The Guardian view on Northern Ireland: there may be trouble ahead | Editorial

A political crisis amid the churn of Brexit should see politicians face up to the real problems in the province. Unfortunately there is no sign that they want to

The sudden decision by Sinn Féin’s Martin McGuinness to step down as deputy first minister looks almost certain to capsize Northern Ireland’s assembly. His departure is the latest in a series of political dramas which have deepened a crisis building in the province for weeks. The scandal over a flawed renewable heating scheme, which will leave taxpayers facing a bill of at least £400m, has smouldered since February. But it erupted when it emerged that Arlene Foster, now the Democratic Unionist first minister but in 2013 the person in charge of the initiative, had been contacted by a whistleblower over its serious flaws. These warnings went unheeded and the scheme was extended, increasing the liability for the taxpayer. Costs ran out of control because they were not capped.

With an insouciance bordering on arrogance, Mrs Foster dismissed critics, saying she could not expect as minister to know every “jot and tittle” of the unsound scheme. Although it was the smaller parties – particularly the Alliance party – that identified Mrs Foster’s clear conflict of interest, it was left to Mr McGuinness, a former IRA commander, to deliver the coup de grace to the present administration. With fractious exchanges between the DUP and Sinn Féin, the two largest parties in the assembly, little is being done to promote the trust and cooperation that is essential to making power-sharing work. In words and deeds both parties are putting a decade of the peace process, which has brought so many improvements to Northern Ireland (including a reduction in terrorist murders), at risk. It is clear that Mrs Foster should have stepped down as first minister while an investigation was carried out, as Sinn Féin and others demanded. Instead, she accused her opponents – who were male and female – of misogyny and of “playing chicken”. This tough-talking no doubt plays well with certain sections of a unionist audience, but it is extremely foolhardy to call for an election, as Mrs Foster did, when the government of the province should be engaged with preventing a calamitous outcome from Brexit on issues such as immigration and trade.

The worry is a resurgence of a tribalism that rests upon a counsel of fears. Sinn Féin will be tempted to play its nationalist cards – not least to ward off attacks from the leftwing People Before Profit which won seats in its heartlands. Mr McGuinness is not in the best of health. If elections do now come early, as seems likely, he may not return to Stormont. Given his popularity, this could be a seismic shift in Sinn Féin’s leadership. For the DUP, there is a question about the biggest party trading in zero-sum politics which hinder reconciliation. Mrs Foster blocked funding to deal with inquests into the most controversial killings of the Troubles, a move criticised by the province’s senior judge. Packaged as a way of preventing the hearings being skewed against the state it was a decision made with an eye on unionist votes. Just before Christmas the DUP cut bursaries for poor Irish language students a few months after funding marching bands patronised mainly by unionists. It is in nobody’s interests to see the collapse of the assembly that has taken years to build. The electorate, if given the chance, should reject identity politics and cast their votes on the substantive issues facing the part of the UK with the highest levels of deprivation, unemployment and poverty.

Contributor

Editorial

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on the Northern Ireland election: vote to keep the border soft | Editorial
Editorial: The assembly elections on 2 March were not necessary. But they give voters the opportunity to demand fresh thinking about Brexit’s impact on the Irish border

Editorial

19, Feb, 2017 @6:38 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Karen Bradley’s task in Northern Ireland: three months to stop the drift | Editorial
Editorial: Theresa May’s focus on Brexit has been bad for Northern Ireland. It is time to get the peace process working once more

Editorial

09, Jan, 2018 @7:31 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Northern Ireland assembly election: a warning to Brexit Britain | Editorial
Editorial: The usual parties finished in the usual order in the 2 March election. But Arlene Foster’s obduracy and the UK’s vote to leave the EU threaten a period of fresh instability

Editorial

05, Mar, 2017 @7:13 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Northern Ireland: no budging, no budget | Editorial
Editorial: The Stormont standoff is not just another no-surrender rerun. Brexit has created new disruptions to the peace process

Editorial

01, Nov, 2017 @7:32 PM

Northern Ireland: Ulster's real deal
Editorial: In the end, it is a tribute to the robustness of the peace process, and to the prosperity which it has delivered, that the DUP has finally agreed to a deal on the devolution of Northern Ireland policing and justice

Editorial

06, Feb, 2010 @12:06 AM

Article image
Northern Ireland forms new power-sharing executive
Independent unionist appointed as justice minister, while seven other Stormont posts are shared between DUP and Sinn Féin

Henry McDonald Ireland correspondent

25, May, 2016 @5:16 PM

Article image
Sinn Féin ​refusal to replace McGuinness set to trigger Northern Ireland elections
After PM holds talks with Northern Ireland leaders, first minister Arlene Foster says Sinn Féin is forcing new election

Henry McDonald and Peter Walker

16, Jan, 2017 @1:47 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the DUP: back to the past | Editorial
Editorial: Northern Ireland has a new executive. But unionism’s main party seems to be reverting to protest, not power

Editorial

17, Jun, 2021 @6:18 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on dual mandates: double trouble in Northern Ireland | Editorial
Editorial: Brandon Lewis’s piecemeal approach is all too typical of this government’s preference for political manipulation

Editorial

20, Jan, 2022 @6:29 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Tory government: coalition of chaos | Editorial
Editorial: A blistering attack from a former PM, ministerial resignations and moves to soften Brexit all feature in another extraordinary day at Westminster

Editorial

13, Jun, 2017 @6:45 PM