Julia Gillard can turn things around | John McTernan

Kevin Rudd lost his populist touch and started to speak as a technocrat, but Gillard is a robust performer

"Kevin07, Gone by 11", was the taunt in Canberra when I was there last month – and so it proved. Kevin Rudd, who returned Labor to power in Australia after 12 years in opposition, and who achieved some of this highest approval ratings in Australian history, was unceremoniously dumped by his party today. What does this mean for the direction of the Australian government?

In broad political terms, probably not much. Though Julia Gillard is, in Labor factional terms, from the left, she was put there by the right. They made the same calculation as James Purnell did over Gordon Brown last year – that the party would go down to electoral defeat with its current leader. However, as Martin Kettle notes, the Australian Labor party has none of the sentimentality that dogs British Labour and it acted.

What went so badly wrong? Rudd was at his best when making big political stands – signing Kyoto and making the apology to the indigenous people of Australia, and in particular the Stolen Generations. He was at his worst when he lost his populist touch and started to speak as a technocrat.

Ultimately, though, he lost his way over climate change. He called it the "greatest moral challenge of our time", but when facing parliamentary defeat deferred his legislation. His thoughtfulness became his undoing. A more populist leader would never have embarked on an emissions trading scheme in advance of other countries, a more Machiavellian one would have manoeuvred his legislation to defeat in the Senate at the joint hands of the Greens and the Liberals. Kevin Rudd chose to delay. That caused a catastrophic rupture with voters. Young urban voters split to the Greens and middle Australians to the Liberals. This left Labor facing a wipeout.

Can Gillard turn it round? Almost certainly. She has grown in stature as deputy prime minister and was responsible for education – a central pillar of the domestic reform agenda – and the difficult industrial relations portfolio. She is a robust parliamentary performer, more than able to hold her own in what is a far more rowdy chamber than the House of Commons. In opposition, she was named by the Speaker and excluded for 24 hours for calling Tony Abbott "a snivelling grub". (I was in the opposition box that day: it was a towering performance.)

And she is a very effective communicator who more than has the measure of the Liberal leader, Tony Abbott – with whom she has often sparred in good-nature when appearing on television together. Abbott's populism rattled Rudd who couldn't find a voice to deal effectively with it. But Abbott's appeal to the Liberal base is more than balanced by his difficulty with women voters. He is a devout Catholic who is on the record as saying that women should not give away their virginity lightly. Gillard led the attack.

Women are probably the key swing group in the forthcoming election. If she can draw a line under Rudd's errors, get a grip and establish competence quickly, Julia Gillard is likely to get Labor back on track for re-election. After all, there's been no one-term Australian government since the 1930s.


John McTernan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Julia Gillard: Canberra's soap opera | Editorial

Editorial: In the past week, Australia's Labor party has made Britain's New Labour look like a gentlemen's club


27, Feb, 2012 @10:00 PM

Julia 'moving forward' Gillard seems to be going backwards | Judith Ireland
Judith Ireland: The fresh new face of the Australian government has spent her first month copying Kevin Rudd, the man she deposed

Judith Ireland

29, Jul, 2010 @6:00 AM

Article image
Julia Gillard: Labor's love lost | Editorial

Editorial: The real winner of Labor's years of infighting and meltdown in the polls has been opposition leader Tony Abbott


26, Jun, 2013 @10:25 PM

Article image
Julia Gillard becomes Australia's first female prime minister

Sudden change of leadership comes after Kevin Rudd steps down rather than face Labor party ballot

Ellen Connolly in Sydney

24, Jun, 2010 @7:57 AM

Article image
Julia Gillard holds on as prime minister – in pictures

Photographs from a remarkable day in Australian politics when Julia Gillard headed off an attempt to remove her as the leader of her Labor party and the prime ministership

Pictures: Penny Bradfield and agencies. Text: Warren Murray

21, Mar, 2013 @12:14 PM

Article image
Australian prime minister Julia Gillard calls for Labor party leadership ballot

Decision to settle matter 'once and for all' follows the resignation of the country's foreign minister, Kevin Rudd

Alison Rourke in Sydney

22, Feb, 2012 @1:23 PM

Article image
Julia Gillard now leads 'most unpopular Australian government in past 40 years'

A year after prime minister ousted previous Labor leader Kevin Rudd, only one in four Australians say they would vote for her

Alison Rourke in Sydney and agencies

18, Jun, 2011 @11:01 AM

Article image
Julia Gillard: The ten pound Pom who became prime minister of Australia
Family and friends pay tributes to 'little Julia', who takes over after Kevin Rudd steps down as Labor party leader

Steven Morris in Barry and Ellen Connolly in Sydney

24, Jun, 2010 @8:51 PM

Article image
Kevin Rudd challenges Julia Gillard over the Australian premiership – video

Former foreign minister and ex-PM will challenge Julia Gillard for leadership of the Labor party and the position of prime minister

24, Feb, 2012 @10:45 AM

Article image
Australia's gets new PM in British-born Julia Gillard as Rudd steps down

British-born Julia Gillard becomes Australia's first female PM as Rudd blames plotters within the party

Mark Tran

24, Jun, 2010 @12:25 AM