Octopus takeover of Bulb faces delay after rivals seek judicial review

Three companies complain over lack of transparency around deal which could be biggest government bailout since RBS and Lloyds

The takeover of collapsed bailed-out energy supplier Bulb by rival Octopus faces further delays after three rival companies launched judicial review proceedings, arguing that there are “significant concerns” over a possible £1bn government-funded “dowry”.

Octopus agreed to buy Bulb out of a special government-handled administration last month after a year-long process which could cost the taxpayer up to £6.5bn, according to a government estimate.

Octopus was the sole bidder for much of the process, despite early interest from rivals including British Gas owner Centrica and a last-ditch bid from Ovo. However, three rival energy companies, ScottishPower, E.ON and British Gas, intervened earlier this month, arguing for more transparency over the terms of the deal, which could be the biggest government bailout since Royal Bank of Scotland and Lloyds Banking Group during the financial crisis of 2008.

The three companies are now starting judicial review proceedings, the Guardian understands. A review would probably look into whether the government followed the correct legal process in finding a buyer for Bulb, and could significantly delay a takeover, or require the process to be carried out again.

Octopus is estimated to have paid between £100m and £200m to acquire Bulb, which has 1.5 million customers, creating the UK’s third largest energy supplier behind British Gas and E.ON, with 4.9 million customers.

The high court hearing on Tuesday was due to set a date for the takeover to proceed. However, ScottishPower argued that the deal should be halted because of “defects in the marketing process” for the remnants of Bulb, according to court documents.

The decision from the court is expected on Wednesday, but the reasons behind the decision will not be revealed until next week, according to people familiar with the process.

The administration is being handled by advisory firm Teneo, which hired investment bank Lazard to oversee the search for a buyer. ScottishPower argued that it “was not informed that any large-scale government support would be available to the successful bidder”, and that Lazard also failed to provide enough information on Bulb’s hedging positions and customer credit balances, according to a summary of ScottishPower’s arguments heard in court on Tuesday.

ScottishPower said it believed “a substantial part of the £6.5bn” cost to the government of the Bulb saga will go on a “10-figure debt to fund a ‘dowry’” to Octopus, the documents said.

Counsel for the Bulb administrators argued that the energy companies’ submissions were “replete with factual errors and speculation”, and argued that they were irrelevant for the purposes of the hearing, according to a summary of their arguments. The administrators argued that the rival energy companies could have sought meetings with government on potential funding options.

An Octopus Energy spokesperson said: “It’s now clear that other companies had many opportunities to bid, knew they could propose hedging support, and were invited to counter-bid against Octopus. Instead of doing so, they waited until a deal was announced and then launched expensive legal action which could cost taxpayers millions, even billions.”

“We will continue to work hard to get this resolved as fast as possible, bringing stability for Bulb customers and staff and ending the huge financial exposure for taxpayers.”

The Office for Budget Responsibility said this month that the cost of bailing out Bulb had reached £6.5bn, as a result of a decision not to buy power ahead. The government disputes the figure. The National Audit Office, which studies government spending, is scrutinising the deal.

The Octopus founder, Greg Jackson, has said the transaction represents a “fair deal” for taxpayers and that the company has paid over the market rate for Bulb’s customers.

Bulb was set up by the entrepreneurs Hayden Wood and Amit Gudka, who rapidly gained customers with slick technology and marketing. However, its ineffective hedging policy saw Bulb become by far the largest casualty of an energy crisis which saw 28 other suppliers go bust.

Wood told the Guardian on Monday that he was “very sorry for the way things turned out” and said he had worked “extremely hard” to minimise the cost to the taxpayer during the administration process. Gudka left Bulb before its collapse to found a battery storage venture. Both cashed out £4m in shares in a fundraising in 2018.

Lazard was approached for comment.


Alex Lawson, Jasper Jolly and Anna Isaac

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Big six energy firms braced for government price crackdown
New rules are expected to be implemented as soon as next week, most likely in form of price cap on standard variable tariffs

Adam Vaughan

17, Apr, 2017 @3:43 PM

Article image
Energy regulator under scrutiny as both Tories and Labour vow to act
Ofgem will have power to disprove claims it is ‘toothless’ on electricity and gas price hikes

Adam Vaughan

10, May, 2017 @7:52 AM

Article image
Bulb takeover saga sheds light on ‘disgraceful’ lack of transparency
Let’s hope E.ON, Centrica and Scottish Power’s judicial reviews succeed in forcing some openness

Nils Pratley

30, Nov, 2022 @7:04 PM

Article image
What does energy price cap mean for households and firms?
From whether you should switch suppliers to how it could lead to job cuts

Adam Vaughan

06, Nov, 2018 @3:55 PM

Article image
Octopus takeover of Bulb under scrutiny by spending watchdog
Exclusive: NAO to investigate deal amid calls for greater transparency over price paid to government

Alex Lawson Energy correspondent

09, Nov, 2022 @4:00 PM

Article image
Big five UK energy companies turning away new customers
Home movers and customers seeking better service wrongly told to stay with current supplier because of volatile market

Anna Tims

19, Sep, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
‘Bleak Friday’: websites of UK energy suppliers crash in meter reading rush
Customers try to beat 54% price rise, as multiple hikes from council tax to VAT on pub food also come into effect

Rob Davies and Rupert Jones

31, Mar, 2022 @6:21 PM

Article image
KiWi Power: the tech-savvy energy firm with a way out of Britain's power crisis
Laptop-sized product monitors customer's energy usage and can cut it off in times of high demand – and the client gets paid for it

Terry Macalister

07, Jul, 2014 @7:25 PM

Article image
UK government pledges up to £4.5bn to fund Bulb takeover by Octopus
Support comes on top of £1.1bn paid to handle collapsed energy firm’s administration costs

Alex Lawson Energy correspondent

21, Dec, 2022 @4:52 PM

Article image
Big six energy suppliers could be broken up after Ofgem triggers full investigation
British Gas warns of an increasing risk of power outages but the energy watchdog says 'it will enhance confidence in the investment climate'

Terry Macalister and Sean Farrell

27, Mar, 2014 @7:17 PM