Australia's 'deficit bad, surplus amazing' mantra should finally be binned | Greg Jericho

After more than six years of flat household income growth, how can anyone still be obsessing over debt and deficit?

More than anything, the current crisis has revealed the paucity of logic that has dominated economic debate for far too long. The obsession over debt and deficit was always silly, and it sure as heck made for easy analysis: deficit bad, small deficit less bad, surplus amazing. But it needs to be thrown in the bin.

Less than a year ago the government was boasting how glorious was its economic management because it took the budget deficit from $10bn in 2017-18 to just $690m in 2018-19.

Awesome! Wow! I guess the economy was surging?

Err, no.

2018-19 saw both GDP and GDP per capita growth slow by the largest amount in six years and both measures overall posted their third worst results since the 1990s recession:

In that year productivity fell for only the third time in 30 years, and the growth of domestic demand was only marginally above the pathetic post-GFC average.

But pfft, look at our budget balance!

The budget balance gets far too much coverage. So unimportant is it that it should barely be mentioned – except to highlight that any boasting about it generally reveals its lack of connection with the economy.

You might think after the GFC smashed the heck out of the small government, low taxes and lower regulation economic system that we might have seen some changing of minds.

But no.

Out of fear of stepping outside the pack, mediocrities always stick with the rote lessons they have been force-fed. And our political and media class truly have within them a confederacy of the mediocre.

We still see the worries about government deficits and debt despite enduring a period of the weakest ongoing economic and income growth since the 1970s.

You would think that more than six years of flat household income growth would cause some to think something was wrong with the desire to keep reducing the deficit:

But no.

You might think that a massive pandemic that has seen deficits surge to previously unknown levels would shock the commentariat and politicians to realise that deficits don’t matter anywhere as much as they once believed.

But no.

The Coalition government will, with little pushback, still argue we were fortunate to enter the pandemic in such a strong budget position. The Labor party will still suggest that growing levels of debt are a sign of mismanagement.

And still we hear worries about how too much spending, too many deficits, and too much debt is unsustainable because ... [insert platitudes about future generations and hyperinflation].

Last week’s statement on monetary policy by the Reserve Bank showed just how big a hole we are in and how the government and the RBA are failing to do all they can to aid the recovery.

As I noted on Sunday, even with hopes of very strong growth in 2021 and 2022, we will still be some 4.6% below where we expected we would be before the pandemic hit.

Even with very solid 3.5% annual growth from 2023 onwards, it would take us till the end of 2026 to get back level with pre-pandemic expectations.

And even with that strong growth, large deficits and increase in debt, the Reserve Banks expects underlying inflation to remain below 2% until at least 2023:

That would mean seven years of inflation growth below the RBA’s target band of 2% to 3% – surely long enough to suggest either a massive failure or that the band is not really a target at all.

The Grattan Institute’s Brendan Coates and Matt Cowgill have argued the RBA needs to do more – including considering negative interest rates.

But the low inflation growth points to just how broken the deficit bad/surplus good arguments are, and how equally fraudulent is the line that we can’t keep going into debt or inflation will take off and we’ll be Zimbabwe or the Weimar Republic.

The government currently expects the budget deficit in the 2021-22 to increase by 5.4% pts to 9.7% of GDP. By comparison, during the GFC the biggest deficit increase was “just” 3.8% pts of GDP.

Government net debt is expected to rise from 24.6% of GDP to 35.7% of GDP.

And despite all of that, the Reserve Bank still expects underlying inflation growth in 2022 to be just 1% – a level which, if achieved, will actually be a record low.

And at the same time the RBA predicts the growth of public demand (essentially the level of government input into the economy) will be just 3% in the 12 months to June 2022 – a mere 0.2%pts higher than the RBA expected would be the case before the virus hit:

Does anyone now think 2022 will be as good as we thought it would be six months ago?

If not, why then is public demand not expected to be significantly larger?

We ask the wrong questions about budgets. The headline should not be the deficit or surplus but the forecasts for GDP, employment, inflation and household income growth, changes in income equality, poverty, and access to and provision of services.

And we should judge the recovery by similar measures. After the past decade and especially the past six months, anyone still worrying about deficits and debt deserves laughter and scorn.


Greg Jericho

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The government's wages growth predictions appear to be wishful thinking | Greg Jericho
Until underemployment levels fall significantly, the prospects of wage growth are nonexistent

Greg Jericho

14, Aug, 2019 @6:00 PM

Article image
It's not just the pandemic, stupid. Australia's economy has been weak for years | Greg Jericho
We have now gone five years with inflation being lower than the Reserve Bank’s 2% target

Greg Jericho

27, Jan, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Bushfires and the coronavirus will hit Australia's economy – but they won't knock it out | Greg Jericho
While the Reserve Bank will most likely need to cut rates again earlier than it otherwise would, talk of a recession is premature

Greg Jericho

03, Feb, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Australia's economy is in the doldrums and infrastructure is failing to prop it up
The level of engineering work done in the March quarter of this year was 13% below what it was a year ago

Greg Jericho

26, Jun, 2019 @6:00 PM

Article image
The RBA has not raised interest rates for 130 months – and history suggests low rates are here to stay | Greg Jericho
Since the last rate rise, Australian house prices have risen so much that levels seen in the past would wreck the economy

Greg Jericho

06, Sep, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Few signs of economic life as inflation stays stuck in its rut | Greg Jericho
The latest sluggish figures increase the odds of the Reserve Bank embarking on another interest rate cut

Greg Jericho

29, Jan, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Inflation growths remains lower than the Reserve Bank wants. How will it act? | Greg Jericho
The current low level of inflation growth signals that the economy lacks much in the way of vigour

Greg Jericho

30, Jan, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
Inflation in Australia might be on the rise, but it’s hardly running wild | Greg Jericho
Mostly what we’ve seen is a breakout of people saying high inflation is on the way, rather than a breakout of high inflation

Greg Jericho

27, Oct, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Inflation will reappear in Australia – but that shouldn’t mean the end of stimulus | Greg Jericho
Last year prices actually fell, so by comparison anything is going to look like a surge

Greg Jericho

12, Apr, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Coalition and Labor have their eyes on the horizon – they should focus on hurdles in front of them | Greg Jericho
Worryingly low demand, national income growth and wage growth means the economy needs a jolt right now

Greg Jericho

09, Jun, 2016 @12:27 AM