Jim Chalmers ‘furious’ after former PwC tax adviser found to have shared confidential government briefings with staff

Treasurer vows to ‘throw the book’ at people responsible for breach after unauthorised disclosures of multinational tax consultations

Jim Chalmers has said he is “absolutely furious” at findings a former PwC tax adviser breached the confidentiality of multinational tax consultations by disclosing them to other staff at the firm without authorisation.

On Wednesday, the treasurer promised to “throw the book” at people responsible for what he labelled a “shocking breach of trust, an appalling breach of trust”.

On Sunday, the Australian Financial Review first reported that the former head of international tax for PwC Australia Peter-John Collins had been deregistered by the tax practitioners board for failing to act with integrity and for sharing confidential government briefings.

The board confirmed on Monday that it had found Collins “made unauthorised disclosures” to partners and staff at PwC of confidential information, obtained in consultations, about new rules to stop multinationals avoiding tax by shifting profits from Australia to tax and secrecy havens.

“In addition, the [board] investigation determined that PwC had failed to properly manage conflicts of interest when this confidential law reform information was shared with partners and staff in their tax practice,” it said in a statement.

The board deregistered Collins, with a two-year ban on him becoming a registered tax practitioner, and ordered PwC to put in place training and procedures to ensure conflicts of interest are adequately managed.

Chalmers said he was “absolutely furious and absolutely ropeable about the revelations”.

“There is no consultation without trust,” he told reporters in Canberra. “We want to be able to consult in a meaningful way when changes to the tax system are in prospect.

“And the actions that we’ve seen alleged and reported cut across that … this puts that sort of consultation at risk.

And so it puts the quality of economic decision-making and policymaking at risk.”

Chalmers revealed he had met the assistant treasurer, Stephen Jones, and asked Treasury, the Australian Tax Office and the tax board to advise on “any additional steps that we should be taking to protect the integrity of these important processes”.

Chalmers described the incident as a “wake-up call”, warning that consultations were “not possible without integrity and trust in the system”.

“We need to find where this has happened and throw the book at people … to make sure it doesn’t happen again.”

A PwC spokesperson reportedly told the Australian Financial Review: “We acknowledge the [tax board] found that a partner of the firm did not comply with confidentiality agreements in relation to a consultation process with Treasury, which occurred in 2014.

“We also acknowledge that PwC should have had specific conflict management procedures and policies operating at the time to prevent this occurring. In each case this failed the standards we set for PwC and we deeply regret this occurred.

A PwC spokesperson told Guardian Australia it is “deeply disappointed that in this government consultation process we failed the high standards we set for ourselves as a firm”.

“We recognise and understand the need for our tax system to operate with integrity and deeply regret confidentiality in this matter was not maintained.”

The spokesperson said PwC had taken action to prevent this happening again including a central confidentiality agreement register, a single non-client facing contact for similar consultations and an education program.

On Tuesday, the Liberal MP Michael Sukkar, who worked for PwC in 2005 to 2006, described the deregistration of the tax practitioner as serious but dismissed suggestions that PwC should be sanctioned beyond the tax board’s order.

“Sanctions administered by the [board] are rightly imposed against individual tax practitioners, as has occurred here,” Sukkar reportedly told the Australian Financial Review.

“I am pleased that the former Coalition government took steps to strengthen the independence and role of the [tax board], which has helped facilitate this action.”

The shadow treasurer, Angus Taylor, told reporters it was “not acceptable behaviour” but backed Sukkar’s stance that “there should be consequences for the individual” but no further punishment of PwC.


Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Jim Chalmers says he will make the ‘right decisions’ on stage-three tax cuts
Treasurer says while the government’s policy has not yet changed ‘any responsible government’ would be looking at global economic pressures

Sarah Martin

04, Oct, 2022 @5:41 AM

Article image
Jim Chalmers opens door to changing superannuation tax concessions
Treasurer again questions sustainability of concessions on contributions, saying conversation ‘shouldn’t be off the table’

Amy Remeikis

20, Feb, 2023 @5:06 AM

Article image
‘Differences of opinion’ within Labor over stage-three tax cuts amid worsening economic outlook
Assistant treasurer Stephen Jones says government ‘not walking away’ from previous policy but framing budget in ‘difficult’ circumstances

Sarah Martin and Josh Butler

05, Oct, 2022 @7:53 AM

Article image
Federal budget 2022 summary – winners and losers: who will benefit and who was left behind?
The governor general, Bob Katter, jobseekers, seniors and Double J listeners – everyone has a stake in the federal budget, but some have done better than others

Caitlin Cassidy

25, Oct, 2022 @8:45 AM

Article image
Jim Chalmers announces $50bn improvement in federal budget compared to March projections
Treasurer says improvement comes in large part from higher than expected commodity prices boosting returns from mineral exports

Peter Hannam Economics correspondent

20, Sep, 2022 @3:58 AM

Article image
Energy price relief plan due before Christmas, Jim Chalmers tells ABC’s Q+A
In a solo appearance, the treasurer is bombarded with questions but does not rule out subsidies or changes to company tax

Amy Remeikis

03, Nov, 2022 @11:27 AM

Article image
Labor could have unleashed a fiscal chainsaw massacre – instead it opted for a cautious hop on superannuation | Katharine Murphy
The Albanese government has climbed on to the starter’s block for budget repair with its move on super tax breaks

Katharine Murphy

28, Feb, 2023 @9:19 AM

Article image
Business sector has driven shift to ‘values-based capitalism’, Jim Chalmers says
Treasurer hits back at criticism of his essay that championed co-investment and economic inclusion

Katharine Murphy Political editor

01, Feb, 2023 @9:15 AM

Article image
Jim Chalmers’ first budget comes amid a darkening economic outlook. Here’s what could go wrong
The federal budget forecasts growth of 3.25% this year but hints at a slowing global economy with high inflation and interest rates

Peter Hannam

25, Oct, 2022 @9:24 AM

Article image
Jim Chalmers confident Australia will avoid recession despite warnings of more interest rate rises
The treasurer also noted ‘very encouraging’ signs on power prices falling, saying Labor’s energy price relief package was working

Amy Remeikis

12, Feb, 2023 @3:34 AM