Merkel's rival Peer Steinbrück offers the alternative Germany needs | Henning Meyer

Rather than challenging Merkel's economic record, the German media focus on attacking her social democratic challenger

2013 is now upon us and when it comes to German politics it is already clear what the climax of this year will be: the federal elections in September. As 2012 drew to a close, the election campaign was already well under way. But rather than focusing on the policies needed to overcome the many issues Europe faces, the focus has been on Peer Steinbrück, Angela Merkel's social democratic challenger. And given the general lack of scrutiny of Merkel's politics one cannot help but feel that large parts of the German media landscape have a much too cosy relationship with the incumbent chancellor.

Headlines in recent weeks were dominated by accusations that Steinbrück had given too many paid talks while an MP and his criticism of the low salary that comes with the chancellorship. Even though the vast majority of Steinbrück's talks were pro bono and the fees were not excessive by international comparison, most German media sought to paint the SPD candidate as greedy.

It's another symptom of the campaign against Steinbrück that he remained the centre of attention long after a full account of all paid speeches was published. Meanwhile, the fact that Merkel's CDU blocked an SPD attempt to achieve the same level of transparency for all MPs remained largely unreported – as did the fact that there are many MPs in conservative and liberal ranks who have significant additional income on top of their MP's salary.

Whether you agree with all of Steinbrück's positions or not, he has two important qualities that are in short supply in the current climate: he is competent and honest. A former finance minister whose political stewardship during the financial crisis was widely praised even beyond the borders of Germany, he has for instance published a significant paper on reforming the financial sector. His reform proposals include vital elements such as the separation of investment an retail banking, the creation of a bailout mechanism paid for by the banks, the capping of bonus payments, better oversight of hedge funds and the prohibition of speculation with commodities such as crops. He has recently also urged that eurozone crisis countries should be allowed more time to get their economies back on track and has also made comments against excessive austerity: a bold move in the current German political climate.

Steinbrück is also right to accuse Merkel the of not having communicated the real nature of the European crisis: she continues to talk about a sovereign debt crisis even though, apart from Greece, the real macro-economic instability originated in the private sector. And she looks set to continue down this path. In her new year address she warned German citizens about difficult economic times in 2013, conveniently without mentioning her own role in bringing these economic risks about.

You really do not need to know much about macro-economics to conclude that a country as export-reliant as Germany will suffer if most of its important trading partners are in a recession. If offsetting factors, such as increasing exports into the Brics countries also weaken, the German economy will face difficult times.

The Merkel government has apparently also not understood the nature of the macro-economic interconnectedness within the eurozone. Leading experts such as Paul De Grauwe of the London School of Economics and even IMF director Christine Lagarde have pointed out that a symmetric adjustment process in the eurozone (ie both deficit and surplus countries changing direction), is needed to achieve a sustainable readjustment. And what does the German government do? Instead of expanding investment, as a symmetric approach requires, the Merkel government is currently discussing an extensive austerity programme that includes a rise in VAT, a reduction of government contributions to the health system and another increase in the retirement age.

With exceptions such as Wolfgang Münchau of the Financial Times and Spiegel Online, the German media have failed to scrutinise these major mistakes in Merkel's politics, even though we are now entering the fourth crisis year and the situation has only calmed down because of bold action by the ECB. Her U-turn politics has actually made the crisis worse.

Instead of doing the job of educating the public, most German media outlets seemingly prefer to engage in ad hominem attacks against her social democratic challenger. This, to my mind, is also why the majority of Germans still believe that Angela Merkel is doing a good job in European politics. Neither the government nor the German media have properly explained the real issues we face. Often, when I explain the alternative crisis view to one of my compatriots I get asked why this is not discussed more prominently in Germany. This is a good question for which I have no answer.

But this is also a shortcoming that can be rectified this year. Election years are years of debate and political alternatives. Peer Steinbrück is the right man to challenge Merkel's crisis narrative and take this debate in a more constructive direction. And if the German media start to join in and scrutinise the real issues at hand, we are in for a very interesting election year.


Henning Meyer

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mrs Merkel's Germany is Europe's one musketeer | Josef Joffe

Josef Joffe: The German chancellor's critics should stop accusing her of Teutonic arrogance. Why should she take on everyone's debts?

Josef Joffe

21, Jun, 2012 @8:30 PM

Article image
Merkel's moment: soft power and hard cash – why all eyes are on Germany

From closely aligned neighbours to austerity-stricken states longing for a more flexible chancellor, when Germans go to the polls in 12 days, the results will reverberate across Europe

Correspondents of the Guardian, Le Monde, El Pais, La Stampa and Gazeta Wyborcza

10, Sep, 2013 @6:15 PM

Article image
Angela Merkel's EU policy is good for Germany – and for the rest of Europe | Hans-Gert Pöttering
Hans-Gert Pöttering: German elections 2013 – the hustings: The European Union and the euro are not perfect, but now we have the chance, and the duty, to help improve them

Hans-Gert Pöttering

24, Aug, 2013 @1:00 PM

Germany: An election that affects us all | Editorial
Editorial: Mrs Merkel's re-election would ensure a stability at the centre of the EU which offers some hope of effective new thinking


17, Sep, 2013 @7:38 PM

Article image
Germany isn’t the big bad boss of Europe | Jochen Hung
The idea that the country has an iron grip over southern European economies is too often used as a convenient excuse for others not getting their house in order

Jochen Hung

05, Feb, 2015 @9:01 AM

Article image
Splits widen in Merkel's coalition over proposals for Greek economic reforms
Social Democrats mostly support Alexis Tsipras’s latest plan, but the chancellor faces mutiny within her own conservative ranks over a third bailout for Greece

Kate Connolly in Berlin

10, Jul, 2015 @5:59 PM

Article image
Is Germany too powerful for Europe?

Twenty years ago, Germany's economy was stagnating. Today, as the eurozone crisis deepens, this giant is keeping Europe afloat. But what does it want in return? Stuart Jeffries talks to German sociologist Ulrich Beck, who believes that his country has become a political monster

Stuart Jeffries

31, Mar, 2013 @6:00 PM

Article image
Germany Eurosceptics win state seats in Saxony

Alternative für Deutschland beats two mainstream rivals, as leader declares party has 'arrived on political landscape'

Ben Knight in Berlin

01, Sep, 2014 @10:54 AM

Article image
US squares up to Germany over austerity and banking union
George Osborne to host G7 summit in UK as Washington pushes Berlin to loosen purse strings and boost domestic demand

Ian Traynor in Brussels and Phillip Inman

09, May, 2013 @6:23 PM

Article image
A Rhine romance: Germany and France celebrate five decades of marriage

Hundreds of politicians and cultural leaders gather in Berlin to mark 50 years since signing the Elysée treaty of friendship

Kate Connolly in Berlin

22, Jan, 2013 @6:22 PM