Facebook investors may want to quiz Mark Zuckerberg | Nils Pratley

Cambridge Analytica data scandal has hit share price, so it is right to ask how the boss is running the firm

Politicians and regulators won’t be the only people who want a word with Mark Zuckerberg. With Facebook’s shares sliding more than 10% since the data breach involving Cambridge Analytica, shareholders would probably also like to quiz their chief executive about how he has been running the firm.

But what are outside investors’ chances of exerting real influence? What if, after a few more chapters in this saga, the majority owners of Facebook conclude the “catastrophic failure of process”, as one MP put it, is so damaging that a new boss is required to restore credibility in the eyes of users, advertisers and the outside world?

The short answer is that those investors would struggle to change the boardroom line-up. Zuckerberg owns only about 16% of Facebook but he has 60% of the votes, having achieved control by creating a class of stock with 10 times the voting rights of normal shares.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

To British eyes, the arrangement looks outrageous. Dual-voting structures at public companies were largely dismantled in the 1990s when they were deemed an affront to the idea that equal economic risk should imply equal voting power.

In US technology sector, however, they prosper. Technology companies born in the 21st century prefer governance structures that belong in the 19th century. Google, Facebook, Groupon, LinkedIn and TripAdvisor all have unequal voting rights. Snap, owner of Snapchat, even managed to issue a class of share with zero votes.

The thin justification is usually that the founders are geniuses who require complete freedom to pursue their visions. Being truly accountable to shareholders, with their grubby short-term concerns, is a distraction from the pursuit of greater long-term glory – or so the argument goes. It is astonishing that US investors, even in their greed to get on the next tech hit, tolerated such guff. But they did, and still do. Dropbox, an internet storage firm, and Spotify want to take the same route.

One cannot, of course, say Facebook has been asleep to data risks because Zuckerberg is insulated via his super-charged shares. Nor can one say that harder accountability to owners would have made the company do anything differently, such as recognising the risk in allowing political messages to run like commercial adverts on the platform. But a proper voice for shareholders might have helped to puncture the instinctive defensiveness that Facebook displays whenever its “social mission” is questioned.

In the circumstances, the severe reaction in the share price is not a surprise. This is a $490bn company with a boss whose voting power means he cannot be removed against his wishes. That arrangement looks fine in good times – not so when crisis strikes.

GKN v Melrose: the battle continues

Another day, another tit-for-tat round of exchanges between GKN and Melrose over pensions, each side claiming its plan is superior. Who’s right? Actually, that’s the wrong question. It is the view of the trustees of GKN’s pension funds that matters. The trustees have declared that GKN’s version provides “appropriate mitigation” but what of Melrose’s offer of “up to” £1bn? It looks OK to the unpractised eye, but what do the experts think?

They should hurry up and give a view. Voting on this takeover bid closes on Thursday next week and, at the margin, pensions could influence some shareholders. It seems unfair that one side has a thumbs-up and the other hasn’t got an opinion.

Melrose should have done itself a favour by approaching the Pensions Regulator for clearance, as it was asked to do. But the GKN trustees should still speak up soon.

• This article was amended on 22 March 2018 to correct the valuation of Facebook from $66bn to $490bn.


Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Facebook board has to look past Mark Zuckerberg for reform | Nils Pratley
The world’s eighth largest firm needs a governance structure to provide better oversight than its founder

Nils Pratley

05, Apr, 2018 @6:33 PM

Article image
Mark Zuckerberg’s Facebook stake falls $3bn in a day
Social network’s shares plunge after chief financial officer warns of slowing advertising growth

Julia Kollewe

04, Nov, 2016 @1:45 PM

Article image
Google, Apple and Microsoft report record-breaking profits
‘Perfect positive storm’ for big tech as pandemic fuels huge quarterly sales and stock market gains

Rupert Neate and Dominic Rushe

27, Jul, 2021 @8:54 PM

Article image
MPs threaten Mark Zuckerberg with summons over Facebook data
Parliament may formally call CEO to face Cambridge Analytica questions next time he is in UK

Jim Waterson Media editor

01, May, 2018 @6:42 PM

Article image
Is this Facebook's great leap forward?
Facebook's share offer will create new billionaires and millionaires – but analysts worry about its capacity for growth and many users fear for their privacy.

Paul Harris in New York

04, Feb, 2012 @5:52 PM

Article image
Mark Zuckerberg’s metaverse is a joke not shared equally with investors | Nils Pratley
Meta’s share price is down 73% in 2022 but Facebook investors can’t force the boss to change course

Nils Pratley

02, Nov, 2022 @6:50 PM

Article image
Meta mass sackings show Mark Zuckerberg is rattled
Investors only have themselves to blame for not insisting on equal voting rights to rein in tech pioneer

Nils Pratley

09, Nov, 2022 @7:05 PM

Article image
Zuckerberg threatened to pull investment from the UK
Minutes of a 2018 meeting show Facebook chief complaining UK was anti-tech and saying he might look elsewhere in Europe to invest

Mark Sweney

08, Dec, 2020 @6:31 PM

Article image
MPs summon Mark Zuckerberg, saying Facebook misled them
Facebook founder is called to give evidence after revelations over data use by Cambridge Analytica

Hilary Osborne and Jessica Elgot

21, Mar, 2018 @11:31 AM

Article image
Fangs: the lightning rise of Facebook, Amazon, Netflix and Google
The tech giants have ballooned in value by $250bn since January - double the value of all the gold mined in a year - in four months

Alex Hern and Nick Fletcher

29, Apr, 2017 @8:00 AM