India’s BR Ambedkar would have abhorred the politics of Narendra Modi | Vijay Prashad

As the Indian PM honours the author of the country’s constitution, the social and political inequality that Ambedkar campaigned against is as rampant as ever

Dr BR Ambedkar was born 124 years ago on 14 April, and Google has honoured him with a doodle – a fitting gesture. Ambedkar was a fierce advocate of education and knowledge, and he would have enjoyed the gamut of information technology. Of the oppressed castes of India (dalits), Ambedkar wrote: “Education is the greatest material benefit for which they can fight.”

Born into a dalit family, Ambedkar, by dint of raw talent and determination, earned the best education, including a PhD in economics from Columbia University in 1927. Learning had earned him a place in the heart of his community, which saw in his success their possibility. As India’s first minister of law in Jawaharlal Nehru’s government, Ambedkar authored the 1950 constitution, which gives pride of place to education as the pathway for dalit freedom.

What irked Ambedkar as much as the oppression experienced by dalits, was the way in which politicians used dalits for their own ends. The Congress party, the main vehicle for India’s freedom movement, was tinged with Hindu supremacy as far as Ambedkar was concerned. Condescension toward the grievances of the dalits moved Ambedkar to argue that they should take an independent attitude and form their own political group rather than allow themselves to be used in the struggles for someone else’s gain.

None of Ambedkar’s initiatives worked to break the hegemony of the Congress and its leader, Gandhi. Yet, Ambedkar’s push oxygenated a dalit politics to the left of the Congress, which germinated in fits and starts in the years that followed.

During Ambedkar’s life, the Hindu right was simply not powerful enough to endanger the growth of independent dalit politics. Ambedkar nonetheless warned his comrades to stay clear of that platform. In 1923, Ambedkar captured the essence of the Hindu right, as a “purely political” movement “whose main object and aim is to combat the influence of the Muslims in Indian politics.” To do so, Ambedkar wrote, the Hindu right has to “preserve its political strength,” for which it must “maintain social solidarity, and its way to maintain social solidarity is not to talk about caste or untouchability.”

India’s current prime minister Narendra Modi is this week honouring Ambedkar. No Indian leader can ignore the immense contribution of Ambedkar to the Indian republic, nor the resilience of Ambedkarism in Indian politics. But Modi’s own party is precisely the kind of political platform that Ambedkar abhorred. Garlands and good words will be placed on Ambedkar’s pedestal by the Hindu right, which has nothing but disdain for his liberation agenda. State elections are on the horizon for Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, both with sizable dalit populations, which is perhaps why the Hindu right – eager to sweep these polls – is making gestures to Ambedkar.

On 25 January 1949, Ambedkar said that while the Indian constitution stipulated the equality of all people before the law, all people were still not equal in two senses: “On the social plane we have in India a society based on the principle of graded inequality which means elevation for some and degradation for others. On the economic plane we have a society in which there are some who have immense wealth as against many who live in abject poverty.”

The contradiction between legal and political equality and social and economic inequality lay at the heart of Ambedkar’s worries about India’s future. “On 26 January 1950, we are going to enter into a life of contradictions,” he noted perceptively. “How long shall we continue to live this life of contradictions? How long shall we continue to deny equality in our social and economic life? If we continue to deny it for long, we will do so only by putting our political democracy in peril.”

These are questions for today. Their perceptiveness indicates why Ambedkar is still essential for India – not merely as figure to celebrate, but as a political philosopher for our current struggles.


Vijay Prashad

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The verdict on India’s strongman, Narendra Modi
Religious conflicts, caste antagonism, economic fears: India’s 900 million voters present a formidable challenge to the country’s leader as he battles for re-election. Michael Safi and Kakoli Bhattacharya test the mood of a restless population in the key state of Uttar Pradesh

Michael Safi

07, Apr, 2019 @7:59 AM

Article image
Narendra Modi and identity politics | Letters
Letters: Randhir Singh Bains says the ruling BJP is the only party in India that is challenging communalism and sectarianism


24, May, 2019 @4:07 PM

Article image
In India’s election race, Modi is not the strongman the world assumes | Ruchir Sharma
The country’s massive diversity means the Hindu nationalist leader can’t rely on sabre-ratting with Pakistan

Ruchir Sharma

10, Apr, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Britain's odious rapprochement with Narendra Modi | Praful Bidwai
Praful Bidwai: About 1,000 Muslims died in the Gujarat riots, under Modi's watch. Without justice, there can be no reconciliation

Praful Bidwai

17, Oct, 2012 @11:35 AM

Article image
India’s farmers have won – but this doesn’t mean Modi is softening | Rukmini S
The space for dissent is still diminishing under Modi, says Rukmini S, a data journalist based in Chennai

Rukmini S

23, Nov, 2021 @9:50 AM

Article image
India’s Muslims quiver in the new dawn of an emboldened Narendra Modi
The Hindu nationalist BJP’s election victory will change the culture of the nation, the prime minister’s critics fear

Michael Safi

26, May, 2019 @5:59 AM

Article image
Who is Narendra Modi? – video
Narendra Modi is expected to become India’s next prime minister. Phoebe Greenwood explains how a lowly ‘chai wallah’ from remote Gujarat blossomed into a Hindu nationalist poster boy

Phoebe Greenwood and Laurence Topham

15, May, 2014 @6:53 PM

Article image
Jeremy Corbyn has the moral authority to challenge Narendra Modi | Kapil Komireddi
The leader of the opposition is a longstanding friend to India. He must ask its prime minister to honour the values enshrined in the country’s constitution

Kapil Komireddi

13, Nov, 2015 @4:58 PM

Article image
Narendra Modi exploits nationalism to distract Indians from a failing economy | Ravinder Kaur
Under the prime minister’s watch, a liberal economy has led to an illiberal society, says historian Ravinder Kaur

Ravinder Kaur

20, Aug, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on India’s Mr Modi: suppressing inconvenient facts | Editorial
Editorial: Unlike his predecessors, the Indian prime minister has in five years never held a traditional press conference. What has he got to hide?


01, Feb, 2019 @6:30 PM