The internet probably has better things than porn. We're just not looking at it | Jess Zimmerman

Several billion monkey descendants with keyboards produce a lot of smut

There was always going to be gay dinosaur porn.

It’s a very large internet, after all, and it’s long been known as a prodigious generator of adult material for every occasion. You know the theory about how if you put an infinite number of monkeys in front of typewriters, one of them will eventually write Hamlet? Thanks to the internet, we have now tried this experiment with several billion monkey descendants. We didn’t get Hamlet, but we did get pretty much every kind of smut imaginable (including Hamlet parody porn). There’s even a name for it: Rule 34, which is generally stated, “if it exists, there is porn of it.” (Don’t bother looking up the other rules; they pretty much all suck.)

The internet isn’t precisely infinite – there is a bounded, though huge, amount of data involved. (One estimate puts total web traffic this year at 966 exabytes, or 966,000,000,000,000,000,000 bytes; that’s 193 million million times the space that would be needed for a text file of all the words ever spoken by humans.) But with the advent of social media, the internet became not just broad, but tall – web sites continue to proliferate, and at the same time, we continue to pile new posts onto our existing little plots of ground. The internet is fractal; measuring it would be like measuring the coastline inch by inch. It might as well be endless.

And so, as with the infinite monkeys – who would not only write Hamlet, but Paradise Lost and The Metamorphosis and David Ives’ Words Words Words and season two of The Wire and anything else you could think of because that is how infinity works – the sheer vastness of the internet makes gay dinosaur erotica, which Buzzfeed investigated this week, not only unsurprising but inevitable. In an infinite universe, everything possible will happen eventually, and that includes every imaginable dirty fantasia. It’s like the Library of Babel, but for porn.

But why only smut? Why doesn’t the internet also host every form of brilliant literature? The answer: it probably does. We just tend not to notice, because our attention is elsewhere.

To realize that one of the monkeys has written Hamlet, there needs to be someone evaluating their work, someone with an eye for Shakespearean prose and ideally no sense of smell. And if she’s looking for Hamlet alone, this hypothetical monkey proctor won’t just toss out the nonsense and the dinosaur porn; she’ll also ignore the monkey typing Henry VI, Part I. On the flip side, she’ll probably find not only Hamlet but Halmet, Hamtel, Helmat and Thelma. We find all manner of dirty films and stories because we prioritize it by seeking it out; we pick through the noise to find it because we care. For the most part, I think the profusion of pornography can occasionally be delightful (did you read that gay dinorotica article?) and, at its worst be dangerous – for instance, ridding the internet of child porn is like playing high-stakes Whac-a-Mole.

The internet also contains every kind of anger and ugliness, because we prioritize and seek that out too. We’re prodigies at outrage, capable of reaming each other out over anything from blatant xenophobia to infelicitous word use. That doesn’t need to be covered by Rule 34, because it’s Rules 1 through 1 Million: people gravitate toward forming factions, holding grudges, lashing out, proving themselves. It’s no surprise that the internet, a near-infinity of human creations, would feature rage and hate, and it’s not a surprise that we tend to bring it to the fore.

But the best of humanity is out there, too. In a nearly limitless internet, everything possible exists somewhere. This makes it a powerful engine for porn and yelling of every stripe, but it is also a powerful engine for aesthetics, for compassion, for stories and ideas. There are multi-year magical-realist humor-drama epics like Achewood. There are weird, emotionally wrenching gems like Mallory Ortberg’s Text Messages From a Ghost. There are genre-elevating parody Twitter accounts like @MayorEmanuel. (There is also, I guarantee, some smut out there that is beautiful literature, too.) There are any number of wonderful stories that couldn’t exist without the internet, and even more that exist in isolation, without an audience. We just have to go looking for them.

Contributor

Jess Zimmerman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Iceland's internet 'porn shield' will confront hardcore violence | Halla Gunnarsdóttir
Halla Gunnarsdóttir: If we don't navigate a path between laissez-faire and censorship, a generation may grow up with a distorted view of sexuality

Halla Gunnarsdóttir

26, Feb, 2013 @10:00 AM

Reactionary forces are shaping the debate on internet porn | James Gray
James Gray: Religious campaigners are exploiting concerns over children's sexualisation to push their own agenda

James Gray

23, Dec, 2010 @3:30 PM

Article image
Should internet porn be 'opt-in' only? - video debate

Deborah Orr and Emma Carr, deputy director of Big Brother Watch, discuss internet censorship

Phil Maynard and Ken Macfarlane

26, Nov, 2013 @11:30 AM

Article image
Why David Cameron's war on internet porn doesn't make sense | Tom Meltzer

Tom Meltzer: The prime minister's so-called plan for controlling access to online pornography is a breathtaking piece of political sleight-of-hand

Tom Meltzer

21, Jul, 2013 @7:00 PM

Article image
Never mind Page 3, internet porn is what damages young minds | Paul Connew
Paul Connew: I happen to agree that Page 3 should be ditched, but there are far worse crimes that require the energy of Caroline Lucas et al

Paul Connew

13, Jun, 2013 @2:44 PM

Article image
How the internet killed porn

It's 15 years since Louis Theroux turned the TV cameras on to the US porn industry. Now he is revisiting it to see if anything has changed – and he finds a business in crisis

Louis Theroux

05, Jun, 2012 @7:00 PM

Internet Porn: Worse than crack?

"Internet pornography is the new crack cocaine, leading to addiction, misogyny, pedophilia, boob jobs and erectile dysfunction, according to clinicians and researchers testifying before a Senate committee Thursday. Witnesses before the Senate Commerce Committee's Science, Technology and Space Subcommittee spared no superlative in their description of the negative effects of pornography," reports Wired News.

Jack Schofield

24, Nov, 2004 @12:11 PM

Article image
Growth of internet porn tells us more about ourselves than technology | John Naughton
The actual size of the sex industry online is difficult to estimate, but it is sophisticated and, in some senses, more honest than Google or Facebook

John Naughton

30, Dec, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
Iceland campaigns to restrict internet porn

Activists call for introduction of porn blockers – but new centre-right government is far from enthusiastic

Alexandra Topping in Reykjavik

26, May, 2013 @1:52 PM

Article image
Can the internet actually be an empathy boot camp? | Jess Zimmerman
The internet forces you to consider more people’s needs more deeply, become aware of the variety of human traumas, motives, histories and concerns

Jess Zimmerman

19, Aug, 2015 @12:19 PM