Policing needs public trust – and we won’t win it with Tasers | Janet Hills

Black officers have deep concerns about the disproportionate deployment of Tasers against minorities, and the death of Dalian Atkinson has heightened them

As a police officer, I was told that the Taser, the new bit of kit that was bright yellow and shaped like a gun, would protect officers and our communities. That they could literally stop a raging bull, take down even the strongest attacker and keep us safe. When first introduced, we were assured that they were the “soft” option. Many police chiefs even stepped forward to be shot with this “safe” option. But now we see that, after several years of use, there have been a number of fatalities.

In a controlled environment, with medical care on hand and with a volunteer who is fit and healthy, everything might seem fine, but on the streets where officers patrol, that benign scenario rarely exists. In the real world the person may have mental health, drink, drug or other issues. This is the situation we seek to contain using this “less lethal” option.

The Taser is supposed to work on two levels, psychological and physical, but if a person has mental health issues the psychological impact of these deadly weapons might be limited. Consider too that there are much higher levels of mental health diagnosis in parts of the black and minority ethnic (BME) community. Statistics show us as three times more likely to be on the receiving end of a Taser.

Eighteen months ago we heard calls for every officer in England and Wales to be given the option of being armed with a Taser to meet the increased terror risk. But I am not convinced that the incidents we have seen in France and Belgium recently would have been stopped by officers carrying Tasers. I still believe our best hope is to stick with the core of what we do best here in the UK: policing by consent, with the support of the public and the communities we serve.

That must mean all communities. The “Peelian principal” – named after the founder of modern policing, Sir Robert Peel – asserts that “the police are the public and the public are the police”. But we know that BME communities continue to have disproportionately high contact with police. This is particularly evident in the area of stop and search, which has already created a mindset of unfairness. We must use our powers with care and sensitivity, and we must do all we can to reduce injury and death at the hands of the state.

As a serving officer I know what it is like to face a man armed with a knife. I have seen the dreadful consequences of knife crime in our communities. What I want is for the Taser to be used to reduce the number of tragic incidents, not increase them. Officers are trained to consider the most appropriate option in the circumstances but ultimately it remains the responsibility of officers and those who employ them to justify their use of force. These decisions are underpinned by legislation, but the law can only ever be a starting point. We must train officers to understand behaviour, to consider all the options, and, in critical situations, to be able to give the vital aftercare that is needed.

As president of the National Black Police Association, I am clearly concerned about the disproportionate use and the impact that Taser use has on our communities. Increasing their use may seem an easy option, but we must always be aware of the concern Tasers are causing in communities already filled with mistrust and fear towards police. The reality is that we are dealing with fragile, vulnerable human beings, and there needs to be more thought before we reach a stage where more officers carry them. When things go wrong, we must be transparent.

It is difficult at this stage to understand the incident in West Mercia involving Dalian Atkinson, who died after a Taser was discharged, but it is vital that thorough investigation is carried out so his family and those closest to him are left in no doubt as to what happened. Our thoughts go out to all involved; our hope is that it never happens again.


Janet Hills

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
I’m a police officer, and I fear increased powers of stop and search will undermine public trust | Andy George
The government must listen: community engagement is the only way to cut serious crime in the UK’s most deprived areas, says Andy George, president of the National Black Police Association

Andy George

07, Jan, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
The terror of Babar Ahmad | Victoria Brittain

Victoria Brittain: The Islamophobia behind his seven-year ordeal in prison fighting extradition can no longer be ignored

Victoria Brittain

02, Dec, 2011 @9:30 PM

Article image
The police don't work for us | Benjamin Zephaniah

Benjamin Zephaniah: As another police officer is discharged, I wonder what it will take to get a conviction for using racist language

Benjamin Zephaniah

26, Oct, 2012 @2:30 PM

Article image
The racial bias in our justice system is creating a social timebomb | David Lammy
My review reveals the prejudice that black and minority ethnic children face. We must address this issue urgently, writes David Lammy, Labour MP for Tottenham

David Lammy

08, Sep, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
PC Blakelock murder trial: the case against Nicky Jacobs was flawed from the start | Stafford Scott
Stafford Scott: As in the Tottenham Three trial in 1987, the prosecution was driven by desperation. But this time, thankfully, justice was done

Stafford Scott

09, Apr, 2014 @5:25 PM

Article image
Stephen Lawrence verdict is about society as much as his murderers | Michael Mansfield

Michael Mansfield: Doreen and Neville Lawrence have exposed an arrogance of unaccountability infecting so many aspects of our democracy

Michael Mansfield

03, Jan, 2012 @7:12 PM

Article image
If the police step up stop-and-search tactics, trouble will follow | John Drury
Our research shows how the strategy contributed to the 2011 London riots, says John Drury, a professor of social psychology

John Drury

31, Jan, 2019 @2:26 PM

Article image
A Prevent-style plan for knife crime is not just misguided, it’s dangerous | Gracie May Bradley
Expecting teachers, doctors and nurses to report young people ‘at risk of violence’ creates alienation, stigma and fear, says Liberty policy manager Gracie Mae Bradley

Gracie Mae Bradley

02, Apr, 2019 @4:32 PM

Article image
Britain criminalising young BME people could spark a new crisis on the streets | Kehinde Andrews
Racism in the criminal justice system increases marginalisation of minority young people, says black studies professor Kehinde Andrews

Kehinde Andrews

30, Jan, 2019 @9:44 AM

Article image
I saw what sparked the Tottenham riots – 10 years on, it could happen again | Stafford Scott
A decade after the killing of Mark Duggan, it’s clear the police have failed to learn vital lessons about excessive force, says activist Stafford Scott

Stafford Scott

04, Aug, 2021 @9:20 AM