The long term seems to be getting longer for online grocer Ocado | Nils Pratley

International adventures will be the crucial contributor but the UK operation is not irrelevant to the wider story

Tim Steiner, chief executive and co-founder of Ocado, has learned over 20 mostly loss-making years how to put a positive spin on the numbers, but he has excelled himself. As the group reported a thumping full-year loss of £501m, caused in large part by a huge earnings reversal in its UK joint venture with Marks & Spencer, Steiner claimed the same operation had “shown its resilience”.

Really? OK, the UK business added customers and online market share, but they were about the only metrics going in the desired direction. Turnover fell 3.8% as customers trimmed the size of their online baskets and top-line earnings from the joint venture collapsed from £150m to minus £4m. Rather than a show of resilience, this looked more like a demonstration of how the online grocery model can be horribly inflexible from the point of view of the operator.

During the pandemic lockdown period, Ocado’s problem was that it didn’t have enough capacity to meet the sudden boom in demand. Now, after expanding rapidly to capitalise on what Steiner claimed in 2021 would be “a dramatic and permanent shift towards online grocery shopping”, it faces the opposite challenge: too many warehouses and robots.

The gap between capacity and the actual level of sales at Ocado is enormous. A new distribution warehouse opened in Bicester this year and another is coming soon in Luton. At that point, the company says it could make 700,000 deliveries a week, equating to annual revenue of about £3.9bn. Actual orders last year were more like 400,000 a week and turnover was £2.2bn.

Demand will catch up eventually because nobody doubts the quality of Ocado’s customer offer and service. But, as the company concedes, the process could take years. In an attempt to stimulate demand and recover fixed costs, Ocado is now reinstating a limited price-match pledge with Tesco that it dropped a couple of years ago. The script wasn’t meant to be so complicated.

Still, optimistic shareholders might reflect, doesn’t the excitement lie in the deals and partnerships with 10 overseas food retailers to supply robots, warehouses and online expertise? Isn’t the real prize the annuity-like streams of income that will eventually flow from revenue-based contracts?

Well, yes and no. In the very long term, the international adventures – from France to the US to Korea – will indeed be the crucial contributor if Ocado’s share price of 549p is ever to get close again to the frothy £28 seen during Covid. But the UK operation is not irrelevant to the wider story.

It is, after all, “the shop window” for Ocado kit. Overseas partners may gasp admiringly at the wondrous net promoter scores achieved in the UK, but they may also want to be sure not to fall into the same trap of adding too much capacity too soon. M&S may now pay £70m less than the maximum under the terms of the 2019 joint venture deal, which is not a great advertisement.

Then there is the fact the UK business is also meant to contribute to Ocado’s big and shiny overall group target of £750m of Ebitda (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation) in 2027. The date is so far in the future that the current UK capacity mismatch should be resolved well before then. But annual performances along the way also matter because the hot debate in the City is whether the group will need to raise fresh capital (again) to fund its overseas expansion before the projected “inflexion point” of positive cashflow arrives 2027.

Ocado is sticking to all its mid-term targets, it should be said. There was no hint of backtracking. But one can also understand why the shares fell 12%. There were no positive surprises within these full-year numbers, just a reminder of how many plates Ocado has to keep spinning at home and abroad. As things stood in 2022, this was a “growth” business reporting an advance in group-wide revenues of a negligible 0.6% and reporting a pre-tax loss of half a billion quid. A triumph in 2027 feels a very long way off.

Contributor

Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
True believers in Ocado should not be tempted by Amazon | Nils Pratley
The speculated bid price of £8 today should not excite those who think a return to £28 is conceivable

Nils Pratley

22, Jun, 2023 @5:54 PM

Article image
Ocado's share boom is no indicator of longterm success | Nils Pratley
Value has risen on the back of smart tie-ups, but rapid expansion brings huge risks

Nils Pratley

10, Jul, 2018 @6:07 PM

Article image
Long-term shareholders must pray Ocado’s latest fundraiser is the last
The £575m is ‘to capitalise on opportunity over the medium term’. Is that the same ‘medium term’ as two years ago?

Nils Pratley

21, Jun, 2022 @6:38 PM

Article image
Dame Sharon White is right to signal her exit at John Lewis | Nils Pratley
Retail chief’s confused messaging has hinted at self-doubt and panic, even though the group is making reasonable progress

Nils Pratley

02, Oct, 2023 @5:00 PM

Article image
This is not just an AGM… M&S should at least give shareholders a cuppa | Nils Pratley
The Marks & Spencer chairman’s digital push is good for access – but shareholders should be encouraged to turn up

Nils Pratley

06, Jul, 2023 @1:25 PM

Article image
Ocado pauses building new warehouses as annual losses balloon to £500m
Decline in retail sales at online supermarket blamed on customers buying fewer items

Sarah Butler and Julia Kollewe

28, Feb, 2023 @8:21 AM

Article image
Ocado shares soar on takeover rumours
Largest shareholder says online supermarket should stay listed in UK after speculation Amazon among firms considering a bid

Joanna Partridge and Nils Pratley

22, Jun, 2023 @5:24 PM

Article image
Faith in Ocado’s global revolution feels increasingly fragile | Nils Pratley
Having had too little capacity during the Covid crisis, the business now has too much

Nils Pratley

13, Sep, 2022 @5:29 PM

Article image
Ocado ‘could sue’ M&S in dispute over £190m final payment
Marks & Spencer, which owns 50% of online grocer, is withholding part of the sum, saying targets were missed

Jack Simpson

29, Feb, 2024 @2:46 PM

Article image
Compass v Ocado proves bottom-line profits and dividends still matter | Nils Pratley
Don’t write off Ocado in very long term – but reversal also points to one of the stock market’s terrible habits

Nils Pratley

11, May, 2022 @5:57 PM