Manxiety needs fempathy: in defence of mansplaining | Victoria Coren Mitchell

Actually, chaps, we women do know stuff, yet if explaining things keeps you happy, do carry on

It made me feel sentimental to see “mansplaining” in the news again. Did you read the story? Actually, there have been two: the first was that Unionen, Sweden’s largest trade union, has launched a mansplaining hotline for women to phone if they’ve been a victim of male condescension.

Oh, with what shivers of nostalgia this took me back. Back, back, back to the salad days of, ooh, 2013 it must have been, when I first heard the term.

It was pretty obvious what it meant, though somebody (probably a man) told me anyway: mansplaining is when a male explains something to a female in unnecessary detail, often a female who understands it better than he does. I was familiar with the phenomenon, of course. Every woman has had simple things explained to her at interminable length by a man. That’s just basic social interaction.

Of course it’s annoying; nobody likes to be treated like a fool. Of course it’s boring; nobody likes to be lectured. But still, how wistfully I remember the luxury of being troubled by that sort of thing, in the long-lost idyll of 2013.

Do you remember what troubled you back then? On the world stage, I mean. You may have struggled – may still struggle – with all sorts of private worries: a medical trauma, a row at work, a harrowing debt. The way your wife runs out of the room giggling when her phone bleeps late at night. That weird recurrent dream you have about a marrow festival.

But the things we worried about generally, in 2013… my word, I spent serious time worrying about whether the 500-year-old remains of Richard III should be buried in York or Leicester! Those were the bloody days.

Have we really got time and space, now, to kvetch about whether men talk to women in a patronising way? With all the other wars that threaten to wage?

The truth is, I don’t think mansplaining is even sexist. I don’t think men reserve a patronising tone for women alone. It’s just how they talk.

In the original essay Men Explain Things To Me (which, although not actually coining the zeitgeisty word, is credited with being the core identifier of the tendency), author Rebecca Solnit writes about a man who lectured her on the subject of one of her own published books.

Because he employed the sort of painstaking, long-winded detail that Solnit herself would only use if giving instructions to an idiot, she assumed the man thought she was an idiot. But the point that I think has been missed by Solnit – and by all the women who have written and talked about mansplaining ever since – is: men also talk this way to each other. It’s not that they don’t defer to women. It’s that they don’t defer to anyone.

Men simply love explaining things. That is what men want to do in conversation: make jokes and explain things. Your average man would be happy to tell Gareth Southgate how to manage the England football team, or the head of MI6 how to deal with Isis, or Stephen Hawking what he reckons about black holes.

It isn’t about the person they’re talking to – it’s about themselves. If anything, the inclination could be seen as a compliment. They offer their nuggets of wisdom as gifts, like a cat offers a half-eaten bird.

That doesn’t mean there is no danger in the mansplaining tendency. Many of the world’s problems can probably be traced to the way men take this approach into government, filling the atmosphere with a load of hot, unschooled certainty. I suspect we’d be better off if we all reached consensus by respecting others’ opinions and experience.

But socially no harm is meant by it. Men would be terribly sad if they were told they must never explain anything again. They get so much pleasure from being expansive, from chewing over their thoughts, sharing a bit of half-remembered fact or quote, airing a little aperçu that occurred to them when driving along the M6. And sometimes it is properly informative or enjoyable.

That is Christmas, for most men: sipping a tasty drink, reaching for the nutcrackers and settling in for a good long disquisition on why it rains or what’s wrong with modern television or whither North Korea.

And, if you ask me, the biggest problem facing our western world at the moment is the decline of kindness. As huge differences of opinion batter against each other, we forget to be gentle and careful with each other’s dreams, respectful of each other’s self-worth.

It means a lot to your poor old dad, uncle, colleague, husband or friend to offer his advice and insights. Sitting there, mug or glass clutched eagerly in hand, looking forward to holding forth… how much do you really want to see him quiet and disappointed, confronting his own limitations? How much do you want to shout: “Nobody gives a shit, Granddad! You pompous old bore! Let’s talk about me!”? How much are you actually reduced if you let him feel listened to?

At the start of this column, I said there had been two recent stories about mansplaining. The first was that the 600,000-strong Unionen has launched a mansplaining hotline.

And the second, which followed soon after, is that the majority of calls to the hotline have been from men: anxious, self-doubting men, asking exactly what mansplaining is and how to avoid doing it.

Beware of throwing your ire at the wrong target. It’s so easy to get angry about things. Too easy. We get distracted from what’s actually important, dissipating our energy with the wrong fights.

Women don’t want to be silenced by men. But I don’t think the answer is for us to silence them in return.


Victoria Coren Mitchell

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A new low in mansplaining – menopause as a metaphor for a failing economy | Catherine Bennett
The bank’s deputy governor is guilty of idiocy and misogyny. Sadly, he’s not alone

Catherine Bennett

20, May, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Is architecture at last breaking through its own glass ceiling? | Rowan Moore
A welcome gold award, and now the RIBA has begun to recognise that what matters is the team

Rowan Moore

05, Oct, 2019 @6:00 PM

Article image
Welcome to libertarian Covid fantasy land – that’s Sweden to you and me | Nick Cohen
The right fails to recognise that the Swedes’ real virtue in this pandemic is their social cohesion

Nick Cohen

26, Sep, 2020 @6:00 PM

Article image
Sweden’s Covid-19 policy is a model for the right. It’s also a deadly folly | Nick Cohen
The Swedes were the Brexiters’ poster nation, but now have Europe’s worst death rate

Nick Cohen

23, May, 2020 @5:00 PM

Article image
Europeans watch our referendum debate with fascination and fear | Hans Kundnani, Ylva Elvis Nilsson and Maria Torrens Tillack
We asked leading commentators in Germany, Sweden and Spain to assess attitudes in their countries to Brexit

Hans Kundnani, Ylva Elvis Nilsson and Maria Torrens Tillack

23, Apr, 2016 @11:05 PM

Article image
It’s not only in Ireland that we need a new view on abortion | Sarah Ditum
Dublin might be preparing for change, but in Poland and elsewhere women’s rights are under threat

Sarah Ditum

04, Feb, 2018 @12:05 AM

Article image
After Ireland’s abortion vote, where does the Catholic church go now? | Catherine Pepinster
Even in the face of declining authority and observance, the church still has much to offer

Catherine Pepinster

03, Jun, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Observer view on the global threat to access to abortion |Observer editorial
Women’s reproductive rights are under widespread threat, not least in America. This is no time for complacency

Observer editorial

20, May, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Stella Creasy’s abortion law campaign showed practical politics at its bestt | Helen Lewis
Courteous, attentive and largely free of partisan posturing, the debate on Northern Ireland’s law was a triumph of cross-party collaboration

Helen Lewis

10, Jun, 2018 @11:00 AM

Article image
Is the idea of ‘real women’ just another way of selling stuff? | Yvonne Roberts
Magazines are making promises – and progress – but they’re still selling impossible dreams

Yvonne Roberts

18, May, 2019 @4:00 PM