The Guardian view on UK energy policy: the limits of the market | Editorial

Government has a vital role ensuring that green goals and supply needs are both maintained

Last year was a rough one for the climate change secretary, the Lib Dems’ Ed Davey. The big government offer in 2010 of a clear, market-driven energy policy turns out to have been easier to promise than to deliver. That is partly the fault of coalition politics. Energy became the battleground for the most fundamental differences between the two partners. As a result, a policy area that demands long-term thinking has been mired in uncertainty. The case for green energy has been widely undermined by misleading accounts of its cost to the consumer. David Cameron, the man who used to say vote blue, go green, now talks of cutting the green crap.

In the midst of the political squabbling, the Department of Energy and Climate Change (Decc) has lurched between crises. Last month, faced with warnings from the power-generation industry that they were working at something close to full capacity, with a margin of as little as 2% at times of peak demand, Mr Davey’s department looked for a cast-iron guarantee that the lights would stay on. Although many independent observers argued that the 2% margin was likely to be breached only in an extreme winter, and then only for a very short period, last month the National Grid held the first ever auction for capacity contracts which can ensure the lights will not go out. The generators guaranteed they would have power available and, in return, were guaranteed sales at a price that, when it comes on stream three years from now, will cost consumers about £1bn a year.

This deal is due to be approved by Mr Davey on Monday. There are two particularly contentious aspects to it. First, it has turned out to be a subsidy to generators for doing something that they would do anyway. Second, instead of encouraging a new generation of gas-fired power stations to enter the market, two-thirds will come from existing capacity, which means that nearly a fifth of the supply will come from dirty coal and contentious biomass, while EDF, the major nuclear power operator, will generate a further 16%.

Meanwhile, the Decc has rebooted the struggling green deal, the flagship project to encourage home owners to invest in energy efficiency. Beset by complexity, at the end of its second year in 2013, green deal had attracted fewer than 4,000 takers. It has now been rebranded as the green deal home improvement fund, and extended to allow consumers to borrow up to £6,000 to invest in more difficult projects like solid-wall insulation. The experience of the green deal home improvement fund has been the reverse of its predecessor. It’s so successful that it’s a complete sellout.

Reshaping energy policy will inevitably be a long-haul project. The political right argues that, with well-designed market incentives, innovative technologies will emerge. Incentives certainly have their place. But, overall, this is too big a challenge, as Mr Davey’s experience has shown, to rely exclusively on incentivising. Moreover, in moral terms, this is a challenge that cannot be left wholly to the market. At its heart, energy policy generates conflicting rights. Only the state can ensure fairness between them.



The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Number of households getting help with insulation plummets
1.61m lofts were fully insulated in 2012, but just 110,000 were treated in the year to October 2013 – a pro-rata fall of 93%

Damian Carrington

30, Dec, 2013 @8:01 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on greening the economy: the price is worth paying | Editorial
Editorial: Some of the policy needed updating. But it cannot be made cost-free


22, Jul, 2015 @6:50 PM

Article image
Green deal finance firm warns about funding gap
Company providing loans in flagship energy efficiency scheme says state-owned bank has closed off funding channel

Terry Macalister

05, Oct, 2014 @4:26 PM

Article image
UK switch to low-carbon energy 'no dearer than doing nothing'

Prediction using unique calculator challenges view that sustainable energy means higher costs

Damian Carrington

28, Dec, 2011 @12:34 PM

Article image
Good Energy: it’s not about technology anymore, it’s about people
Thriving eco energy firm founder Juliet Davenport tells Zoe Williams about power through profit and growing prospects of challenging the Big Six

Zoe Williams

20, May, 2014 @10:00 AM

Article image
Force energy companies to insulate UK homes, climate advisers say
Committee on Climate Change says making energy companies to insulate empty lofts and walls would cut national emissions

Damian Carrington

29, Jun, 2011 @11:01 PM

Article image
Appeal to David Cameron over 'green charges' on energy bills

A group of local authorities, social landlords and academics has written to the PM urging him not to scrap the charges

Fiona Harvey, environment correspondent

27, Nov, 2013 @6:00 AM

Article image
UK retailers in talks to join government's 'green deal'
Tesco, B&Q and M&S among companies that could sell loft insulation and home energy improvements as part of the coalition's flagship energy efficiency programme

Juliette Jowit in Birmingham

06, Oct, 2010 @1:35 PM

Article image
Minister hints at gas boilers ban but says market should drive change
Anne-Marie Trevelyan urges firms to encourage shift to heat pumps, amid criticism of limited £5,000 grants

Jessica Elgot Chief political correspondent

19, Oct, 2021 @8:38 AM

Green deal 'unlikely to deliver promises', say experts

Experts say promises to save money for poorer households and rescue many from fuel poverty cannot be guaranteed

Fiona Harvey, environment correspondent

28, Jan, 2013 @9:54 AM