Morrisons’ new owner has plenty of wriggle room in takeover terms | Nils Pratley

CD&R has made fine-sounding pledges but they don’t stop this being yet another debt-fuelled buyout

The auction for Morrisons wasn’t worth the wait, but the mission to cast Clayton Dubilier & Rice as a kindly, far-sighted owner of the UK’s fourth largest supermarket chain continues at full swing. Andrew Higginson, chairman of Morrisons, did his bit by saying private equity sometimes gets “a bad rap” and generally makes its returns from businesses growing rather than via “financial engineering”.

Top marks for effort, but let’s not pretend that this deal, as it is structured at the outset, is markedly different from most debt-fuelled buyouts. First, the behavioural pledges offered by the buyer – covering sale and leaseback deals, staff pay and treatment of suppliers – don’t deserve the hype they have received. They are vague and only last for 12 months.

On possible property flips, for example, the new owner has said it “does not intend to engage in any material store sale and leaseback transactions”. What’s the definition of “material” in this context? Nobody has ever explained.

As for eschewing financial engineering, it’s hard to know if that is meant seriously. The takeover is worth roughly £10bn – £7bn for the equity plus £3bn of debt already borrowed by Morrisons – and CD&R has talked about investing equity capital of about £3.4bn. So debt could be £6.6bn, which is a mighty sum to load on to a business that made operating profits of £513m in its last pre-pandemic year. That degree of leverage is normally a mark of the financial engineer’s art.

There will be a plan to reduce borrowing, of course, but the cash probably can’t all be generated by running the business better (Morrisons was not badly managed) or by opening convenience stores at the 900 petrol stations owned by CD&R’s Motor Fuels Group. Disposals, think most analysts, must be part of the script.

Yes, of course, there will be growth projects on top. And, yes, CD&R’s reputation as a builder of companies is superior to that of most of its private equity peers. But, come on, this is still a leveraged buyout that relies on debt gymnastics, a fact that should not be lost amid the noise.

Sky plots next move in UK’s fibre expansion

Is Sky, now under the wing of the US cable and media group Comcast, about to upset BT’s plans for fibre broadband domination in the UK?

Well, it won’t derail the rollout because BT is committed to reaching 25m homes by 2026. But Sky has nuisance value on account of its 6 million broadband customers. If it were to throw in its lot with Virgin Media O2, BT’s only big rival in the digging business, the competitive dynamics would change. BT would still be the fibre leader on any likely projection of market share, but the challenger, in theory, would have greater financial confidence to lay more fibre more quickly.

The Sunday Telegraph’s report that Sky could invest in Virgin Media O2’s fibre network knocked 7% off BT’s share price at one point on Monday, a big move for a stock that had already been weak in recent weeks. The damage was contained to 4.7% by the close of the day, but nervousness in BT’s shareholder ranks is understandable.

By rights, Sky would be taking a huge commercial gamble by committing itself solely to the Virgin O2 network, either as an investor or just as a wholesale buyer of fibre capacity. It is hard to believe it would tie its hands that tightly: a deal with both big fibre players still feels more likely. But the terms of any alliance with Virgin O2 would still be annoying for BT.

The smart solution, of course, is to get the fibre in the ground faster. That’s easier said than done.

Next boss knows how to end supply chain crisis

Last week’s government spin said that supply chain strains had nothing to do with Brexit. This week’s explanation is that empty shelves and queues at forecourts are a necessary post-Brexit transition to a high-wage, high-productivity economy. The speed of the narrative rewriting is extraordinary.

By far the most sensible Tory voice on these matters is Simon Wolfson, chief executive of Next, who suggested in a column in the Evening Standard that the agonising over immigration could be resolved by allowing businesses to apply for as many work visas as they need but with two critical conditions. First, overseas workers could not be paid less than UK colleagues. Second, the employer would have to pay a 7% wage surcharge to the Treasury.

It’s an idea – indeed, a practical one that could form the basis of a compromise to satisfy all sides. One assumes, therefore, that it won’t get a hearing this week in Manchester.

Contributor

Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Apollo lands with the frontrunner in Morrisons takeover mission
By dropping solo bid plan and teaming up with Fortress, private equity firm is just one of the crew

Nils Pratley

20, Jul, 2021 @7:06 PM

Article image
Morrisons cuts sick pay for non-jabbed workers after ‘biblical’ pandemic costs
Pay changes part of plans to mitigate supply chain crisis as company prepares to be auctioned off amid profit slump

Jasper Jolly, Sarah Butler and Mark Sweney

09, Sep, 2021 @5:27 PM

Article image
Bankers and advisers would net £275m from Morrisons takeover
Documents reveal fees US private equity firm Fortress proposes for financing deal and for broking and legal advice

Jasper Jolly

22, Jul, 2021 @8:57 AM

Article image
Morrisons pension trustees raise concerns over £7bn takeover plan
Trustees say more protection should be put in place before shareholders vote on private equity deal

Zoe Wood

24, Aug, 2021 @6:36 PM

Article image
Morrisons writes to reassure anxious UK farmers over US takeover
CEO’s letter to 3,000 suppliers reaffirms grocer’s unique dealings with British agriculture

Joanna Partridge

11, Jul, 2021 @3:56 PM

Article image
Apollo in talks to join Fortress-led £6.3bn takeover of Morrisons
US private equity firm’s move cuts chance of takeover battle for UK supermarket group

Julia Kollewe

20, Jul, 2021 @8:05 AM

Article image
Morrisons in talks with suitors and regulator to begin takeover auction
Supermarket works on basis that offers from US private equity firms CD&R and Fortress are not final

Joanna Partridge

08, Sep, 2021 @7:42 AM

Article image
Labour urges government to protect Morrisons in potential private equity takeover
Opposition MPs say ministers must stop company falling victim to asset-stripping as share price rises

Rob Davies

22, Jun, 2021 @6:23 PM

Article image
Fortress-led group increases offer for Morrisons to £6.7bn
Majestic Wine owner attempts to fend off rival suitor and win over reluctant shareholders

Sarah Butler

06, Aug, 2021 @4:38 PM

Article image
Morrisons shares expected to surge as private equity groups circle
At least three groups thought to be looking at grocer, which has accepted a takeover bid from Fortress

Miles Brignall

04, Jul, 2021 @4:16 PM