Russia’s economy is under siege, but will the west break first? | Larry Elliott

Sanctions will take time and ‘Ukraine fatigue’ could blunt west’s resolve as cost of living crisis deepens

It must have looked so simple for Vladimir Putin. Given his military superiority, a lightning strike by Russian forces would quickly overcome Ukrainian resistance and topple the regime in Kyiv.

The Kremlin would have bargained for the invasion being met with sanctions, but assumed these would be a minor inconvenience given the divisions in the west. But even if the measures were tougher than expected, Russia had a huge $650bn war chest of gold and foreign exchange reserves to support the economy.

The 19th-century German military strategist Helmuth von Moltke said no plan survives contact with the enemy and that was certainly true in this case. An increase in interest rates from 9.5% to 20%, the introduction of tough capital controls, the closure of the stock market and the clampdown on dissent all tell the same story: the campaign has not been the pushover Putin envisaged. The stiff resistance mounted by Ukraine was unexpected, as has been the west’s response. Russia’s economy is under siege.

While the targeting of oligarchs has grabbed headlines, by far the most significant sanction has been to limit Moscow’s access to its foreign exchange reserves, there to provide a defence against an attack on the rouble.

Reserves work in two ways. Firstly, they act as a deterrent, because those contemplating a speculative attack think twice if they know a central bank has the ability to slug it out. The bigger the reserves the less likely it is that a central bank will actually have to deploy them.

But if the “come and have a go if you think you’re hard enough” approach doesn’t work, a central bank with deep reserves can actively intervene in the currency markets. In the case of the central bank of Russia, that would involve converting some of the $650bn into roubles. Selling dollars, euros or pounds for roubles would lead to the Russian currency going up in value.

Neither of these options is now feasible. It is unclear precisely how much of the $650bn is frozen but on some estimates pretty much none of it can be used. More than two-thirds of the total – $460bn – is held in foreign currencies or securities, and largely now off-limits to Moscow. Most of the rest is in gold, which is held in vaults inside Russia. Putin could probably find someone to buy a chunk of this gold at a discount but it would be hard to convert the precious metal into ready cash quickly.

As a result of sanctions, the rouble suddenly became vulnerable and it fell by around a third against the US dollar in the past week. It would have fallen still further had it not been for the emergency increase in interest rates to 20% and the introduction of capital controls designed to prevent money leaving the country.

No question, this will hurt. A weaker currency will push up inflation while a doubling of borrowing costs will add to the impact of sanctions and push the economy into a deep recession. Kay Neufeld, the head of forecasting at the Centre for Economics and Business Research consultancy says that in two years’ time the Russian economy could be 14% smaller than it would have been had the invasion of Ukraine not gone ahead. Jobs will be lost. There will be shortages of imported goods. Savings will be worth less.

But as Neufeld points out, sanctions can inflict pain without leading to a change of leadership or a policy shift. Iran suffered a 20% reduction in potential output in the two years following the introduction of sanctions over its nuclear programme but didn’t buckle.

So, 10 days into the invasion, the west has a big decision to make. Does it deploy the biggest economic weapon it has left: adding Russia’s oil and gas exports to the sanctions list?

There are grounds for not doing this. For a start, the EU gets 40% of its natural gas from Russia and finding alternative supplies would take time. Western foreign ministers discussed an energy ban last week but are still at the stage of talking about reducing dependency on Russia rather than sanctions.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

The reason for hesitancy is obvious. Wholesale gas prices are already at record levels while crude oil is up by 40% since the start of the year. Western sanctions would result in oil and gas prices being higher – perhaps a lot higher – for longer. That would add to inflation and intensify an already acute squeeze on living standards.

For now, western governments are putting a higher priority on freedom for Ukraine than they are on domestic pressures on their electorates, but they must now weigh up how much pain they are prepared to inflict on their own people. Putin, when he took the decision to invade, presumably took the view that ordinary people in the west did not care about Ukraine. He was wrong about that, yet even so there is a risk that “Ukraine fatigue” will set in, especially as the cost of living crisis intensifies.

Ultimately the west has to decide how badly it wants to defeat Putin. If it is to do so, certain things need to happen. Sanctions will have to be extended to Russian oil and gas exports. Otherwise, Europe’s consumers will be bankrolling the Kremlin’s war machine. Finance ministries need to provide more help with energy bills, treating this crisis with the same seriousness as they did Covid-19. The transition to clean, homegrown energy must be accelerated. Last but not least, the west must not delude itself that sanctions will work quickly. It has to be ready for a long haul because even the toughest of sieges will take time to work.


Larry Elliott

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Europe could face energy rationing as ‘really tough winter’ looms, Shell boss warns
Ben van Beurden says Ukraine war fallout means big rise in bills and possible need to ration supplies

Mark Sweney and Alex Lawson

14, Jul, 2022 @12:04 PM

Article image
Concerns that India is ‘back door’ into Europe for Russian oil
Volume of Russian crude bought and then exported by India suggests some of it may end up in European petrol stations

Alex Lawson Energy correspondent

26, Jun, 2022 @2:45 PM

Article image
Shell to halt buying Russian oil and gas and Unilever to stop sales in Russia
Exodus of big British companies continues as bosses forced to examine their companies’ links to Russia

Julia Kollewe and Jasper Jolly

08, Mar, 2022 @7:24 PM

Article image
Britain imports no energy from Russia for first time on record
UK aimed to phase oil Russian oil imports by end of 2022; in June it achieved that target, ONS data shows

Larry Elliott Economics editor

24, Aug, 2022 @11:35 AM

Article image
Ukraine war ‘will mean high food and energy prices for three years’
World Bank says biggest commodity shock since 1970s raises spectre of stagflation

Larry Elliott Economics editor

26, Apr, 2022 @3:43 PM

Article image
How the war in Ukraine will fuel a sharp hike in inflation
With global economy hooked on fossil fuels economists are drawing parallels with the the oil shocks of the 1970s

Richard Partington

25, Feb, 2022 @5:20 PM

Article image
Ukraine crisis: commodities prices surge as stock markets slump
Russian invasion of Ukraine fuels near-40% rise in gas price and oil to $105 per barrel as European stock markets tumble

Phillip Inman, Rob Davies and Julia Kollewe

24, Feb, 2022 @5:27 PM

Article image
ExxonMobil launches legal challenge to EU’s windfall tax on energy firms
US oil firm contests legal authority for ‘solidarity contribution’ to raise funds to offset soaring energy prices

Richard Partington

28, Dec, 2022 @5:57 PM

Article image
Eurozone growth slips as Russia-Ukraine war pushes up energy costs
France’s economy stalls and Italy’s shrinks but Germany rebounds from contraction

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

29, Apr, 2022 @2:02 PM

Article image
Shell and Vitol accused of prolonging Ukraine war with sanctions ‘loophole’
Exclusive: Ukrainian economic adviser urges energy firms to heed deadline to halt trade of ‘Russian-origin oil products’

Alex Lawson Energy correspondent

19, Feb, 2023 @12:55 PM