GSK’s changes leave a long road ahead but CEO Walmsley deserves a hearing

Emma Walmsley still has time to build belief in product pipeline – but clinging onto consumer division hardly shouts confidence

“I am a change agent,” declared Emma Walmsley, as she unveiled the biggest overhaul of GlaxoSmithKline in the 20-odd years of the company’s life in its current form. The consumer healthcare division will depart via a plain-vanilla demerger next year; shareholders will have to live with a sharply reduced dividend; and “new GSK” will seek salvation for its rotten share price by investing more heavily in its core business of pharmaceuticals and vaccines.

That’s the outline of the changes, but the edges went a little blurry on close inspection. Why will GSK retain up to 20% of its two-thirds stake in a consumer business as a “short-term financial investment”? Possibly because it wants to cling to the comfort blanket of the consumer division’s reliable cashflows a little longer.

That decision hardly shouts confidence. If you believe Sensodyne toothpaste and Panadol painkillers shouldn’t be housed under the same roof as state-of-the-art prescription immunotherapy medicines – an entirely reasonable view – just make it happen in one go. As it is, shareholders have been waiting for the demerger since December 2018, the date of the first announcement.

Still, the two-step plan was the minor part of the grand vision. The bigger question centred on the sales and profits targets for the “new” pharma and vaccines business. Answer: compound rates of 5% and 10% respectively for the next five years. Walmsley also promised that £10bn of cash would be generated in the same period, and said growth would continue after 2026, notwithstanding the loss of a patent on an important HIV treatment.

By GSK’s recent standards, such growth would count as electric. The numbers were also more bullish than expected, even if investors, inevitably, are being asked to take a lot on trust. The case for optimism is that it took three years for AstraZeneca to convince the outside world it would hit the seemingly ambitious revenues targets it set in 2014 to fend off assault by Pfizer. The gloomier view is that this is GSK, home of false dawns.

That is why, one suspects, the whispering campaign around Walmsley’s position won’t disappear overnight. In theory, it’s far too simplistic to say the chief executive of GSK must be a pure scientist. If Walmsley, whose background is on the consumer side, appoints the right scientists to allocate capital to pharma projects, there shouldn’t be a problem.

In practice, the grumbling won’t stop until the share price improves. It’s picked up 10% since Elliott Management was revealed in March to have taken a “multibillion” stake, but Wednesday’s £14.09, up 1% on the day, is nobody’s idea of a triumph. Various analysts’ sum-of-the-parts calculations put a theoretical value of £20 a share on GSK.

Closing that gap is the challenge for Walmsley. There’s still a year to go until the demerger actually happens, so she has time to build belief in the pipeline and try to excite investors. The wrinkle in the demerger mechanics doesn’t help, but GSK does not need boardroom upheaval right now. Investors should give her a fair hearing.

Andrew Bailey cleared of misleading LC&F inquiry – but row was still ridiculous

“We do not believe Mr Bailey misled the committee,” says the Treasury select committee, addressing the bizarre subplot to the London Capital & Finance affair – the furious public row between Andrew Bailey, formerly head of the Financial Conduct Authority but now governor of the Bank of England, and Dame Elizabeth Gloster over the naming of individuals in her official report on the regulatory failure.

It’s just as well the MPs think Bailey played straight in his evidence to them. Any other conclusion would have raised questions over his suitability to continue in his current job.

Sadly, the MPs did not find room to address the separate matter of whether it was sensible for the governor of the Bank to engage in verbal fisticuffs with Gloster on a minor point about the construction of her report. After all, the facts of the report itself, detailing multiple red flags being ignored by the FCA on Bailey’s watch, were damning. In the end, the taxpayers shelled out £120m to compensate individuals who lost money in LC&F’s mini-bonds.

But perhaps the answer to the “was it wise?” question is obvious: it was ridiculous of Bailey to pick the fight.


Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
New Bank of England governor approved (sort of)
Ex-City watchdog chief Andrew Bailey didn’t exactly get a ringing endorsement from MPs, more of a ‘he’ll do, I suppose’

Nils Pratley

05, Mar, 2020 @8:02 PM

Article image
Even Trump's Twitter binges aren't enough to make it worth $11bn | Nils Pratley
Twitter chief says he is proud daily usage is rising, but revenues just fell and profits are nowhere to be seen

Nils Pratley

27, Apr, 2017 @6:30 AM

Article image
GSK’s Emma Walmsley vows to lead drugs firm through corporate split
CEO is under pressure to improve GSK’s performance after profit slump and arrival of activist shareholder

Julia Kollewe

28, Apr, 2021 @5:22 PM

Article image
Bank of England deserves to be embarrassed about security breach
FCA must now decide how serious breach really is – and who to blame

Nils Pratley

19, Dec, 2019 @2:53 PM

Article image
Time to dig deep? Big miners face a big problem
Most industrial commodities are oversupplied, with the feared slowdown in China deepening miners’ woes

Nils Pratley

24, Sep, 2015 @6:54 PM

Article image
QuickQuid director's FCA role lacked common sense | Nils Pratley
Nick Lord’s committee position was a strange way for watchdog to show it cares about protecting consumers

Nils Pratley

31, Oct, 2019 @10:49 AM

Article image
LC&F collapse calls the regulator's competence into question Nils Pratley
The now bust purveyor of ‘mini bonds’ left 11,500 ordinary investors £236m out of pocket

Nils Pratley

23, May, 2019 @6:48 PM

Article image
The FCA – a watchdog too nice and chummy to bark or bite
Outgoing boss tells MPs why regulator couldn’t do much about one claim of wrongdoing after another

Phillip Inman

25, Jun, 2019 @6:24 PM

Article image
Nissan hasn’t put UK ahead in electric race, it’s just off the starting grid
The first stage of the Nissan project in Sunderland will deliver 9GWh of capacity but there is a very long way to go in this ‘race’

Nils Pratley

01, Jul, 2021 @7:03 PM

Article image
Saga looks horribly exposed as hedge fund Elliott buys 5% stake
Over-50s specialist vulnerable to having its insurance arm split away from its cruise operation

Nils Pratley

17, Jul, 2019 @7:02 PM