The Romney-Ryan ticket: right – and wrong | Editorial

Mitt Romney is gambling by assuming that the whole of US has lurched further to the right

The choreography of the Washington tango – skip to the extremes during the primaries, tack to the centre once they're locked up – used to be routine. Expectations that a different Mitt Romney might suddenly emerge in the general election were all the greater, seeing as he had previously skidded around so much. The son of a respected Republican moderate, and a governor in liberal Massachusetts who put Obamaesque healthcare in place, he only veered off to the right when the courting of militant Republican activists demanded it.

But a bad trip abroad has already scotched hopes of a tack to the centre on foreign policy, and now – with Paul Ryan's nomination for the vice-presidency – there is scant hope of moderation on the economy either. Mr Romney's own post-primaries words on the deficit have had a certain artful ambiguity. No one could accuse Mr Ryan – who greatly enthuses Rupert Murdoch – of that. As the chair of the House budget committee, he produced an answer to the (genuine) problems of rebalancing the books that was lunatic in its lopsidedness.

Instead of banking the future revenue that should flow automatically from the eventual recovery, as fiscal conservatives of Mr Romney's father era would eagerly have done, the Ryan proposals envisaged holding the tax take down so that the need for spending cuts is redoubled. Even if cuts on the Ryan scale could be carried off without immediately killing the economy, they would very likely end in the deaths of many poor Americans. The US already has the highest infant mortality in the rich world, and the Ryan plan would further shred the medical safety net. It would trash American science, hurt veterans and even affect the Republicans' cherished military.

Under the plan, the elderly's popular Medicare entitlements would be replaced by subsidies for private insurance, shattering security and requiring the typical beneficiary to shell out thousands of extra dollars each year. Anticipating the outrage, the Romney campaign immediately claimed that the Ryan appointment did not equate to endorsement of every detail of the Ryan plan.

Be that as it may, as a result of his choice, Mr Romney must prove to America that he is bent on undoing not merely the Obama social reforms but also those of the Johnson and Roosevelt years. The foaming reactionary fringe has moved further to the right in the US; Mr Romney is gambling that the country as a whole is moving in the same direction.


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
How the Republican party sabotaged itself: the real story of the 2012 election | Michael Cohen

Michael Cohen: As America's demographic facts shifted in favour of Democrats, the GOP chose instead to paint itself into an ideological corner

Michael Cohen

05, Nov, 2012 @5:59 PM

Article image
Romney-Ryan, counterintuitive champions of Medicare | Joshua Treviño

Joshua Treviño: With the Ryan plan foregrounding Medicare, Republicans are making virtue of necessity: embracing a defence of entitlements

Joshua Treviño

20, Aug, 2012 @8:08 PM

Article image
Mitt Romney acquires risky asset in Paul Ryan for VP | Joshua Treviño

Joshua Treviño: The Ryan plan's author has merits and liabilities, but his co-option reveals a hollowness at the core of the Romney campaign

Joshua Treviño

11, Aug, 2012 @2:28 PM

Article image
Paul Ryan and the paradox of US politics | Peter Beaumont

Peter Beaumont: Amid greater polarisation, winning centrist independent voters is more vital than ever. Which makes Romney's VP pick so baffling

Peter Beaumont

15, Aug, 2012 @2:14 PM

Article image
How Mitt Romney lost his mojo: he forgot the economy | James Antle

James Antle: The GOP nominee has jeopardised his chances by moving off his central message of job-creation and economic competence

James Antle

02, Oct, 2012 @5:58 PM

Article image
Tomasky Talk: Farewell predictions for 2012 - video

In his last ever Tomasky Talk, Michael looks into the future of the 2012 Republican nomination race, the presidential election itself and how taxation will be the clincher

Michael Tomasky and Jeff Spross

29, Apr, 2011 @9:53 PM

Article image
Obamacare gets my vote: Romney and Ryan's alternative nearly killed me | Clancy Sigal

Clancy Sigal: I'm critical of Obama's presidency, but my medical emergency convinced me that for Obamacare alone we must re-elect him

Clancy Sigal

13, Oct, 2012 @12:00 PM

Article image
How a Paul Ryan Wisconsin effect could alter the US political map | Harry J Enten

Harry J Enten: Early polling suggests little bounce from Mitt Romney's VP pick. But if Ryan delivers Wisconsin, that could all change

Harry J Enten

17, Aug, 2012 @5:57 PM

Article image
Romney introduces VP pick Paul Ryan as part of 'comeback team' GOP ticket

Decision to choose ultra-conservative Tea Party hero will offer voters a stark choice from Barack Obama's fiscal politics

Ewen MacAskill in Washington

11, Aug, 2012 @2:55 PM

Article image
Why the next two weeks may be make-or-break for Romney-Ryan | Harry J Enten

Harry J Enten: Presidential election polling is tight, but consistently shows Obama ahead. Romney needs a convention bounce … or bust

Harry J Enten

24, Aug, 2012 @5:37 PM