Boris Johnson’s faster broadband promise is being broken, say MPs

UK ‘little nearer to closing great digital divide’ between cities and rural areas, says committee

Boris Johnson’s promise to “level up” the nation by providing next-generation-speed broadband to most homes by 2025 is under threat as rural dwellers are left behind in the internet revolution, according to a report by parliament’s spending watchdog.

The report by the public accounts committee found that the government is relying too heavily on companies, most notably BT Openreach and Virgin Media O2, to achieve Johnson’s key election manifesto pledge of addressing the UK’s status as a global laggard in broadband speeds.

These companies are focused on the less costly, easier to reach urban conurbations across the UK. The government plan, developed by the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, is failing to deliver on a promise to find affordable solutions to connect those living in rural areas and remote towns and villages.

“What DCMS does know full well is it can’t rely on the private sector to get fast broadband to the hardest to reach, excluded and rural areas,” said Dame Meg Hillier, the chair of the PAC. “And despite its repeated promises to do exactly that, we are apparently little nearer to closing ‘the great digital divide’ developing across the UK nor addressing the social and economic inequality it brings with it.”

At the end of last year, 47% of UK homes and premises had the potential to sign up for next-generation-speed broadband. While the rollout plan means half of all urban dwellers can get these speeds, only a quarter of those in rural areas have the opportunity.

The huge demand for reliable, high-speed internet connections as millions moved to home, remote and flexible working and schooling during the pandemic has increased pressure on and scrutiny of the government’s plans.

An initial promise by Johnson to deliver full-fibre broadband to every UK home by 2025 was subsequently expanded to include gigabit technology, which provides equally fast connections but the PAC said is “not as future proof”, in order to achieve the target.

The promise to reach every home was then reduced to 85% of homes and premises, with the government making only £1.2bn of a £5bn fund created to connect rural homes available until one year before its 2025 deadline, which the PAC is not convinced will be achieved.

chart

“DCMS’s planning and project management show all the signs of the previous rollout – the focus will continue to be on the easier to reach areas and there is still no plan for the hardest to reach communities,” Hillier said. “It couldn’t really explain how broadband has got as far as it has in this critical national strategy. And incredibly it still doesn’t have a real plan for getting the rest of the way to its downgraded targets.”

The PAC pointed out that the longer-term goal of every household getting access by 2030 still excludes about 134,000 premises in the hardest to reach areas that are not commercially viable. These “forgotten homes” are still unable to get even the 10Mbps speed connection deemed the bare minimum to meet a modern family’s needs.

The prohibitive cost of reaching these premises through conventional methods means the government is considering alternative technology such as satellite broadband to connect them.

“It is misleading to suggest we are reliant on the commercial sector to hit our target, which we remain on track to meet,” said a spokesperson for the DCMS. “We are investing £5bn so hard-to-reach areas can get gigabit speeds. Our policies and investment also mean 97% of premises can access superfast broadband which meets people’s current needs and helped us through the pandemic.”

Contributor

Mark Sweney

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fast broadband speeds not guaranteed by living in city centre, figures show

Research shows slowest area in London includes Barbican, next door to the City of London, while fastest is Charlton in Greenwich

Juliette Garside, telecoms correspondent

27, Mar, 2013 @8:38 PM

Article image
UK's big broadband providers give 'shoddy' service – report
TalkTalk, Sky, Virgin and BT rank worst in annual customer survey by Which?

Rupert Jones

25, Mar, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
Virgin Media and O2 owners confirm £31bn mega-merger in UK
Tie-up between parent groups Liberty Global and Telefonica aims to take on BT and Sky

Mark Sweney

07, May, 2020 @8:19 AM

Article image
Does BT's Openreach deal mean faster broadband or higher prices?
Consumers will hope their service improves when the telecoms group moves its division into a new company

Patrick Collinson

10, Mar, 2017 @1:57 PM

Article image
Why are UK telecoms firms imposing inflation-busting bills?
Exclusive: Ofcom is facing calls to intervene after companies pushed through prices rises of up to 17% this year

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

27, Jun, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
‘More than half of UK broadband customers’ hit by connection problems
Telecoms providers added ‘insult to injury’ as prices rose, says report by Which? for year to January 2023

Mark Sweney

03, Jul, 2023 @11:01 PM

Article image
How feasible is Labour's free broadband plan and part-nationalisation of BT?
UK lags behind other countries over full fibre but the election pledge raises many questions

Mark Sweney and Patrick Collinson

15, Nov, 2019 @10:56 AM

Article image
BT’s cheaper phone and broadband rivals eye transfer market
BT competitors are hoping to make signings after the firm said it plans to put up home phone and internet charges by 6.49%

Miles Brignall

28, Aug, 2014 @12:05 PM

Article image
UK’s broadband firms set for £1.7bn windfall with above-inflation price rises
Exclusive: annual bill increases are often several percentage points higher than the January CPI or RPI rate

Mark Sweney

07, Sep, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Virgin Media and BT take legal action against Birmingham council broadband

Companies file state aid complaint against Birmingham city council over launch of network which will compete with their own

Juliette Garside

21, Oct, 2012 @3:33 PM