Zlatan Ibrahimovic's Byronic bicycle kick | David Winner

Can moments of brilliance such as the Swede's wonder goal against England transcend the sporting arena and become art?

It's not every day that one hears the manager of the England football team describe an opponent's winning goal as a "work of art". Then again, it's not exactly normal to see a big Swede leaping backwards like a giant salmon and bicycle-kicking the ball 30 metres over the head of a stranded England goalkeeper. One only needed to see the Swedish reaction to Zlatan Ibrahimovic's fourth goal on Wednesday to realise something remarkable had occurred. Even the England fans were wreathed in smiles. Roy Hodgson's generous response was understandable.

But is football really art? Did Ibrahimovic's combination of delicacy and daring add up to a masterpiece? Where does it stand in the pantheon of football's most beautiful moments? Was it as spine-tingling as Pelé's dummy of the Uruguayan goalkeeper in 1970? As jaw-dropping as Maradona's dribble through the entire England defence in 1986? I'd say not, but these are questions of personal taste.

Football can be many things: quasi-religion, politics by other means, a locus of local and national identity. But we also instinctively understand the game to be, on occasion, numinous. That's why Stoke City's Tony Waddington called it "the working man's ballet".

Indeed, aesthetic considerations crop up in discussion of everything from tactics to fan songs. At peak moments such as world cups, football reveals its power as a story form that holds entire nations rapt. That was one reason Stanley Kubrick was fascinated by it. Characteristically, he preferred the dark psychology of Italian defending to the "facile" prettiness of Brazilian or Dutch attacking. On retirement, Ruud Krol, one of the stars of the "total football" movement of the 1970s, spent three years visiting the art galleries of the world. "Football is not art," he declared enigmatically, "but there is an art to playing good football."

Excellence certainly comes in numerous styles and flavours. Much like George Best or Lord Byron, Ibrahimovic fits the profile of the moody, impulsive romantic hero. The son of Yugoslav immigrants, he developed his baffling array of flicks, feints and juggling skills on the streets of Malmö, and embodies the idea of the creative footballer as maverick individualist.

However, he also spent unhappy years with Ajax in Holland and at Barcelona, where a very different aesthetic prevails. Ibrahimovic was baffled by the no less lustrous positional game, which is built on passing and geometric patterns of movement.

The English, meanwhile, traditionally viewed football as a rumbustious fighting game. Our best-loved heroes were not ball artists in the Zlatanian sense but oak-hearted warriors such as Nat Lofthouse, the "Lion of Vienna". There was beauty in that too, as there was in the generosity of Hodgson's comments, which recalled the warmth in 1953 for the Hungarians who won 6-3 at Wembley to end England's unbeaten home record. Rather than resenting the defeat, English fans fell in love with "the Magical Magyars".

In the beginning, as they say, was the word, and it seems there may be some connection between the ability to talk about the game in an original and beautiful way and to play it in an original and beautiful way.

Dennis Bergkamp was one of the most interesting of all footballing artists. Arsenal supporters voted his goal at Newcastle in 2002 the best they had ever seen. But he dissented. "It was not pure," he explained. If the defender had anticipated the touch and spin he could have stopped the goal.

And while the English fall back in amazement at the skills of Ibrahimovic, Johan Cruyff – perhaps the greatest and certainly the most influential footballer of modern times – was less impressed. "For a bad player his technique is rather good," he said in 2010. "And for a good player his technique is rather bad."


David Winner

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Twenty international goals that rival Zlatan Ibrahimovic's overhead kick

Zlatan Ibrahimovic's outrageous strike against England has been called the greatest of all time. Is it even the best goal scored in international football? Here are 20 other contenders

Paul Campbell

15, Nov, 2012 @12:37 PM

Article image
Zlatan Ibrahimovic's best goals

The Sweden striker is a rare breed: a great goalscorer and a scorer of great goals. Here are some memorable finishes

Paul Campbell

15, Nov, 2012 @11:15 AM

Article image
Zlatan Ibrahimovic's strike was outrageous but no match for Di Stefáno | David Lacey
David Lacey: The Sweden striker scored a fine goal against England but it was only a friendly and its worth was distorted by TV

David Lacey

16, Nov, 2012 @12:15 PM

Article image
Was Zlatan Ibrahimovic's wonder strike really the greatest goal ever? | Sachin Nakrani
Sachin Nakrani: The Sweden striker's fourth gaol against England was a masterpiece – but it falls down in the big debate on the question of context

Sachin Nakrani

15, Nov, 2012 @1:41 PM

Article image
Sweden 4-2 England | International friendly match report

Steven Caulker scored on his debut for England but Zlatan Ibrahimovic stole the limelight with four goals – saving the best until last

Daniel Taylor at Friends Arena

14, Nov, 2012 @9:41 PM

Article image
Steven Gerrard: Zlatan Ibrahimovic goal was best I've ever seen

Steven Gerrard was full of praise for Zlatan Ibrahimovic, who scored all four of Sweden's goals in 4-2 win against England

Dominic Fifield at Friends Arena

15, Nov, 2012 @12:34 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on supporting England: much more than a game | Editorial
Editorial: Nations tell stories of themselves to make sense of their experience. We hope that England provides a happy ending


06, Jul, 2018 @3:56 PM

Article image
Zlatan Ibrahimovic: I liked the first goal more because it was history
The Swedish striker described his glorious fourth goal as merely 'nice' and suggested to score four for his country against England was 'not bad'

Dominic Fifield at Friends Arena

15, Nov, 2012 @12:32 AM

Article image
Zlatan Ibrahimovic’s Swedish national anthem streamed 3m times
Zlatan Ibrahimovic has received a gold record award after his rendition of the Swedish national anthem was streamed three million times in his native country

Guardian sport

12, Oct, 2015 @1:49 PM

Article image
Was Zlatan Ibrahimovic's wonder strike really the greatest goal ever?

The Guardian's sports editor Ian Prior gives his take on the reaction to Zlatan Ibrahimovic's overhead kick

Ian Prior, Mustafa Khalili and Alex Healey

15, Nov, 2012 @5:57 PM