Student loans: entry fees | Editorial

The likely appointment of Professor Les Ebdon at Offa is a step in the right direction – but does not solve the underlying problem

University entrance is in a mess. It is a mess that is damaging to individual students whose potential is wasted, and damaging to an economy which cannot compete without an expanding, well-educated workforce. Up to now, coalition policy has made matters worse rather than better. The good news is that the appointment of the University of Bedford's Professor Les Ebdon to the Office for Fair Access is a small step in the right direction. But it has come only after a spurious political row, and it does nothing to address the real problem underlying access to higher education.

Conservatives are neuralgic about a perceived falling-off in standards, and some suspected that Professor Ebdon, who has defended newer degree subjects like media studies against critics who say they cannot be intellectually challenging, would undermine admissions autonomy with his power to cap the fees universities charge if they failed to improve access. In a highly unorthodox move, a group of Tories on the Commons business committee, apparently encouraged by the education secretary Michael Gove – and, it was said, some independent schools and Russell Group universities – told the business secretary Vince Cable to look again for a new boss for Offa. Happily, after David Cameron said he had no power to oppose it, on Monday the appointment is expected to be confirmed.

The particular Tory target was the idea of contextual admissions – that is, recognising that students from less academic schools often do better at university than those from selective schools who got similar A-level grades. Mr Gove says his schools reforms will lever up results: not soon enough, say the Lib Dems, and especially not, say Labour MPs, when policies like education maintenance allowance that made a difference were early victims of austerity.

In a piece of window dressing, discontented Tories were told that the abandonment of plans for an early-repayment penalty on the higher student loans that start in September was a quid pro quo for Professor Ebdon. In fact, as the LSE expert Nicholas Barr and the NUS president Liam Burns both point out, the generous loan structure means early repayment would rarely make sense in narrow financial terms. Of course the odd well-heeled parent may be determined to clear the debt of their graduate child, and that leaves a sour taste in a world where everyone else will be repaying for decades.

The real issue, however, remains entirely ignored. The generous terms of the loan come at a cost which is deemed to preclude an overall increase in the number of students. Sold as a way of keeping up the numbers in higher education, they are actually working against it.

• This article was amended on 20 February 2012 to clarify a reference to neuralgia.


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Tory MPs veto Vince Cable's choice of university access tsar
Conservative MPs reject Lib Dems' choice for university admissions chief Prof Les Ebdon, a critic of higher tuition fees

Jessica Shepherd, education correspondent

08, Feb, 2012 @6:26 PM

Article image
Student fees protest leaves ministers shaken but not shocked
The coalition's six-month cuts window bangs shut as Nick Clegg takes the heat after U-turn

Nicholas Watt, chief political correspondent

10, Nov, 2010 @8:52 PM

Article image
Higher education shouldn't be a market. No wonder tuition fees are failing | Hugh Muir

Hugh Muir: First thoughts: All that pain, all that argument, to bring in the £9,000 fees cap – now it's close to costing us more than it's made. So why bother?

Hugh Muir

21, Mar, 2014 @10:33 AM

Letters: Fair access and social engineering
Letters: We hope Les Ebdon will stick to his principles in the face of a huge backlash in the rightwing press and among Tory backbenchers

27, Feb, 2012 @9:00 PM

Article image
Tuition fees do not need to rise further, says Nick Clegg

Under attack in the Commons, deputy prime minister accuses Labour of trying to make 'political mischief' over student debt

Rowena Mason, political correspondent

25, Mar, 2014 @3:00 PM

Article image
AC Grayling has caricatured British universities. No wonder they're fuming | Simon Jenkins

Simon Jenkins: The New College of Humanities founder has exposed higher education as a luxury consumable for the middle classes

Simon Jenkins

09, Jun, 2011 @9:00 PM

Article image
Student fees protest: 'This is just the beginning'

Conservative party headquarters attacked in what ministers acknowledge is likely to be 'just the beginning'

Jeevan Vasagar, Paul Lewis and Nicholas Watt

10, Nov, 2010 @9:38 PM

Letters: The Lib dems and democracy
Letters: The Lib Dems are virtually a spent force in politics, their sole residual role being to ease through vicious Tory legislation by toning it down a tiny bit

11, Dec, 2010 @12:07 AM

Article image
Ed Miliband condemns rise in university tuition fees - video

Labour leader Ed Miliband says the coalition's policy on fees could result in university places being cut

19, Apr, 2011 @1:50 PM

Article image
Student fees: Liberal Democrat MPs braced for 'doorstep' protests

Security at constituency offices stepped up ahead of marches, sit-ins and walkouts planned for Wednesday over proposed rises

Paul Lewis and Matthew Taylor

22, Nov, 2010 @7:50 PM