Madonna don't preach | Emma Brockes

Good for Madge, sticking up for Pussy Riot and pissing off Marine Le Pen. But as a rule, she does pop better than politics

Good old Madge, stepping up for fellow artists Pussy Riot against the Russian authorities.

"I think art should be political," she said this week, when asked by reporters to comment on the band's arrest for "hooliganism", and prior to her tour date in Moscow tonight. "Historically speaking, art always reflects what's going on socially".

It's been a busy few weeks for Madonna on that front, as she counters legal action by France's Marine Le Pen for featuring her in an unflattering video montage. At least, that is how Le Pen has chosen to see it. Before the president of the Front National flashes up on screen with a swastika across her forehead, we see various iterations of Madonna – her little face peering out of a hijab; the top half of her head combined with the Ayatollah's beardy chin; wearing what I think is General Pinochet's hat; definitely a shot of Sarah Palin's eyes in there and, possibly, former president Mobutu's leopard print fedora; finally, Madonna again wearing a Hitler moustache, while, in the background, she sings, "It's no good when you're misunderstood."

I think this is called irony, but who knows. As commentary, it has the same political content as a game of Guess Who? (Deluxe Dictators Edition).

The singer did have a chance to be political last year with the release of WE, her biopic of lovable old Nazi sympathizers Wallace Simpson and Edward VIII. Madge vigorously countered claims she was glamorising their dubious politics by insisting she had looked into it thoroughly and determined that they did nothing improper – an assertion she underlines in the movie by having a character point out that although the pair were wined and dined by Hitler, it was in 1937, before he had done anything too naughty. (The Nuremberg laws, prohibiting Jews from enjoying German citizenship, were introduced in 1935, and concentration camps for political prisoners had been opening since 1933, but why be a bore about it?)

The sad thing is, Madge doesn't need to do anything particular to be political. She is at her most political when she does nothing at all. Like Gaga, the very fact of her – her continued success in a marketplace where most female pop stars look like the Pussycat Dolls – is all the argument she needs. If only she'd leave it at that.

Contributor

Emma Brockes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Madonna shows support for Pussy Riot at Moscow concert – video

During her performance at Moscow's Olimpsky Stadium, Madonna takes her jacket off revealing the words Pussy Riot written on her back

08, Aug, 2012 @7:03 AM

Article image
Madonna: Pussy Riot verdict is 'inhumane'
Singer condemns conviction of Russian musicians, urging artists around the world to 'protest against this travesty'

Sean Michaels

20, Aug, 2012 @10:57 AM

Article image
Pussy Riot: Madonna supports punk trio at concert in Russia

Singer condemns persecution of the band by appearing on stage in Moscow with a balaclava and 'Pussy Riot' written on her back

Miriam Elder in Moscow

07, Aug, 2012 @10:28 PM

Article image
Russia hints at visa obstacles for western pop acts after gay row

Madonna, Lady Gaga and Bloodhound Gang have all voiced public disapproval of Russian anti-gay laws. But in future, promoters could find it harder to get US artists into the country, says Alec Luhn

Alec Luhn

16, Aug, 2013 @5:36 PM

Article image
Madonna and Lady Gaga accused of breaking Russian visa rules
Vitaly Milonov, politician behind St Petersburg's law banning gay 'propaganda', leads efforts to charge outspoken singers

Sean Michaels

02, Aug, 2013 @11:21 AM

Article image
Do women who have had sex always tell lies? | Jane Clare Jones

Jane Clare Jones: The credibility of a woman's voice is often undermined by sexual slurs – as rape victims, Madonna and Pussy Riot well know

Jane Clare Jones

13, Aug, 2012 @8:30 AM

Article image
Madonna backs Russia's Pussy Riot at Moscow concert - video

In Moscow to perform a concert, Madonna urges the Russian authorities not to jail the three women from punk band Pussy Riot

07, Aug, 2012 @9:24 AM

Article image
Sophie Ellis-Bextor: girls today are encouraged to display their sexuality

Singer says the issue of sexuality seen as empowering thing is really sensitive for people with young daughters

Maev Kennedy

05, Jan, 2014 @7:32 PM

Article image
Freed Pussy Riot member pledges to continue protests

Yekaterina Samutsevich claims they will 'deceive the authorities' to perform again and denies any split in the group's ranks

Sean Michaels

11, Oct, 2012 @11:04 AM

Article image
Q&A with Naomi Wolf: why do people hate Madonna? | Naomi Wolf

Naomi Wolf: On Monday, I argued that Madonna courts trouble because she is, unapologetically, a serious artist. What do you think?

Naomi Wolf

10, Feb, 2012 @4:27 PM