Osama bin Laden. It can’t be both. Of course, all this backfired. The more al-Jazeera was attacked by venal and vicious Arab rulers, the more it was valued by their people as a source of news.

The network also acted as a bridge to the western media world, with al-Jazeera English providing a fresh perspective. It connected people at the perceived periphery of the world to the decision-makers at its centre. And – so far – it has never responded to intimidation. You may love al-Jazeera or hate it, but you can’t deny that it has changed the media landscape in the Arab world.

While both the Saudis and the Emiratis have launched channels to rival al-Jazeera, it has continued to be the most trusted source of news in the Arab world because of an editorial spirit nurtured by a qualified team of journalists in a region saturated with poorly presented government-sponsored propaganda.

The current demand to shut down al-Jazeera is best understood as a punishment for the network’s role in the Arab spring. The countries led by Saudi Arabia, that supported the counter-revolution, would feel more secure if it was closed down.

Their mistake is their failure to understand that it was not because of al-Jazeera that young people marched for freedom and democracy in the streets of Tunis and Cairo. On the contrary, it was because of the absence of more al-Jazeeras. If the region’s youth had more independent platforms on which to express their views , they would have found ways to reform their societies without the need to revolt. Shutting down the network, imprisoning those who dare to express their opinions through social media, are exactly the kind of actions most likely to provoke a new, violent version of the Arab spring.

Yes, I am the first to admit that there is and always has been an element of advocacy about al-Jazeera’s role. Its reporting opened the minds of a generation of Arab young people. It told them their voices matter and gave them freedom and hope. For the first time, through al-Jazeera, that generation felt connected to the rest of the world. Those young, open-minded and non-sectarian people were the heart of the Arab spring, which was the brightest moment in recent Arab history.

The demand to shut down the network, to turn off this light, is nothing less than a declaration of war against the future of the region. This is a deadly serious fight. The ancien regime of absolute monarchs and military dictators is making its last stand against the forces of democracy and freedom, spearheaded by a generation that has thrown off the shackles of corrupt, clientielist regimes.

Imagine an Arab world without al-Jazeera. It would be a darker, more grim, and above all more silent place.


Wadah Khanfar

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Al-Jazeera, insurgent TV station that divides the Arab world, faces closure
The network has raised political awareness across the Middle East. No wonder Qatar’s conservative enemies want it shut down

Hugh Miles

01, Jul, 2017 @11:16 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on al-Jazeera: muzzling journalism | Editorial
Editorial: In the Arab world, freedom of speech is being curbed to stop old and new media from raising questions about the way in which countries are run. This is wrong


23, Jun, 2017 @5:55 PM

Article image
The blockade of Qatar is a move against the values of the Arab spring | Wadah Khanfar
The pretext offered was to cut the funding of terrorist groups. Yet the most significant demand had nothing to do with this: it was to close down al-Jazeera

Wadah Khanfar

08, Jun, 2017 @6:58 PM

Article image
Hackers target al-Jazeera as Qatar crisis deepens
Move targeting kingdom’s major broadcaster comes amid diplomatic standoff with fellow Arab states

Staff and agencies

08, Jun, 2017 @5:50 PM

Article image
Anti-Qatar alliance renews attack on al-Jazeera Arabic
UAE says TV station gives platforms to terrorists and should be controlled, as US tries to mediate in Saudi Arabia on regional crisis

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

12, Jul, 2017 @5:19 PM

Article image
Saudi Arabia’s role in success of al-Jazeera | Letters
Letters: Saudis’ sudden closure of BBC Arabic channel gave Qatar pick of more than 150 talented BBC-trained Arab presenters, writers, producers and technicians


25, Jun, 2017 @5:46 PM

Article image
The deceit of ageing Arab regimes won't stop al-Jazeera | Wadah Khanfar
Wadah Khanfar: Arab regimes' attempts to discredit al-Jazeera only highlight the honesty of the new people's media

Wadah Khanfar

15, Jun, 2011 @8:30 PM

Article image
The Arab spring has shaken Arab TV's credibility | Ali Hashem
Ali Hashem: Their biased coverage is undermining viewers' faith in the Middle Eastern satellite channels that sprang up in the 1990s and 2000s

Ali Hashem

03, Apr, 2012 @12:23 PM

Article image
Revealed: how abusive texts led to discovery of hacking of Al Jazeera
Threatening messages led to monitoring of phone that unearthed evidence of cyber-attack against Qatar-based network

Michael Safi and Jassar Al-Tahat

22, Dec, 2020 @12:34 PM

Article image
Al-Jazeera has lost its head – but will it lose its spirit? | Hugh Miles
Hugh Miles: Waddah Khanfar took the network from strength to strength. His royal replacement puts a strain on its independence

Hugh Miles

22, Sep, 2011 @5:24 PM