Who are this new breed of Russian football fans? | Mary Dejevsky

The fighting at Euro 2016 in Marseille was initially blamed on English hooligans then Russian thugs. Perhaps it’s best seen as a regrettable stage in the evolution of sporting self-assertion

Watching the story, and the images on television of football hooliganism from Marseille unfold between Friday night and Monday morning was hardly an uplifting experience, not least because of how one version so quickly eviscerated all the others.

The early pictures and the commentary that went with them told of the shameful return to vintage form of the England football team’s travelling supporters. Here we were, so it seemed, right back in the 1980s: the early-morning drinking, the trashing of businesses and the outbreaks of hand-to-hand combat between our flabby white islanders and the tougher, fitter natives – in this case, some of the hard men of the sprawling Marseille gangland.

By Saturday afternoon, however, a new warrior detachment entered the fray in the shape of the Russians, as pale as the English, but demonstrably fitter and better equipped. And in the aftermath of the actual match – though it is hard to recall now that two national teams playing football was the point of the whole exercise – things really kicked off, when the Russians clambered over barriers to ambush their foes in the stadium.

There was a sense – baffling to those of us unversed in match lore – that starting the fighting while still in the stadium was unfair and that the French police, condemned for overzealousness outside the ground, had now been asleep on the job. But suddenly the English were the victims. Their excesses of the previous 24 hours were forgotten in the headlong rush to blame the Russians. Not only had their team had the nerve to score a late equaliser, but their fans’ brand of quasi-military thuggishness, including inside the ground, had apparently broken some unwritten rule.

England fans embroiled in third day of violence in Marseille

At least the head of Britain’s Euro 2016 policing operation, Mark Roberts, seemed to think so. But I wonder how different their “tooling up” and their “sort of uniforms” really are from features of our own footballing past. Those of us who just about recall Millwall supporters at the height of their notoriety or the sharp suits and fighting prowess of Chelsea’s Headhunters will perhaps not be as shocked as we should have been. (A gentler breed of Chelsea fans now wear fur hats in a nod to their Russian owner.)

But the whole thing only reinforced – among Britons, at least – the stereotype of Russians as no-holds-barred barbarians. Their discipline and organisation also suggested an extra layer of militarism – a reminder, as it were, of Russia’s operations not so long ago in Ukraine.

What is more, in some of their chanting, it appeared the Russians were also putting two fingers up, not just to their England footballing rivals, but also to Europe. The damage was compounded when Igor Lebedev, a Russian national football official and MP, said it was normal for fans to fight and even egged them on. “Well done lads,” he tweeted, “keep it up!”

In all this, however, it is worth considering the wider context. The first is that Lebedev is a member of the nationalist LDP. The Russian sports minister, Vitaly Mutko, struck a different tone and condemned the violence, saying the fans had “brought shame on their country”. Russia’s hosting of the 2018 World Cup, he would have been aware – is not uncontested.

The second is that 30 years ago it would have been almost unthinkable for Russian sports fans to travel; even 20 years ago, it was still a novelty to get a passport and foreign travel was expensive. It is only recently that costs have come down; freedom to travel is more positive than negative, even if some undesirable elements take advantage.

And the third is that what fuels the violence of – some of – today’s Russian football supporters may not be a million miles from the wellspring that feeds the excesses of some England fans. A frustration with their lot at home, and an identification with the national team that makes every triumph and defeat an extension of their own ambitions. Plus, most of these young Russian men will have military experience, as conscription is only starting to be phased out.

During a journalistic trip to Moscow in the early 2000s, I met an aide to the relatively new President Putin, whose tasks included trying to devise ways of fostering a new sense of national pride among citizens who saw the collapse of the Soviet Union as a humiliating defeat. At one point, the official delved into a side cupboard and pulled out a bag. Inside was a “kit” for Russian football fans. It included a T-shirt with the Russian flag and crest, a baseball cap emblazoned with “Rossiya”, a sheet with the words to the (first post-Soviet) national anthem, and a small Russian flag.

The “kit” was almost sweet in its innocence, and much has happened since then. Now Russia has been fined €150,000 and has been told any further violence will result in its disqualification. But the apparently new breed of Russian football fan in action in Marseille may be better understood as a regrettable stage in the evolution of sporting self-assertion, than as the vicious shape of things to come.

Contributor

Mary Dejevsky

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
If we cast all football fans as thugs, only the hooligans win | Zoe Williams
From Hillsborough to Marseille, supporters are stripped of their dignity by the same old mass misrepresentation that they’re all as bad as each other

Zoe Williams

12, Jun, 2016 @3:14 PM

Article image
I was in Marseille and I know: all England fans bear some blame for the football violence | Tom Walker
Those intent on trouble may be few. But it’s the ‘respectable’ majority who breathe malevolence into the game. It’s time to grow up and show some respect

Tom Walker

16, Jun, 2016 @11:36 AM

Article image
Russian hooligans were savage and organised, say England fans
Some were disguised in English club shirts and equipped with gumshields and truncheons for violence in Marseille

Daniel Boffey in Marseille

12, Jun, 2016 @2:37 PM

Article image
Britain's Euro 2016 police chief lambasts 'tooled up' Russian fans
Assistant chief constable Mark Roberts says some supporters wore gum shields during clashes with England fans in Marseille

Daniel Boffey in Marseille

12, Jun, 2016 @7:48 PM

Article image
Russian officials blame security for problems and praise fighting fans
Russian officials have played down the violence over the weekend in Marseille – and in some cases even praised the fans involved – while denying a contingent travelled specifically to fight England supporters

Shaun Walker in Moscow

13, Jun, 2016 @9:00 PM

Article image
Euro 2016: Russia rolls back support of violence as deportation process begins
Dmitry Peskov, Vladimir Putin’s spokesman, has said statements from colleagues supporting the actions of Russia fans ‘don’t reflect the official point of view in any way’

Shaun Walker in Moscow

14, Jun, 2016 @9:02 AM

Article image
Clashes of England and Russia fans in Marseille exposes failure of planning | Barney Ronay
The violence was committed by a small, toxic minority of English and Russian fans, but the authorities in Marseille failed miserably with everything from the scheduling to the policing

Barney Ronay in Marseille

12, Jun, 2016 @10:09 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Russian football hooligans: politics at play | Editorial
Editorial: Whether it encouraged it or not, Putin’s regime is trying to capitalise on the violence of its football fans – as another ingredient of its clash with the west

Editorial

16, Jun, 2016 @6:57 PM

Article image
Euro 2016: notorious far-right activist at tournament with Russian FA delegation
Alexander Shprygin, travelling to Euro 2016 with the official Russian FA delegation, is considered by the Fare network to be a leading light among extreme-right ultra fan groups

Owen Gibson in Paris and Shaun Walker in Moscow

13, Jun, 2016 @8:27 PM

Article image
Whitehall fears Russian football hooligans had Kremlin links
UK government: we suspect many of those who attacked England supporters are in Russia’s uniformed services, fighting Putin’s ‘hybrid warfare’

Daniel Boffey Policy Editor

18, Jun, 2016 @7:53 PM