If BP’s change of heart isn’t a U-turn, it’s certainly a major detour | Nils Pratley

Bernard Looney is ‘leaning in’ to his earlier pledge to cut hydrocarbons, but where will it end?

The calls from Labour’s shadow climate secretary, Ed Miliband, and others for a “proper” windfall tax on BP and its brethren after the oil supermajor revealed a near-doubling of its profits are the least of chief executive Bernard Looney’s worries. A more powerful influence is the company’s own shareholders, who have clearly demanded a rethink on previous pledges to slash hydrocarbon output by 40% this decade.

Three years ago, when he was fresh in the job, Looney sounded as if he’d made up his mind. “Today is about a vision, a direction of travel,” he declared to an audience of investors and industry analysts. “The direction is set. We are heading to net zero. There is no turning back.”

And now? Well, there is still no reversal, BP would argue, because an extra $1bn (£830m) a year until 2030 is going into what the company calls its “transition growth engines” – meaning biofuels, electric charging points, wind, solar and hydrogen. That is what Looney meant when he spoke on Tuesday of “leaning in” to the same strategy.

But an equivalent extra sum will also be directed at oil and gas, meaning the ambition of reducing hydrocarbon output by 40% by 2030 has been scrapped in favour of a 25% figure. Whereas BP used to say it would happily live without the “low margin barrels” that would be removed from the production schedule, it now refers to “short-cycle fast-payback opportunities”. This may not count as U-turn, but it is a major detour.

The world is “a different place” and “needs energy that is secure and affordable as well as lower carbon”, argued Looney, emphasising the need for an “orderly” transition. Well, yes, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine had obviously transformed the economic calculation. Oil is now $80-plus a barrel v $40 when the transition-speak was turned up. That explains the investor pressure to be oily for longer: BP’s shares, even as they rose 7% after the latest results, are still rated substantially lower than those of unashamedly oil-focused ExxonMobil.

But one wonders where this plot is going next, and whether even the diluted hydrocarbon pledges are vulnerable to another rethink. BP is banking on returns on capital of 15% from its fresh oil and gas investments but referenced just 6%-8% in parts on its renewables power portfolio. Therein lies in the difficulty in trying to please all shades of investors. Even the crowd that loudly proclaims its environmental credentials seems to want two things at once: the halo of renewables plus more of the rewards on display on Tuesday – record profits of $28bn in 2022 and share buybacks galore – from dirty oil and gas.

Looney predicted his new, rejigged investment plan would deliver top-line earnings of $51-$56bn by 2030. His life will be trouble-free if that ambition looks like it will be met over the next few years. Problems will arise, however, if the financial goals start to appear out of reach. In that case, it’s not hard to imagine that pressure will come to abandon the “leaning in” line and be wobbly on renewables.

Miliband and co should take note. One can argue all day about whether a “proper” windfall tax on North Sea profits would set the headline rate at 75%, as now, or at 78%, as prevails in Norway. But the bigger story is happening elsewhere: it is the signal from the likes of BP, Shell and others that the transition to a lower carbon energy system will take longer than previously forecast. That is the more significant lesson from the current results season.


Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Global carbon emissions forecast cut due to Ukraine war and Biden, says BP
Oil and gas group says countries are pursuing energy security by backing domestic, renewable supplies

Alex Lawson Energy correspondent

30, Jan, 2023 @11:03 AM

Article image
BP leads energy companies preparing two major UK carbon capture projects
17m tonnes of carbon dioxide to be stored beneath the North Sea every year

Jillian Ambrose

27, Oct, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Light fantastic: BP’s solar venture launches biggest UK project yet
From solar farms to floating arrays, from Australia to Bedfordshire, Lightsource BP is ramping up its renewable energy push

Alex Lawson Energy correspondent

06, Oct, 2022 @9:37 AM

Article image
BP criticised over plan to spend billions more on fossil fuels than green energy
Company’s oil and gas investments for 2023 will be as much as double those on renewables

Alex Lawson Energy correspondent

27, Dec, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
BP facing green rebellion at annual shareholder meeting
Some of UK’s biggest pension funds preparing to demand tougher plans to reduce emissions by 2030

Jillian Ambrose Energy correspondent

24, Apr, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Ineos in talks with Rolls-Royce on mini-nuclear power plant technology
Chemicals giant wants to produce zero-carbon electricity to power planned hydrogen systems at Grangemouth refinery

Jasper Jolly

27, Nov, 2022 @5:43 PM

Article image
Does the UK really need to drill for more North Sea oil and gas?
Ministers are weighing up a new gasfield but is more UK fossil fuel production necessary or desirable given its climate commitments?

Jillian Ambrose

01, May, 2023 @1:41 PM

Article image
BP to install charging points for electric cars at UK petrol stations
Further indication that oil firms are planning for growth of battery-powered vehicle market

Adam Vaughan

30, Jan, 2018 @3:07 PM

Article image
BP faces shareholder challenge over carbon targets
Company is among energy firms being urged to set goals in line with Paris agreement

Adam Vaughan

10, Dec, 2018 @12:01 AM

Article image
BP’s joint solar venture Lightsource BP to more than double expansion by 2025
Deal worth £1.3bn means operation will develop enough solar farms to power equivalent of 8.4m homes

Jillian Ambrose Energy correspondent

20, Sep, 2021 @6:00 AM