Yes, Ceta is a gold-standard trade deal – for North America’s corporations | Stuart Trew

The Canada–European Union deal, spun as a victory for EU workers, is TTIP via the back door. Shame on Europe’s social democrats if they endorse it

There was a point in 2016 when it seemed the Canada–European Union free trade deal – Ceta – was not going to make it. Ironically, Donald Trump’s election as president of the United States has all but assured its approval in Europe. Resistance to Ceta, which had been building quietly in Europe for several years, exploded into massive street protests in Germany and Brussels in the middle of 2016. The lightning rod was the inclusion of rights for investors to challenge public policies that harm their profits.

But other parts of Ceta were rightly criticised for how they would weaken the precautionary principle and undermine public services. These concerns, and studies showing the agreement would suppress wage and job growth on both sides of the Atlantic, should have sucked the air out of any promises of a new, sustainable trade regime. And yet, in this upside-down post-Trump world, an agreement that will contribute to widening inequality is being spun, impossibly, as a victory for progress. An agreement negotiated by Stephen Harper’s government (one of the most rightwing Canada has ever seen) on behalf of, and with input mainly from, very large corporations, will be declared a major boon for the struggling middle class.

Justin Trudeau, Canada’s prime minister, plans to be in Strasbourg next week for the European parliament vote – to give Ceta a final Midas touch that will transform it from political hot potato to “gold standard” trade deal. Unfortunately, in its current form Ceta will only fuel Trumpism and its European variants on the far-right.

Despite some last-minute procedural reforms, Ceta will eventually expose European regulations to more investor lawsuits from Canadian resource firms and the Canadian subsidiaries of US multinational corporations, ushering in, through the back door, a hated part of TTIP, the supposedly moribund EU-US free trade deal. Ceta also advances a longstanding North American demand for “regulatory cooperation”, a euphemism for an early warning system that allows foreign corporations to nip unwanted regulations in the bud. The election of Trump, who is already unleashing a deregulatory tsunami in the US, only heightens the threat this new framework poses.

Far from acting as a counterweight to Trump, the Canadian corporate sector is already pressing the Trudeau government to match the US president’s deregulatory moves in order to remain competitive in their most important market. Ceta’s regulatory cooperation mechanisms will provide an avenue for North American lobbyists to quietly deploy downward pressure against EU regulations. This is particularly true in sensitive areas such as genetically modified organisms and endocrine-disrupting chemicals, where Canada and the US have continually challenged the EU diplomatically and at the World Trade Organisation.

Ceta also fails to live up to its “gold standard” hype for what is missing from the agreement. Despite what the European commission says about its hastily cobbled together “understanding” on Ceta, the text contains no valid general carve-out for public services, which are shielded from Ceta’s powerful investment and services obligations only grudgingly and in a piecemeal manner.

On our side of the pond, Ceta forces Canada to change its patent protection system in ways that are expected to add C$850m a year to the costs of medications. Canadians already pay the second-highest drug costs per capita in the developed world. Ceta’s stricter intellectual property rules will more than cancel out the potential benefits to Canadian consumers of tariff elimination on all EU imports into Canada.

As Thomas Piketty and others have highlighted, the Canada-EU deal also contains no binding targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. In fact, Ceta hardly mentions climate change at all. Its protections for labour, the environment and sustainable development are essentially toothless. European social democrats should be ashamed to endorse them, let alone portray them as a victory for workers.

Environmentalists, consumer advocates, trade unions, political progressives and many small- and medium-sized enterprises, on the other hand, are right to ask the European parliament to block this Canadian deal. With Ceta the idea of “social Europe” – the cooperative, progressive counterpoint to a union organised primarily for the benefit of transnational capital – recedes further into the imagination.

The rebranding of Ceta as a progressive, “gold standard” agreement is hardly an antidote to the frightening resurgence of rightwing nationalism that preys on the inequalities and insecurities created by the type of globalisation that is codified and enforced in Ceta’s two-dozen chapters. It is precisely that type of self-serving spin that fuels public cynicism and anger at liberal elites. If one of the lessons of the Brexit vote is that too many citizens feel they are losing control over their lives and economic futures, then sleepwalking into a trade deal that will cede even more democratic authority to the corporate sector is playing with fire.

• This piece was co-authored by Scott Sinclair, a senior research fellow at the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives


Stuart Trew

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Think TTIP is a threat to democracy? There’s another trade deal that’s already signed | Nick Dearden
If you needed proof that trade agreements are just an excuse to hand big business power at our expense, look no further than Ceta, a deal between the EU and Canada

Nick Dearden

30, May, 2016 @8:58 AM

Article image
Who really benefits from free trade agreements like TTIP, Ceta and Nafta? | Letters
Letters: The unfettered free trade we have now, based largely upon who can pay least to those producing our goods, is not fair trade. It has run its course


15, Nov, 2016 @7:01 PM

Article image
The transatlantic trade deal TTIP may be dead, but something even worse is coming | George Monbiot
Governments and corporate lobbyists keep inventing new ways to embed privatisation and circumvent democracy – in this case, the Canada-EU deal

George Monbiot

06, Sep, 2016 @6:23 PM

Article image
You thought TTIP was dead? With Brexit we’ll get the same thing, on steroids | Nick Dearden
The most extreme free-market fundamentalists in Europe are now in the driver’s seat in Britain. That’s what ‘taking back control’ looks like in practice

Nick Dearden

08, Jul, 2016 @12:25 PM

Article image
Belgian politicians drop opposition to EU-Canada trade deal
EU leaders hope deal will be signed as Belgian PM says leaders of five regional parliaments have reached an agreement

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

27, Oct, 2016 @4:05 PM

Article image
EU-Canada trade deal in crisis as Canadian minister walks out
President of European parliament makes last-ditch bid to save talks as Chrystia Freeland announces ‘failure’ of Ceta over Wallonia objections

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels with agencies

22, Oct, 2016 @2:17 AM

Article image
EU-Canada free trade deal at risk after Belgian regional parliament vote
Wallonia parliament passes resolution against CETA, which requires unanimous agreement of all 28 EU member states

Jennifer Rankin

14, Oct, 2016 @3:20 PM

Article image
Walloons make a good point about free trade | Letters
Letters: It’s not surprising that the EU is facing such a crisis of legitimacy when such backroom deals cooked up with big business lobbyists are foisted on the public without proper consultation


25, Oct, 2016 @6:48 PM

Article image
Wallonia blocked a harmful EU trade deal – but we don’t share Trump’s dreams | Paul Magnette
Thanks to our action over the Canada deal, the EU will have to listen to the desire for a world where trade doesn’t come before everything

Paul Magnette

14, Nov, 2016 @8:59 AM

Article image
'Ball in Europe's court' to rescue Ceta deal, says Canada trade minister
Chrystia Freeland says Canada ready to sign and hopes to return with Justin Trudeau if EU can persuade Wallonia to lift block

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels, with agencies

22, Oct, 2016 @11:23 AM