Cory Monteith: the Glee star's death is an all-too familiar teen idol plotline | Hadley Freeman

Every generation has its death and for many teenagers the death of a celebrity is how they learn about mortality

The night before it was announced that Cory Monteith, the 31-year-old star of the hugely popular and very fun TV show Glee, was found alone and dead in a hotel room in Vancouver, I was thinking about River Phoenix. This October, it will be 20 years since Phoenix, then 23, died on a sidewalk in LA while his sister Rainbow and girlfriend Samantha Mathis stood helplessly by and his little brother frantically called 911. Those of a younger generation may need reminding that River was Joaquin's older brother. Those of my generation and older will doubtless be reeling at the realisation it has been two decades since Phoenix went from being one of the world's most famously promising actors to one of its infamously dead.

Hollywood loves recycling plotlines, and one plotline that never goes away is that of the tragic teenage pin-up. That this story has become such a cliche only adds to the tragedy and sense of waste when it returns, again and again. The autopsy on Monteith has not yet been released but if drugs did play a part in his death – and that is not unthinkable, as he had struggled with substance abuse since his teens and recently left rehab for the second time – this would place him in a tragically popular pantheon. Off the top of my head, four teen icons have died from substance abuse in the past five years: Brad Renfro, Heath Ledger, Corey Haim, Brittany Murphy and one can include Amy Winehouse in there, too, already calcified into the status of a legend.

For millions of teenagers, the announcement of Monteith's death was as shocking as Phoenix's and Kurt Cobain's were for the now 30 and 40somethings, as Ledger's was for today's 20somethings. Every generation has its death and, for many teenagers, the death of a teen icon is how they learn about mortality. While it is true that social media can encourage the fetishisation of collective grief, equally, just because it is expressed in 140 characters, does not mean it isn't truly felt.

Looking at that list of teen icons, and then including some of the others who have died brutally and prematurely in the past 20 years, such as Phoenix and Cobain, it's interesting to note how many are male. The media have always been and are increasingly fascinated with self-destructive women in the public eye, with the National Enquirer once keeping a "death watch" on Lindsay Lohan. Self-destructive young men generally slip past the media's salacious radar unless they actively court the tabloids, Pete Doherty style. One can only imagine the paparazzi harassment Monteith's co-star and long-term girlfriend, Lea Michele, would have suffered had she been the one coming out of rehab. Monteith, by contrast, barely made an imprint on even This not only makes the deaths of the young men more of a surprise to the public but also underlines how the media treats young women as objects of voyeuristic prey and young men as a backdrop.

Part of what makes Monteith's death so sad is that he always came across as a thoughtful, nice guy. This is not something one can say about many teen idols who die young. He spoke out against bullying, homophobia and talked often about how he hoped his recent stint in rehab from addiction would inspire others.

Most celebrities struggle with the disjunct between their public image and their private selves. This is exacerbated for teen icons, who are often selling a vision of life to young fans that is far from the speeded-up lives they live. By all accounts, Phoenix tussled with the contrast between the "whacked-out hippy" side of his life that preached veganism and the side that took heroin in nightclubs. Others, like poor Brad Renfro and Corey Haim, are dumped when their personal chaos is deemed to overshadow and undermine their professional work.

Monteith, unusually, tried to tie the two sides of his life together, refusing to deny or be defined by either Glee's clean-cut image or his problems with drugs: "You see this young, all-American quarterback-looking dude on the show … but I felt I had to step in at some point and relate to people my truth," he said in a recent TV interview, looking the picture of apple-pie good health, which he knew was a distracting cover.

When young entertainers die, it is tempting to look back and see eerie premonitions. Probably the most well-known is James Dean's public service announcement advocating safe driving, made just 13 days before he was killed in a car crash: "Take it easy driving! One of those lives you might save might be mine," Dean says jocularly as he walks off camera for the last time.

For Monteith, there's Glee's defining musical moment: the cast's performance of Don't Stop Believing in the pilot episode. The show makes the common mistake of thinking this is an optimistic song because of the title, whereas it is really the opposite: the story of lonely people desperately flinging themselves towards success in the belief it will save them, making it an apt song for aspiring teen icons. "Some will win!" belts out Michele during one of their duets. The camera swings round to Monteith, close-up: "Some will lose," he replies, grinning like the naughty little boy he once was.

There will never be a shortage of beautiful young people who crave fame. Whether it's the need for fame that bespeaks an inner emptiness that courts risk, or something about the fame itself that creates an unhappiness, which in turn necessitates oblivion, cannot be fully known. As Monteith's fans tearfully await the results of his autopsy, another slew of pretty young boys are grappling to take his place in the spotlight. Some will win, and some will lose.


Hadley Freeman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Cory Monteith co-stars pay tribute after Glee actor's death
Police say no signs of foul play in star's death in Vancouver, as producers of hit show praise 'exceptional' performer

Alexandra Topping and agencies

14, Jul, 2013 @1:03 PM

Article image
Cory Monteith obituary
Canadian actor best known for his role as Finn Hudson in Glee

Anthony Hayward

14, Jul, 2013 @5:43 PM

Cory Monteith: memorable Glee moments

Following news of the Glee star's death in Vancouver, we look back at his career on the show that made him a star

Vicky Frost

14, Jul, 2013 @8:34 AM

Article image
Cory Monteith snubbed at 2014 Oscars

Troubled star of hit TV show Glee not remembered at Academy Awards ceremony

Xan Brooks liveblogs the ceremony
Full list of winners as they're announced

Andrew Pulver

03, Mar, 2014 @4:06 AM

Article image
Paul Bhattacharjee and Cory Monteith deaths: is acting today just too tough?

Are the recent deaths of high-profile actors tragic one-offs? Or is the profession now too precarious? Michael Simkins, a veteran of stage and screen, lifts the lid on a lonely world

Michael Simkins

23, Jul, 2013 @5:45 PM

Cory Monteith's death confirmed by Vancouver police – video

Vancouver police confirms that Canadian actor Cory Monteith has been found dead in a Vancouver hotel room

14, Jul, 2013 @8:39 AM

Article image
Cory Monteith: how will Glee producers deal with his death?

Andrew Collins: From Livia in The Sopranos to Leo in The West Wing, TV shows have found respectful ways of coping with a key actor's departure

Andrew Collins

16, Jul, 2013 @10:50 AM

Article image
The grief for Cory Monteith is real, even if his character wasn't | Sarah Bee
Sarah Bee: Glee's devoted fanbase – 'gleeks' – poured their emotions into the show. Now they are pouring their grief on to the internet

Sarah Bee

15, Jul, 2013 @2:03 PM

Article image
Gwyneth's Glee sex education lesson is out of touch

Gwyneth Paltrow's forthcoming singing stint in Glee has her unwittingly covering a Gary Glitter classic

Alexis Petridis

10, Mar, 2011 @8:00 PM

Article image
Glee says goodbye to Cory Monteith with earnest but awkward tribute | Emma G Keller
Emma G Keller: The show danced around the details of Monteith's death. Still, there were moving moments – and what looked like real tears

Emma G Keller

11, Oct, 2013 @3:34 PM