Negative interest rates? Deflation risks mean they could be here to stay

Australia avoided quantitative easing thanks to Labor’s stimulus, but for other countries it has become the norm and now more rate cuts are a possibility

Policy experiments continue to be a feature of the global economy with the European Central Bank and Bank of Japan moving official interest rates below zero. This follows the earlier radical decisions of the US Federal Reserve and Bank of England to engage in quantitative easing, which in effect dumped cash into the banking system in the hope that some of the excess money would flow to the private sector and be invested, spent and drive economic growth.

With inflation very low and commodity prices in freefall, these policy experiments have been low risk and, importantly, successful. The global economy not only avoided the Great Depression scenarios that were bandied about as the banking system ground to a halt, but 2016 is set to be the eighth year since the crisis where global GDP growth has been above 3%.

In Australia, there has been no such radical monetary policy. Although rates have found a floor at at 2%, RBA governor Glenn Stevens said on Friday that there was room to cut the cost of borrowing if the turmoil on global markets spilled over to Australia and QE remains a remote prospect.

One reason for the RBA being out of step is that Australia has relied on other policy and market mechanisms to manage the economy and avoid recession.

When the financial crisis hit hard in late 2008, the Australian government had the foresight and pragmatism to aggressively use fiscal policy to manage the economy. While the Rudd government handed $10bn straight to households, other countries’ attempts at fiscal stimulus were dogged by already wide budget deficits, relative high levels of government debt and political considerations. The roadblocks to stimulus led in some cases to tightening fiscal policy into a recessionary economy.

The consequences, especially in the eurozone, were dire. Unemployment spiked into double digits and fears of deflation escalated. Those concerns persist today which is why negative interest rates and QE remain the base case of the bulk of the global economy.

The deflation fears have some credence. Most importantly, there appears to be a huge amount of spare capacity in labour markets. This means that wages growth will remain subdued and the wage/price linkage will skew inflation risks squarely to the down side.

At the same time, the weakness in most commodity prices is lowering input costs to the production process. With energy costs near a decade-low and many raw materials prices also floundering under the weight of a glut of global production, firms can maintain profits even if they lower prices simply because input costs are falling.

If the macroeconomic consequences of digital disruption are added to the picture, deflation risks are compounded. In other words, the pressures on inflation are widespread and could be spreading to the point where they spill over to deflation.

Which comes back to the first point. Easy monetary policy with a mix of negative interest rates and QE is not all that surprising. It is unusual, to be sure, and conventional economics text books rarely, if ever, note the issues surrounding negative interest rates. But if inflation is very low and the risk of crossing the line below zero builds, counter-cyclical monetary policy requires interest rates to be cut and cut and cut, even if that means moving them well below zero.

Many are still grappling with the notion of negative interest rates. They have never been seen until recently, but who’s to say that if deflation does materialise, central banks won’t cut rates to -1% or -2%?

It would be unusual and unconventional, but entirely appropriate if deflation was to emerge as a serious risk.

Stephen Koukoulas is a research fellow at Per Capita, a progressive think tank.


Stephen Koukoulas

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Reserve Bank may resort to more rate cuts and 'even quantitative easing'
NAB economists expect global headwinds to force cash rate to 1% by August 2017, raising prospect of unconventional policy

Martin Farrer

09, Aug, 2016 @2:14 AM

Article image
Forget the spin. Cost of living and interest rates may stay high for some time to come | Satyajit Das
The RBA tells us the pain is only temporary and for the best, but it could be here for a while. Here’s why

Satyajit Das

22, Feb, 2023 @2:20 AM

Article image
Reserve Bank of Australia leaves interest rates unchanged at 2%
Governor Glenn Stevens leaves the door open for further cuts in the cash rate with a statement that emphasises the weakness of the economy

Martin Farrer and agencies

02, Jun, 2015 @6:20 AM

Article image
Negative interest rates: mad economic science or the logical next step? | Greg Jericho
As the economy begs for a stimulus and the government fixates on a surplus, talk of extreme monetary policy is growing

Greg Jericho

28, Oct, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
Joe Hockey's interest rate statement gives lie to Coalition's carbon tax claims
Reserve Bank of Australia says the economy is slowing, defying Abbott government predictions that axing the carbon tax would strengthen it

Greg Jericho

05, Feb, 2015 @3:00 AM

Article image
Can Labor provide cost-of-living relief without feeding inflation and interest rates? An expert panel responds
Anthony Albanese says the government can’t afford to provide energy payments or other relief because to do so would put even more pressure on the RBA to raise interest rates – is he right? Three economists have their say

John Quiggin , Angela Jackson and Stephen Koukoulas

04, Nov, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Reserve Bank keeps interest rates on hold – but hints at more cuts to come
The RBA maintains the cash rate at 2.25% but governor Glenn Stevens drops strong hint that it will be reduced again to boost the flagging economy

Martin Farrer

03, Mar, 2015 @3:32 AM

Article image
Dollar dives, shares soar as Reserve Bank cuts interest rate to 2.25% – as it happened
Shares hit a seven-year high as RBA cut rates by a quarter point but the dollar loses US1.5c. Follow the reaction with Greg Jericho

Greg Jericho

03, Feb, 2015 @5:24 AM

Article image
Interest rates: RBA weighs up risk of ‘climb shock’ ahead of decision
Economists split on how much Reserve Bank will lift cash rate on Tuesday as it looks to rein in inflation

Peter Hannam

06, Jun, 2022 @6:42 AM

Article image
Australian interest rates head for 1% as emergency measures loom for economy
RBA governor drops strong hint of fresh cuts to 1.25% cash rate while experts say US-style quantitative easing is on the cards

Martin Farrer

20, Jun, 2019 @6:00 PM