The terror of Babar Ahmad | Victoria Brittain

The Islamophobia behind his seven-year ordeal in prison fighting extradition can no longer be ignored

As Stephen Lawrence's parents sat in court this week, they were a reminder to us of how their son became the trigger for a self-critical look into the dark side of British institutional racism, thanks to Lord Macpherson's inquiry. Eighteen years after the Lawence murder, the case of Babar Ahmad may be poised to trigger another, equally explosive outcry into the institutional racism and Islamophobia that have allowed him to remain in a high security prison in Britain for more than seven years fighting extradition to the US. The Crown Prosecution Service has refused to prosecute him for the crimes that the US alleges he has committed here.

The Ahmad case became explosive when family and friends amassed 140,000 signatures on an e-petition for a parliamentary debate on his right to a trial here. In places like Bradford and Luton, young people mobilised by mosques, youth leaders and social networking have made their first forays into mainstream politics – deluging MPs with letters and emails.

The initial response of the backbench business committee last week was to tag this e-petition on to a pre-arranged debate on extradition to be held not in the main chamber, but in Westminster Hall. The MPs involved appeared unaware of, or impervious to, the groundswell of real anger among young people in particular, who felt disrespected by the MPs' decision. And the outrage went much broader, with more than 100 lawyers, including QCs, writing to the leader of the house, Sir George Young, asking for a full debate.

Last Tuesday backbench MPs decided that on Monday there will after all be a debate on a motion "to reform the UK's extradition laws as a matter of urgency to strengthen the protection of British citizens …". But it does not mention Ahmad and the e-petition, with Dominic Raab – the MP who was instrumental in securing the debate – refusing to insert the key phrase "pending cases" into the motion, which would have included people facing extradition. This is not the democratic outcome of listening to 140,000 people's voices.

Five other men, including three Britons, are in the same position of having been fighting extradition to the US for years from prisons in the UK, where they are accused of no crime. The stress on their lives can be gauged from the fact that one has been moved to Broadmoor after a breakdown in the special detainee unit where Ahmad is held.

Ahmad's ordeal has had particular resonance in part because of the saga of the 73 injuries he received during his arrest, and his subsequent court case against the officers involved. In 2009 the Metropolitan police made an unprecedented admission that officers subjected Ahmad to a brutal beating causing multiple injuries, and offered him £60,000 compensation. The case exposed shocking behaviour by some officers, in which racism and islamophobia were overt; and incompetence, or worse, lay behind the curious disappearance of many sacks of vital evidence.

Two years later, in a criminal case against the officers, the jury was not told of the Met's admissions, or the payment it had offered, and the four officers concerned were found not guilty.

The stigma of terrorism is behind this story of abuse and corner-cutting by police, compounded by an attempted cover-up in court – which failed once and succeeded the second time. Only last week it was revealed that the police, with extraordinary laxity, in 2003 sent material gathered from his house to the US, without showing it to the Crown Prosecution Service. Along the way, the Home Office, and regrettably some MPs, have failed to see the huge resonance of this case for Britain.


Victoria Brittain

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Babar Ahmad and the injustice of the US/UK extradition laws | Victoria Brittain
Victoria Brittain: In the eight years Ahmad has been locked up without charge, a situation has developed that MPs of all sides call Kafkaesque

Victoria Brittain

06, Apr, 2012 @12:07 PM

Article image
Babar Ahmad case: we must not outsource our criminal justice system | David Bermingham
David Bermingham: The DPP should be bold and take over a private prosecution, so that two terrorism suspects avoid US extradition

David Bermingham

11, Sep, 2012 @11:50 AM

Article image
Breaking the spell of the official terrorism narrative | Arun Kundnani and Jeanne Theoharis
Arun Kundnani and Jeanne Theoharis: The UK government tried to disappear Talha Ahsan and Babar Ahmad to the US, but the basic rules of evidence were unexpectedly applied

Arun Kundnani and Jeanne Theoharis

23, Jul, 2014 @6:00 AM

Article image
Is it justice to lock up Babar Ahmad so long without trial? | Mehdi Hasan

Mehdi Hasan: Babar Ahmad has spent seven years behind bars fighting a US extradition warrant. Innocent or not, he deserves a fair hearing here

Mehdi Hasan

06, Nov, 2011 @10:30 PM

Article image
Babar Ahmad seeks injunction to prevent extradition to US
Terrorism suspect joins Khaled al-Fawwaz and Abu Hamza in lodging appeal after last week's rejection by European court

Owen Bowcott, legal affairs correspondent

01, Oct, 2012 @1:27 PM

Letters: Why I launched a private prosecution against Babar Ahmad and Talha Ahsan
Letters: Our criminal justice system should deliver on its duty by ensuring that these two British citizens, alleged to have committed very serious crimes in the UK, are tried and, if appropriate, imprisoned here

12, Sep, 2012 @8:00 PM

Article image
Abu Hamza extradition ruling should be a wake-up call to the legal system | Richard Norton-Taylor
Richard Norton-Taylor: The UK and US in particular must stop treating security or terrorism cases as too sensitive for publication

Richard Norton-Taylor

10, Apr, 2012 @2:52 PM

Article image
Deport Abu Qatada: or if not, give him the law's full protection | Simon Jenkins
Simon Jenkins: Qatada champions al-Qaida and delights in terrorist outrages. But Britain is robust enough to tolerate madcap clerics

Simon Jenkins

07, Feb, 2012 @8:30 PM

Article image
Babar Ahmad ruling is a victory for freedom of expression | Joshua Rozenberg

Joshua Rozenberg: Clarke shows none of the usual stubbornness by not seeking to appeal against the BBC

Joshua Rozenberg

12, Jan, 2012 @11:10 AM

Article image
National liberty is at stake, as well as national security | Martin Kettle

Martin Kettle: The plan to hold secret court hearings is anti-terror reflex, imported at the behest of the US by the security services

Martin Kettle

04, Apr, 2012 @8:00 PM