UK rail firm rebuked for cancelling contest over ‘poor-quality’ entries

Advertising watchdog finds against East Midlands Railway after it said winner would receive £5,000

A train company breached advertising rules by cancelling a competition because of “poor-quality entries”, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has ruled.

In February, East Midlands Railway (EMR) asked members of the public to submit ideas to help it “build back better” and said the winning entry would receive £5,000.

The competition was cancelled shortly after being launched as the company said it had received “a high volume of what they felt to be poor-quality entries” and did not think any of the responses were suitable to be implemented.

The ASA ruled that this breached competition standards and had “caused unnecessary disappointment”.

In its ruling, published on Wednesday, the ASA said the fact the company “had not identified any ideas that they considered would be suitable to be implemented would not have prevented them from awarding the prize to the idea chosen to be the best by the judges”.

It told Abellio, which owns EMR, to ensure it awards prizes in future competitions and to make sure promotions are conducted under proper supervision.

When it announced the cancellation of the competition, EMR said: “We were overwhelmed with the level of passion and interest shown as we received well over 800 entries to the competition, with a huge range of ideas – from the very small to the very grand! However, we have regretfully taken the decision not to progress the Build Back Better competition at this time.”

It went on to say that while the railway is funded by taxpayers, “in light of exceptionally low passenger numbers, it would not be right to provide a cash prize and incur the expenditure to introduce the ideas.”

It added: “We know this will come as a disappointment to many of you, but we believe it is the right thing to do in these unprecedented times.”

ASA ruled that since the competition was launched nearly a year into the pandemic, the company would have been able to anticipate the challenges of going ahead with it.

An EMR spokesperson said: “We are aware of the ruling in this case and have taken onboard the recommendations made. We have also confirmed that we will not be progressing any submissions at this time. We would like again to thank all entrants for their submissions.”

Contributor

Jessica Murray

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Advertising watchdog rules against Gatwick Express '30 minutes to London' claim
The Advertising Standards Authority found more than a fifth of trains were delayed

Mark Sweney

31, Jul, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
UK watchdog rules Eurostar’s £39 seat sale advert was misleading
Operator advertised trips from £39 each way but only small percentage of tickets were on offer at that price

Jack Simpson

03, Jan, 2024 @5:59 PM

Article image
HS2 rail chief Terry Morgan faces sack over spiralling costs
Morgan, who Chris Grayling described as ‘world class’, set to go after four months in job

Kevin Rawlinson and Dan Sabbagh

30, Nov, 2018 @7:49 PM

Article image
Northern Rail asks Acas to intervene in row with RMT over guards
Rail operator asks arbitration service to establish inquiry into issues at heart of two-year dispute

Helen Pidd North of England editor

19, Dec, 2018 @5:48 PM

Article image
Rail strikes to go ahead after talks over role of guards break down
Failure of talks between unions and Arriva – which runs Northern – and South Western Railway will mean disruption on three days next week

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

04, Jan, 2018 @6:59 PM

Article image
Northern rail disruption continues amid driver shortage
Dozens of trains cancelled on key routes as strike threatens to cause more problems

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

22, May, 2018 @12:15 PM

Article image
Rail fares: unions and Labour condemn 'staggering' increase
Prices will rise by 3.4% on average, sparking protests at dozens of train stations as ‘passengers pay more for less’

Peter Walker Political correspondent

02, Jan, 2018 @7:03 AM

Article image
Southern rail and RMT chiefs agree to face-to-face talks over strikes
Union calls for talks after franchise owner apparently pledges a second staff member on all trains with a conductor, a sticking point in dispute

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

11, Oct, 2016 @5:46 PM

Article image
Cancellations and delays as new rail timetables introduced
Northern and Thameslink services particularly affected on ‘meltdown Monday’

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

21, May, 2018 @11:21 AM

Article image
Christopher Grayling may back 'flawed' TransPennine rail upgrade
Exclusive: sources say DfT committee recommends delay-plagued route should not be fully electrified

Helen Pidd North of England editor

07, Dec, 2018 @6:16 PM