The Guardian view on India’s Daughter: a necessary spotlight | Editorial

By blocking this BBC film about the assault and murder of Jyoti Singh, Delhi appears unwilling to grasp the connection between rape and wider misogyny

The crime was exceptionally shocking, but it grew out of a misogyny that is all too common. As much as the harrowing details of the gang rape and murder of Jyoti Singh, it was the sense that this horror was animated by attitudes that condemn many Indian women to lesser indignities and injuries every day that brought vast crowds on to the streets. The film, India’s Daughter, trains an unflinching eye on the evil deeds of one day in December 2012, but its real service is in exposing wider prejudices. By going to the courts to stop it being shown, the Indian authorities reveal themselves to be unable – or unwilling – to grasp the connection between the two.

The immediate controversy surrounded the death-row interview that director Leslee Udwin conducted with Mukesh Singh, the rapist who drove the bus on which Ms Singh was assaulted. It is, of course, chilling to hear him argue that “you can’t clap with one hand”, that a girl who steps out after dark is “more responsible” for rape than a man. But more frightening than the vicious self-justification of this lowlife are the arguments with which the defence lawyers attempt to woo wider society. A 23-year-old medical student’s life had been brutally cut short after a trip to the cinema, and yet ML Sharma felt it appropriate to liken women to flowers, beauties which ought to be worshipped in temples, but which would, inevitably, degrade if they sank into the gutter. “In our culture,” he added, “there is no place for women.” Another lawyer, AP Singh, observed that, if his own daughter dabbled in pre-marital relations, he “would put petrol on her and set her alight”.

The words of these two educated men cannot and must not be taken as speaking for India as a whole. The world’s largest democracy affords some women prominent roles, and indeed produced one of the first female prime ministers. But Ms Singh’s parents say something revealing when they recall how friends were mystified when they celebrated Jyoti’s birth “as if she were a boy”, the same something that’s borne out in the large male majority among Indian infants, a gender gap in which selective abortion and even infanticide have surely played a part. Some of the remarks that Ms Udwin coaxes out of Mukesh Singh may be rare, but his claim that “housekeeping and housework are for girls” is one part of his worldview that is anything but unique.

The Indian police, at the presumed behest of the government, sought to get the film blocked on account of Ms Udwin’s supposed failure to follow certain bureaucratic procedures regarding the prison interviews, and because to broadcast the words of a notorious rapist could be inflammatory. When Ms Singh’s family were closely involved with the film, to get hung up on either point seems perverse; it would make more sense if the real source of the objection was patriotic resentment at foreign film-makers shining an unflattering light on Indian society. But uncomfortable or not, it is a light that had to be shone. The BBC deserves credit for defying demands made in Delhi and bringing forward this urgent broadcast.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Questions of perspective on India’s Daughter | Letters
Letters: The documentary about the Delhi rape should also have said that this is a worldwide problem in which Britain has one of the worst records

11, Mar, 2015 @7:40 PM

Article image
India’s Daughter: since the Delhi rape things have got worse | Jayati Ghosh
Yes, the documentary had its faults, but our society’s depravity must be exposed if we are to change its attitudes

Jayati Ghosh

06, Mar, 2015 @6:02 PM

Article image
It’s not Leslee Udwin’s message that India is struggling to accept, it’s the messenger
The row about Udwin’s film, India’s Daughter, calls to mind the way Gandhi dealt with the sickening accounts of child bride abuse in Katherine Mayo’s 1927 book, Mother India. Governments hate to hear the truth from an outsider

Ian Jack

14, Mar, 2015 @8:00 AM

Article image
India news channel in on-air protest against rape documentary ban
NDTV, stopped from showing India’s Daughter, displays largely blank screen during hour-long slot with text describing reactions to the film and its ban

Maseeh Rahman in Delhi

08, Mar, 2015 @6:36 PM

Article image
India's Daughter review – this film does what the politicians should be doing
This documentary, which focuses on the assault of Jyoti Singh on a bus in Delhi in 2012, may not contain much that will surprise Indians, but its determination to shed light on the country’s rape crisis should inspire change

Sonia Faleiro

05, Mar, 2015 @8:22 AM

Article image
India's Daughter makes me want to defend India. It's the wrong impulse| Beejoli Shah
As an Indian-American, I’ve had to be a self-appointed ambassador for the country from which I hail. But it doesn’t need me to put it on a pedestal

Beejoli Shah

09, Mar, 2015 @11:30 AM

Article image
Kill the Rapist? Provocative Bollywood thriller aims to deter Indian attacks
Controversially titled new feature film shows 'very violent and brutal' demonstration of how a victim decides fate of her attacker

Jason Burke in Delhi

30, Aug, 2013 @2:58 PM

Article image
Narendra Modi must lift the ban on my film about rape in India | Leslee Udwin
I will be protesting outside the Indian prime minister’s Wembley rally today to ask him to reverse an absurd ban on a film that pleads for an end to gender-based violence

Leslee Udwin

13, Nov, 2015 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on sex abuse after Savile: culture change needed | Editorial
Editorial: Jimmy Savile got away with his crimes on an exceptionally public stage. The BBC has specific shortcomings to fix. The deeper need is to challenge a wider cultural instinct to look away


25, Feb, 2016 @8:05 PM

The Guardian view on Angelina Jolie: star attraction

Editorial: Without Angelina Jolie … representatives of 140 countries would not be gathering in London to try to make a difference


09, Jun, 2014 @8:23 PM