We wait to see if, when push comes to shove, the holdout landlords really will vote against Arcadia’s demand for rent cuts for a second time. Intu is determined to say no to Sir Philip Green, but it is the biggest and thus has most to lose in terms of rental income. Waverers may conclude they’ve made their point that CVAs are not a slam dunk for struggling retailers and quietly fall into line. Green could still get his way.

It would be the best outcome in terms of saving jobs, since Green may be serious about his threat to force the business, employing 18,000 people, into administration if landlords vote down the CVA proposal.

From his point of view, the consequences of collapse are not as severe as they may sound. Green’s reputation would take another hit, but he’s probably beyond caring. Arcadia’s pension fund, complete with a deficit of £750m on one accounting measure, would fall into the Pension Protection Fund and, unlike at BHS, the Pensions Regulator would struggle to chase him for serious top-up payments. Green would be likely to plead, accurately, that he made an offer on pensions that was accepted by the regulator but the blasted landlords got in the way.

Such an argument would still be outrageous, of course. Green and his wife paid themselves a £1.2bn dividend from Arcadia in 2005 and could, in any subsequent year, have chosen to hand back some of their winnings to repair the pension deficit. Instead, they still cruise the Mediterranean in a superyacht.

For parallel reasons, you see why Intu is furious. If it agrees rental concessions to a billionaire sunning himself in the waters off Monaco, what’s it supposed to say to other tenants who would also like to pay less? On the other hand, Intu is kidding itself if it thinks it can seriously halt the slide in rental values in retail land. After three upwards only decades, the market has turned.

Neither side deserves to win this CVA fight, in other words. In the absence of an honourable victor, preserving jobs and securing even an underwhelming pensions deal (£175m of cash over three years, plus £210m of securities) should be the priority. Best to allow Arcadia to limp on.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

Woodford’s reserve needs a review

Bloody-mindedness was a virtue for Neil Woodford in the good old days when he was beating up underperforming boards and refusing to follow investment fashion. It’s very different now the chief executive of the Financial Conduct Authority and the chair of the Treasury select committee are shouting at him to waive fees on the gated Equity Income fund.

The alternative explanation is Woodford somehow believes that, since the fund is still operating and he’s probably working harder than ever, the fees are justified because investors are receiving a service.

But, if that’s his thinking, he needs to make a mental leap and look at life from the point of view of the poor old punters. Deprived of the option of cashing up and exiting the fund, they are being forced to pay for their own imprisonment. That’s within the rules of the game – the possibility of gating is in the terms and conditions – but the moral case for waiving the fees is overwhelming.

Remember, too, that Woodford Capital, the company 65% owned by Woodford and 35% by his business partner, has received £97m since the fund management venture set out in 2014. The duo can afford to run the fund for free until the gates are removed. Even if the process takes six months, they’d still be massively in the money.

Nicky Morgan’s committee may wish to summon Woodford to explain why a fee waiver hasn’t appeared already. That might hurry up a U-turn that surely has to happen.

Deutsche Bahn can’t railroad Arriva sale in UK

Deutsche Bahn has been under pressure to sell Arriva for a while. The state-owned German railway is carrying too much debt and the UK-based bus and rail company, bought for £1.5bn in 2010, is an obvious candidate for disposal. Reports by Reuters on Tuesday, citing internal documents, said a sale or flotation of Arriva is seen as the only way to meet investment budgets in Germany.

Good luck in trying to float the business in London, though. Rail franchising is a mess, the threat of rail nationalisation under Labour is in the background and Arriva’s troubles with strikes on its Northern operation are fresh in the memory. Arriva also has non-UK operations but, even so, don’t expect a rush of UK investors.


Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Woodford's fall shows that investment genius rarely lasts | Nils Pratley
Why did it take independent outsiders such as Hargreaves and the FCA so long to notice?

Nils Pratley

04, Jun, 2019 @6:56 PM

Article image
Neil Woodford loyalists pay dearly for stock-picker's style drift
Winding up of flagship fund should also be a big lesson for Hargreaves Lansdown

Nils Pratley

28, Jan, 2020 @6:35 PM

Article image
Nicky Morgan must ask questions of regulator after Neil Woodford saga
Was Financial Conduct Authority asleep or merely powerless to act under EU rules?

Nils Pratley

06, Jun, 2019 @6:54 PM

Article image
Why did it take the FCA four years to ban Paul Flowers? | Nils Pratley
The investigation into the former Co-op Bank chair went on far too long. It’s high time to speed things up

Nils Pratley

06, Mar, 2018 @7:12 PM

Article image
Neil Woodford needs permission to set up new firm, says FCA
City regulator still investigating collapse of fund manager’s previous business

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

17, Feb, 2021 @11:20 AM

Article image
The Lloyds bank boss may be a staff hero but is he worth £6.3m? | Nils Pratley
Staff think António Horta-Osório is ‘a winner’ but does that merit pay at 169 times the shop floor salary?

Nils Pratley

20, Jun, 2019 @9:36 AM

Article image
Bank of England was warned about Brexit property fund problems
Documents show FCA twice told Bank about potentially serious outflows from commercial property trusts and that funds could be suspended

Jill Treanor

12, Jul, 2016 @9:04 AM

Article image
Exit of Virgin Trains leaves behind a muddle over pension liabilities | Nils Pratley
Ministers should have been much clearer about who was on the hook for a £6bn deficit

Nils Pratley

11, Apr, 2019 @6:22 PM

Article image
Is Facebook's Libra currency a case of corporate megalomania? | Nils Pratley
The planned cryptocurrency has big questions to answer, not least on transparency and trust

Nils Pratley

18, Jun, 2019 @3:13 PM

Article image
The stock markets have rallied, so is peak panic over?
In the past fortnight an optimism of sorts has returned but the rebound rests in part on some pretty heroic assumptions

Nils Pratley

31, Mar, 2020 @6:17 PM