Downton Abbey and House of Cards: dramas that live in the world of the 1% | Gail Dines

I can't help bingeing on series like Downtown Abbey and House of Cards, yet hate the pernicious influence of their politics

In Manufacturing Consent, their now classic work on the role of the media in legitimising income inequality, Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky argue that the news media play a central role in propagating an ideology that renders invisible the true class relations of capitalism.

While I agree wholeheartedly with this, I have to add – having recently binged on both Downton Abbey and House of Cards – that drama shows are probably just as powerful (and more insidious) in manufacturing our consent to a society in which the world's 85 richest people own as much as the poorest 50% of humanity.

In the US we are being fed a bizarre media mix of a kindly (if somewhat intellectually challenged) elite – in the form of the wealthy early-20th century Crawley family who run Downton Abbey alongside a Machiavellian vice-president Francis Underwood, who operates within a modern-day government that is owned and controlled by capitalists who are anything but kind. Taken together, these two shows create a politics of despair because, in their different ways, they portray a world devoid of any hope for social and economic change.

Who needs unions at Downton when you have a benevolent elite taking such good care of their workers? American viewers are into the fourth week of the fourth series, and I really don't think I can stand it much longer. In record numbers, we tune in to watch the soap-opera lives of the idle rich and the overworked poor, no doubt identifying with the former rather than the latter. If truth be told, the three hot meals a day that the servants get – not to mention the delectable snacks provided by the cook, Mrs Patmore – must look very good to the millions of Americans who live below the poverty line.

The politics of the show are excruciating for anyone with a progressive bent. Each week the most pressing issue is whether the daughters of the family will find a suitable husband, or if the stately home will survive, given that it is being run by Lord Grantham, the moronic patriarch of the family who squandered his wife's fortune. Forget what was actually happening to real people in England at that time, what with mass poverty, the privations of war and rampant disease. What really matters is that a good maid is so hard to come by that the "ladies" of the house are forced to dress themselves for dinner.

But for all their faults, it is not the rich who make me squirm the most each Sunday night. Rather, it is the fawning servants who seem to spend their days endlessly worrying about the wellbeing of the very people who are working them into an early grave. I don't know whether the elite class really believes that the poor are delighted to take care of them, or whether they invented this ideology to assuage their collective conscience. Either way, the image of the grovelling Carson, the butler, who longs for the days when the rich didn't have to deal with uppity workers, makes me crazy. Please, someone, give this man a copy of the Communist Manifesto so he can get a dose of some much-needed class consciousness!

As much as I can't stand Carson, it is Tom, the former chauffeur who married one of the Grantham daughters (only to watch her die in childbirth), who is the object of my wrath in season four. We have had to bear witness to this once proud socialist being turned by the Crawley clan into a self-hating, simpering shill of the rich to the point where he tells a potential love interest who shows some disdain for the wealthy that he does "not believe in types but in people". Gone are his class politics, only to be replaced by neoliberal drivel that sounds amazingly like Margaret Thatcher, when she famously said: "There is no such thing as society. There are individual men and women, and there are families."

Try telling that to Underwood and his cohort as he rounds up support from the 1% who run the US government. There is no pretence here that individuals are just individuals, as we get to see how the elite use their wealth and power as a class to manipulate the government into doing their bidding. These "individual" men – and it is almost all men – rule as a class with collective economic interests, and we get to see the seamless web that links the captains of the global economy to government, and how the rest of us aresimply outmanoeuvred, outplayed, and outspent.

What is so depressing about this show is not that it tells lies about the rich, but that it provides an image of the world devoid of any class resistance. Rarely do you see any evidence of unions, non-governmental organisations, or any activists who in reality are thorns in the side of the elite. Watch House of Cards and you think the elite have so brilliantly stacked the deck that there is no point in fighting back. Indeed, anyone who does fight back usually ends up dead, because when it comes to resistance in the House of Cards, there are indeed only individuals, no collective movements.

And this at a time when an Oxfam study reveals that 1% of the world's population controls nearly half the planet's wealth, and that in the US, the wealthiest 1% got 95% of the post-financial crisis growth. The only way out of this mess is a mass movement of resistance, one that refuses to buy into the paralysing ideology that the benevolent, kindly rich are deserving of their wealth, or the equally paralysing view that there is no hope for change.

We need to get away from this neoliberal notion that we are all individuals and follow the lead of the elite by acting as a collective – a collective strong enough to wipe the smug smile off the faces of the Francis Underwoods of the world. Now wouldn't that be dramatic?


Gail Dines

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK period drama scores Emmy nominee success with Downton and Wolf Hall
Mark Rylance, David Oyelowo and Ricky Gervais competing for best actor as Downton Abbey continues US television awards success with three nominations

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

16, Jul, 2015 @7:37 PM

Article image
Sherlock, Downton Abbey: what the US can learn from our TV exports
Neil Midgley: As Benedict Cumberbatch’s detective scoops seven Emmys, what is the secret of successful UK drama?

Neil Midgley

31, Aug, 2014 @5:04 PM

Article image
Downton Abbey: a case of familiarity breeding boredom?
Brian Moylan: The show’s fifth season, which premiered on PBS on Sunday, is still the equivalent of TV comfort food – but have the flavours become a bit too bland?

Brian Moylan

05, Jan, 2015 @2:40 PM

Article image
Duchess of Cambridge visits Downton Abbey set
Cast members including Hugh Bonneville and Jim Carter welcome duchess who watches during shoot for sixth series of show

Caroline Davies

12, Mar, 2015 @3:36 PM

Article image
Downton Abbey to end after season six
ITV confirms hit period drama will go as writer Julian Fellowes focuses on new US drama but speculation over feature film

Mark Sweney

26, Mar, 2015 @4:07 PM

Article image
Downton Abbey welcomes Shirley MacLaine for series three

MacLaine, who has made more than 60 films, will play Lady Grantham's mother in the third series of the hit ITV drama

Vicky Frost

30, Jan, 2012 @8:00 PM

Article image
The Gentle Tory is alive and well – on television | David Priestland
David Priestland: Period dramas like Parade's End reveal a yearning for a conservative type that politics has left behind

David Priestland

03, Sep, 2012 @8:30 PM

Article image
Downton Abbey could get tax break in TV production plan
Chancellor George Osborne considers measure to stop filming of 'cinematic television dramas' moving abroad

Nicholas Watt in New York

16, Mar, 2012 @12:01 AM

Article image
Downton Abbey sees off Doctor Who at National Television Awards

ITV's period drama beats the Time Lord's adventures and Waterloo Road in ceremony at London's O2

Josh Halliday

25, Jan, 2012 @11:20 PM

Article image
Downton Abbey review – ridiculous, vanilla-flavoured fun | peter bradshaw's film of the week
Imelda Staunton joins Maggie Smith and co in this standalone film that feels like an intensely glucose Christmas special

Peter Bradshaw

09, Sep, 2019 @11:01 PM