Aldi’s 29p mince pie a close second to Waitrose’s winner in blind taste test

Waitrose’s No 1 Brown Butter pies wowed with their ‘buttery aroma’, while Aldi’s, at half the price, scored just one point less

Tucking into a mince pie is usually the first sign Christmas is on the way and with budgets under pressure this year getting your fix doesn’t have to break the bank, with a 29p pie from Aldi coming a close second to Waitrose’s brown butter pastry in a taste test.

The upmarket supermarket’s No 1 Brown Butter Mince Pies came top in a “rigorous” blind taste test conducted by Which?. They wowed the panel of baking experts with their “buttery aroma” and “citrussy aftertaste” to achieve the top score of 74%, earning the consumer group’s coveted “best buy” badge of approval.

Waitrose’s No 1 Brown Butter Mince Pies.
Waitrose’s No 1 Brown Butter Mince Pies came out on top, winning the ‘best buy’ badge of approval. Photograph: Sarah Lee/The Guardian

At £3.50 for six, or 58p per pie, the judges said the almonds and chunks of fruit in the Waitrose pies gave them a “homemade” quality. Reading between the lines this could mean you could attempt to pass them off as your own work.

But with food prices rising at their fastest rate for 45 years Which? said shoppers eager to save money did not have to compromise as Aldi’s pies, which are half the price of Waitrose’s at 29p or £1.75 for six, scored 73%, just one point less. The Aldi pies also work out cheaper than making your own given the cheapest jar of mincemeat costs about £1.25 in the supermarket.

The popularity of the mince pie is rivalled only by pigs in blankets at Christmas with shoppers spending around £100m on the festive treat amid a fierce supermarket bake-off. This year a welter of new flavours, including speculoos and cheese pastry, are on the menu as stores seek to broaden their appeal.

Natalie Hitchins, Which?’s head of home products and services, said there was “nothing quite like a deliciously warm and crumbly mince pie straight from the oven to get you in the festive spirit”.

“The competition was tight this year but the luxury mince pie offerings from Waitrose and Aldi have come out on top,” she said. “Our experts tasted pies from the biggest supermarkets in the UK and found some great options which won’t break the bank”.

The Which? panel rated each pie on taste, aroma, texture and appearance and despite failing to secure a best buy gong, the judges praised the “buttery aroma” of the Co-op’s Irresistible All Butter Pastry Luxury Mince Pies although they complained alcohol “dominated the flavour”. They added that Asda’s Extra Special Mince Pies were also a “tasty option”.

However this year’s taste test turkeys were Tesco and Morrisons. Morrisons’ The Best and Tesco’s Finest mince pies did not stand out from the crowd when it came to the taste test and came bottom of the rankings, Which? said.


Zoe Wood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
M&S wins crown for best Christmas turkey and fizz in blind tasting
Supermarket chain’s festive range got the most top ratings in Good Housekeeping tests, with Aldi also performing well

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

16, Oct, 2017 @11:01 PM

Article image
Heston goes the whole hog this Christmas with bacon and banana trifle
Gastronomic gamble from chef Blumenthal to hit Waitrose shelves as British food stores unleash twists on festive classics

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

28, Nov, 2016 @12:01 AM

Article image
Aldi and Lidl mince pies beat Fortnum & Mason's in Which? taste test
'Lush, spicy and juicy' Aldi mince pies, the cheapest tested out of entries from a dozen retailers, top pre-Christmas contest

James Meikle

21, Nov, 2013 @12:31 AM

Article image
Aldi and Primark among retailers closing for Queen’s funeral
Morrisons makes checkout beeps quieter and turns off PA systems as businesses pay respects

Rupert Jones and agencies

12, Sep, 2022 @5:17 PM

Article image
Mince pie war hots up as supermarkets bid to woo younger taste buds
Be it cookie-style or plant-based, gin-infused or speculoos filling, retailers are experimenting with the festive cake

Zoe Wood

27, Nov, 2021 @8:41 AM

Article image
Supermarket shoppers can get their Christmas dinner for £20 – survey
Cost of buying 11 festive ingredients comes to £19.82 if consumers shop around across Aldi, Lidl, Asda, Morrisons and Iceland

Rebecca Smithers

30, Nov, 2016 @1:00 AM

Article image
Supermarkets to square off amid festive fervour of year’s biggest trading day
Visa expects Britons to load £1.3bn on their cards as the final Christmas trolley dash gets underway in key moment for retailers

Zoe Wood and Sarah Butler

22, Dec, 2014 @8:48 PM

Article image
Budget mince pies from Asda and Iceland top Which? taste test
Asda pies praised for ‘crisp and buttery’ pastry, while Iceland’s taste ‘like a more expensive product’

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

19, Nov, 2020 @12:01 AM

Article image
Slam dunk? Belgian biscuits set to be big Christmas foodie trend
Biscoff biscuits have soared in popularity during pandemic and supermarkets are taking notice

Zoe Wood

08, Oct, 2021 @12:26 PM

Article image
Venison and veal on the menu as Christmas shoppers trim the turkey
Sales of duck, guinea fowl, goose and even veal are all strong with customers choosing smaller turkeys or even crowns to serve alongside alternative meats

Rebecca Smithers

20, Dec, 2015 @3:35 PM