Scotland may have to rethink free university places pledge, analysis shows

IFS says if Holyrood’s health and climate policies remain in place other public spending will also suffer

The Scottish government could be forced to reconsider spending pledges to provide free university places and free personal care for older people in light of a squeeze on payments from the UK Treasury over the next two years, according to analysis by the Institute for Fiscal Studies.

The thinktank said the Scottish National party administration would face “difficult trade-offs” if it pursued plans to increase health spending and meet net zero climate targets from a budget adjusted for inflation that is on course to shrink.

It said other public services could be required to cut about 13% from their budgets between 2023 and 2027 if the health and climate policies remained in place.

The SNP government’s assumptions that the income of Scottish households and businesses will grow at a faster rate than their English counterparts over the next five years, boosting tax revenues by more than Westminster forecasts, also put Scotland’s planned spending at risk, according to the IFS.

“If this faster growth doesn’t materialise, then the Scottish government’s choices would be harder still, with funding for non-benefits spending in 2027–28 still 5% below 2022-23 levels,” the report said.

Scotland has benefited from a decade of transfers from the Treasury under the system known as the Barnett formula. It decides the share of public spending allotted to different UK nations, enabling Edinburgh to protect services from the austerity pursued by successive Tory governments.

Spending per person reached 125% of that in England last year after top-ups by the Barnett formula, cushioning spending cuts that affected English regions. However, the IFS said spending increases agreed by the chancellor, Jeremy Hunt, in the autumn budget to protect services from high inflation would not be fully passed on to the Scottish administration.

The outlook over the next 30 years shows the amount spent per person in Scotland could fall to 115% of England’s figure.

To maintain services and support the NHS, Scotland’s acting finance secretary, John Swinney, said in December that income taxes would rise from 41p to 42p in the pound for people earning more than £43,666, and from 46p to 47p for those earning more than £125,140.

“The extra penny is being raised for a specific purpose,” Swinney told MSPs. “It is an extra penny to ensure patient care in our National Health Service.”

The report said higher taxes would not fully offset Barnett cuts and funding would fall by 1.6% in real terms in 2023–24 compared with this year. Even after adjusting for major one-off costs this year, such as council tax rebates that Westminster has agreed for the whole of the UK, the reduction would still be 0.8%.

“While the Barnett formula is often thought to benefit Scotland, in the long term it is likely to lead to relatively smaller increases in funding for Scotland than for England,” the report said.

The speed of this “Barnett squeeze” depends on the rate of growth in spending in England (both real-terms growth and that which merely offsets inflation), and the rate of population growth in Scotland relative to England.

David Phillips, an associate director at the IFS, said the Barnett squeeze would make it harder for the Scottish government to meet rising costs and the demands on public services associated with an ageing population, “and to maintain enhanced service provision relative to England, such as free personal care and free university education, in the longer term”.


Phillip Inman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Unfunded tax cuts mean UK ‘will need £60bn spending cuts’
IFS says Kwasi Kwarteng’s mini-budget will leave ministers making serious reductions in public services

Phillip Inman

10, Oct, 2022 @11:01 PM

Article image
Election 2015 live: Gordon Brown - the SNP are not offering a penny more than Labour
With two weeks to go on the campaign trail join our political team for all the latest, as the IFS delivers its verdict of each of the main parties tax and spending policies

Andrew Sparrow, Nadia Khomami and Mark Smith

23, Apr, 2015 @9:13 PM

Article image
Size doesn’t matter for Scottish economic success. But planning does
Strong institutions, the right mix of human and physical capital, and sound economic management are key

Larry Elliott

02, May, 2021 @10:31 AM

Article image
Independent Scotland would face choice of tax rises or deep cuts, says IFS
Scottish government contests Institute for Fiscal Studies report that predicts 'significant additional fiscal tightening'

Severin Carrell, Scotland correspondent

18, Nov, 2013 @6:09 PM

Article image
How the autumn statement brought back the ‘squeezed middle’
Respected thinktanks say Jeremy Hunt’s policies will shock Middle England, with higher taxes here to stay

Larry Elliott

18, Nov, 2022 @2:11 PM

Article image
Scotland cuts its deficit, but is still outspending the UK
Latest data shows gap between income and spending is four times as much as UK as a whole

Severin Carrell

22, Aug, 2018 @3:10 PM

Article image
Kwarteng scraps top 45% rate of income tax and cuts stamp duty
Chancellor abolishes cap on banker bonuses, cuts basic income tax and national insurance in mini-budget that favours top earners

Phillip Inman and Rowena Mason

23, Sep, 2022 @10:20 AM

Article image
Pound falls and UK borrowing costs rise despite Jeremy Hunt debt promise
Chancellor says he will do ‘whatever is necessary’ to bring down national debt

Angela Monaghan and Phillip Inman

21, Oct, 2022 @2:39 PM

Article image
Election 2015 live: Labour will stand up to corporate power, Miliband tells Russell Brand
David Cameron responds to disappointing GDP figures, while Labour sets out its 10-point immigration plan

Andrew Sparrow, Jamie Grierson and Claire Phipps

28, Apr, 2015 @9:00 PM

Article image
Mini-budget 2022: pound crashes as chancellor cuts stamp duty and top rate of income tax – as it happened
Tax cuts to cost Treasury around £37bn in 2023-24, official figures reveal

Nadeem Badshah (now);Andrew Sparrow and Graeme Wearden (earlier)

23, Sep, 2022 @6:40 PM