Shell and BP face tough job of keeping customers and investors happy as profits roll in

The oil giants will also have to contend with intensifying calls to put more money into clean energy

The bosses of Shell and BP face the same task as they prepare to present their companies’ annual results this week, but at completely different points in their tenures. Wael Sawan will make his City debut after taking over as Shell chief executive at the start of the year. Bernard Looney marks three years since a watershed presentation in London when he took over at BP, unveiling a target to hit net zero by 2050 or sooner.

The pair now each have the task of convincing the public they are not profiteering during the energy crisis – while keeping investors sweet. Profits surged in 2022 on the back of high gas prices caused by the invasion of Ukraine, and are expected to stay high against historical averages this year, while oil prices have climbed in early 2023 as the Chinese economy reopens.

Sawan will take his bow first, on Thursday, as he fronts Shell’s first full-year results since completing the relocation of its headquarters to London – where the business began as an importer of oriental seashells in the 1830s. He’s wasted little time since taking the role, having put Shell’s Europe home energy supply businesses under review. Shell’s figures will be suitably eye-watering: adjusted annual profits are expected to come in around $83bn (£67bn) against $55bn a year ago, including around $19bn in the final quarter of the year, against $16.3bn in the same period of 2021.

The firm’s prized dividend – which was cut during the Covid crisis for the first time since the second world war – has been lifted by 15%. Shell is spending $18.5bn buying back its own shares this year, a statistic that has only increased the calls for the firm to allocate more of its cash pile towards renewable energy and less to rewarding shareholders. This year’s capital investment is expected to come in at between $23bn and $27bn, but renewables will make up a relatively small proportion of this.

If Sawan chooses to change this narrative and ramp up the company’s green spending, he will be following in Looney’s footsteps. In February 2020, the Irishman said the company had to change to ensure a “rapid transition to net zero”, talking grandly about “reimagining energy for people and our planet”. In the three years since, much of Looney’s focus has been on navigating the pandemic, slashing 10,000 jobs in response.

Wael Sawan poses for a photograph beside a picture of a ship
Wael Sawan will be making his first results presentation since becoming Shell’s chief executive at the start of the year. Photograph: Bruno Kelly/Reuters

He has come under pressure from green groups pushing for BP to decarbonise more quickly, and from investors – some of which argue he needs to slow the transition to protect profits. The Guardian reported last month that BP plans to spend as much as double the amount on oil and gas projects as it will on renewable investments in 2023. Looney is also facing calls to show progress in the sell-off of its stake in Russia’s Rosneft.

BP, which reports on 7 February, is expected to reveal fourth-quarter underlying profits of about $5bn. That would represent a slowdown from the $8.2bn recorded in the previous three months, but still outstrips the $4.1bn it made in the same quarter a year earlier.

The BP and Shell updates come during an oil and gas earnings season in which France’s Total and American behemoths Chevron and Exxon will also update the market, with the five western oil giants expected to have raked in a huge $200bn in annual profits combined. This profit pot is expected to moderate to $150bn this year, will still be well above historical trends.

The figures will doubtless reignite calls for Britain’s windfall tax on North Sea oil and gas operators to be further strengthened. Shell said this month that it expected to take a hit of about £1.7bn to earnings for the final quarter of 2022 as a result of windfall taxes in the UK and EU. BP said in early November that it expected to pay about $2.5bn in tax on its North Sea business this year, including $800m from the windfall levy. However, the chancellor, Jeremy Hunt, later raised the rate of the tax from 1 January.

“Let’s not forget that these companies are richer because the rest of us are poorer,” said Alice Harrison of campaign group Global Witness. “Brits should be asking themselves whose side their government is on – those of us living in cold, draughty homes or an industry that’s riding the wave of the energy crisis and returning billions to its shareholders?

“The UK needs a proper windfall tax on the profits of big polluters that isn’t undercut by tax relief and other subsidies for oil and gas companies.”

CMC Markets analyst Michael Hewson says the profits will “trigger the usual tired political carping when it comes to ‘obscene’ profiteering”, arguing that higher prices for oil and gas will persist if firms are not incentivised properly to develop newer sources of supply.

However, he adds: “Oil companies don’t help themselves when they take the decision to continue to buy back billions of dollars in their own shares, rather than increase the amount of investment in renewable sources of energy.”


Alex Lawson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Investors fear there'll be no bright post-Covid dawn for oil majors
The industry may have put the lows of summer behind it, but this week will show that previous highs are now unreachable

Jillian Ambrose

24, Oct, 2020 @11:05 PM

Article image
Eco investors turn up the heat on Shell over climate target
Voting at the oil giant’s annual meeting this week could see Follow This activists making trouble over emissions

Jillian Ambrose

15, May, 2021 @11:05 PM

Article image
High energy prices leave oil giants untroubled by Russia exit or tax hints
BP and Shell are expected to report increased profits this week despite taking a big hit from the war in Ukraine

Rob Davies

30, Apr, 2022 @11:05 PM

Article image
On the horizon: the end of oil and the beginnings of a low-carbon planet
With demand and share prices dropping, Europe’s fossil fuel producers recognise that peak oil is probably now behind them

01, Nov, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
As energy bills rise, oil giants are poised to make unpopular profits
BP, like its competitors, looks like becoming a ‘cash machine’ again this week as it surfs the wave of soaring gas prices

Jillian Ambrose

06, Feb, 2022 @12:05 AM

Article image
Greener BP must do more than talk tough on the climate crisis
A company steeped in oil and gas production may not find it easy to convince investors of its environmental credentials

19, Sep, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Shell and BP bounce back into profit even as oil’s glory days fade
Covid dealt fossil fuel giants a heavy blow, but demand is lifting revenues again in a last hurrah before decarbonisation

Jillian Ambrose

24, Apr, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Shell’s sale of dirty tar sands assets cleans up debt and spruces image
But campaigners remain unconvinced by firm’s shift towards cleaner energy

Adam Vaughan

11, Mar, 2017 @3:59 PM

Article image
£40bn profits for BP and Shell fuel calls for windfall tax on energy firms
‘Obscene’ amounts of surplus cash should be used to ease cost of living crisis, MPs told

Phillip Inman

05, Feb, 2022 @5:05 PM

Article image
What could be fairer than a tax on oil and gas’s North Sea winnings
Labour is pushing for a windfall tax on the industry’s bonanza – and Sunak must grasp that this is not even an ‘un-Tory’ idea

Phillip Inman

12, Feb, 2022 @5:00 PM