In praise of… Mahler in the north

Editorial: Mancunian audiences are less demonstrative than Berliners. But last Saturday, when the city's three orchestras launched a collaborative cycle of the complete Mahler symphonies, at least three people rose to their feet

No reporters turned up at the airport on Sir John Barbirolli's return from a triumphant performance of Mahler's ninth with the Berlin Philharmonic in 1963. So the much-loved conductor of Manchester's Hallé rang the Guardian's Michael Morris to tell excitedly of 11 standing ovations. Mancunian audiences, then and now, are less demonstrative than Berliners: a Manchester ovation is defined as one person rising in Bridgewater Hall. But last Saturday, when the city's three orchestras launched a collaborative cycle of the complete Mahler symphonies, at least three people rose to their feet as conductor Gianandrea Noseda was repeatedly called back to the platform after the BBC Philharmonic's white-hot rendering of the first. The applause was as much for the project as the performance; 10 more concerts, five each by the BBC Philharmonic and the Hallé, and one by the Manchester Camerata, are to follow over five months, each to include a new commission from a wide range of composers. This collaboration between friendly rivals would be unlikely elsewhere in Britain: London has the means to do it, but hasn't. The climax, in terms of both co-operation and noise, comes on 2 May when the BBC Phil and the Hallé combine to pack the Bridgewater Hall platform for a performance of the eighth, the Symphony of a Thousand. Meanwhile, the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic has started its own complete Mahler cycle, to be spread over two seasons. You can never have too much of a good Mahlerian thing.


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Editorial: In praise of ... Handel

Editorial: You cannot blame a baroque composer for composing baroque operas. Handel was himself alone


06, Mar, 2009 @12:01 AM

Leader: In praise of ... Chopin

Leader: Frederic Chopin was a pianist first and foremost


17, May, 2008 @12:23 AM

In praise of … conductors | Editorial
Editorial: It's easy to claim that orchestras would be better off with no one in charge on the podium. But just try it


11, Jan, 2011 @12:05 AM

In praise of … Brahms | Editorial
Editorial: Brahms's music still thrives thanks to his drive to express the most radical ideas within strictly established disciplines


18, Aug, 2011 @10:21 PM

Editorial: In praise of ... Odetta

Editorial: Some singers are so startling their names should be part of everyday musical vocabulary


05, Dec, 2008 @12:01 AM

In praise of… MaestroCam
Editorial: At five televised Proms this summer you can spend the whole evening focused entirely on the man on the podium


23, Aug, 2009 @11:05 PM

Editorial: In praise of ... Bireshwar Gautam

Editorial: Who on earth tries to make a living from a tradition of classical music that is close to dying out?


30, Jun, 2008 @11:01 PM

In praise of ... Elliott Carter

Editorial: Through all of his career, Carter has remained a wonderfully urbane and perceptive observer


08, Dec, 2008 @12:01 AM

In praise of ... Edward Downes | Editorial

Editorial: How sad that Edward Downes has become more famous in death than he was in life


14, Jul, 2009 @11:01 PM

In praise of … Stephen Sondheim | Editorial
Editorial: A well deserved lifetime achievement award from Critics Circle for the foremost composer-lyricist of his generation


08, Mar, 2012 @11:25 PM