Stock exchange merger is now caught in the Brexit crossfire

Before the vote to leave the EU, the pitch from the London Stock Exchange and Deutsche Börse was straightforward, almost compelling

Confident assertions are being made about what will happen to the City after Brexit. Sir Charlie Bean, former deputy governor of the Bank of England, said last week that he had “absolutely no doubt at all” that euro-denominated clearing of interest rate derivatives would be moved into the European Union.

Then chancellor Philip Hammond said the exact opposite, suggesting the EU would be foolish to attempt such a manoeuvre because it would only hand business to New York. London, Hammond argued, benefits from economies of scale that EU countries shouldn’t try to smash out of “narrow and hypothetical national advantage”.

Such arguments go to the heart of the debate about the wisdom of allowing the London Stock Exchange to merge with Deutsche Börse, a £24bn deal that now faces about six months of regulatory scrutiny.

Before the vote for Brexit, the pitch from the pair was straightforward, almost compelling. The duo would be a European powerhouse to compete with the big US houses, led by ICE (owner of the New York Stock Exchange), and oil the wheels of the European economy. All that was required was for both sides to accept a new structure in which the holding company would be based in London but local regulators would continue to oversee local entities as if nothing had changed.

The structure is clever and shareholders duly approved the terms, so now it’s up to the regulators and politicians to protest if they wish. The European commission will fret about the possible loss of competition. The specific UK worry, however, is obvious: if, despite Hammond’s advice, EU governments try to slice off chunks of City business, are their chances improved by the LSE/Deutsche merger?

Hammond’s relaxed stance is understandable up to a point. The Frankfurt-based European Central Bank has always been infuriated that London dominates euro-denominated trading but it has lost one court battle on the matter and, say most lawyers, the UK’s exit from the EU wouldn’t alter the basis of the relevant judgment. What’s more, sensible EU business folk might complain if Berlin or Paris tried to undermine London; they would worry that the price of capital could go up for them.

All the same, Bean’s warning shouldn’t be dismissed lightly, or without proper scrutiny. It’s very odd, for example, that Xavier Rolet, chief executive of the London Stock Exchange, is in charge of studying market infrastructure for Baroness Vadera’s post-Brexit financial services taskforce; as an architect of the Deutsche deal, he’s hardly impartial.

What’s needed is a specific national interest study. If it concludes that the merger should be paused until the terms of Brexit are decided and proper assessments can be made, so be it. The Deutsche/LSE deal is too important to the City to be waved through on the merry assumption that things will probably work out OK in the end.

Who are the UK’s fat executives?

International trade secretary Liam Fox, if he had wanted to attack the UK’s “lazy” business culture seriously, could have pointed to the UK’s large balance of trade deficit and compared it with Germany’s surplus.

Fox didn’t do that, however. Maybe there were two reasons why. First, successful German exporters tend to enjoy more financial support from local and central government, which doesn’t suit Fox’s agenda. Second, the UK’s exports of goods and services per capita are the third highest in the G7, after Germany and Canada, as economist Andrew Sentance pointed out.

Downing Street declined to endorse Fox’s remarks. That was wise. Theresa May, let’s hope, will go further and invite Fox to shame those “fat” UK executives he thinks play golf on Friday afternoons instead of negotiating export deals. If the golf line was a throwaway, let’s hear about all the deals Fox thinks could have been done. Without evidence, his generalisations are absurd.

Exit Shafik

Deputy governors of the Bank or England are meant to last more than two years, so Dame Nemat Shafik’s escape to the London School of Economics is big news in the small world of central banking.

It’s hard to detect any falling-out in the glowing tribute from governor Mark Carney. And the Bank’s review of fair and effective markets, overseen by Shafik, received generally favourable reviews. So one assumes she really does find the pull of academia too great.

Yet it would be struggle to say Shafik has established a high profile. When she arrived from the IMF in August 2014, some people thought Carney had hired a potential successor; it’s been a while since that theory was aired.

Contributor

Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Theresa May must block London Stock Exchange bids until after Brexit | Nils Pratley
The LSE/Deutsche Börse merger was doomed – the UK’s vote to leave the EU only piled confusion upon uncertainty

Nils Pratley

27, Feb, 2017 @7:32 PM

Article image
Hong Kong stock exchange bid for LSE was least credible of the lot | Nils Pratley
Shortcomings in failed £32bn approach were evident from the outset

Nils Pratley

08, Oct, 2019 @6:41 PM

Article image
ITV shouldn't get away with blaming Brexit for falling revenues | Nils Pratley
The commercial broadcaster grumbles about ‘political and economic uncertainty’ – but consumer confidence is still high

Nils Pratley

03, Mar, 2017 @1:02 PM

Article image
London Stock Exchange and Deutsche Börse merger blocked by EU
Competition regulator says £21bn deal would create a ‘de facto monopoly’

Graham Ruddick

29, Mar, 2017 @9:58 AM

Article image
LSE chief says London will keep key tasks after stock exchange merger
Xavier Rolet says £21bn deal with Deutsche Börse will not remove clearing of euro-denominated financial services from City

Julia Kollewe

04, Aug, 2016 @4:14 PM

Article image
The UK stock market isn’t working | Nils Pratley
Recent bidding battles for sub-£1bn firms such as Wincanton and Currys suggest London has an undervaluation problem

Nils Pratley

29, Feb, 2024 @6:18 PM

Article image
Why scrapping bonus cap could be a hard sell for Mark Carney
Bank’s worry about EU cap approach was justified, but don’t be surprised if nuanced reason for UK dropping it is lost on many

Nils Pratley

29, Nov, 2017 @7:05 PM

Article image
Stock exchange merger frenzy shocks markets
Revelation of planned Deutsche Börse and NYSE Euronext tie-up overshadows news of LSE-TMX talks

Simon Goodley and Dominic Rushe

09, Feb, 2011 @8:47 PM

Article image
London’s stock market has bigger problems than Tui’s likely departure | Nils Pratley
A sole German listing for the tour operator should surprise no one, but the dearth of UK fizz and liquidity is a harder puzzle to solve

Nils Pratley

06, Dec, 2023 @6:12 PM

Article image
Has British Gas conjured up a magic solution to energy bills? | Nils Pratley
Talk of an energy price cap has spurred the big six into action, but Centrica’s ban on pricey tariffs looks cosmetic

Nils Pratley

20, Nov, 2017 @4:53 PM