Businesses saw right through Johnson’s bombast, but will Sunak?

The PM’s Thatcherite conference speech ignored many realities that will have to be addressed in this month’s budget

Boris Johnson threw a mishmash of wishful economic thinking at the Conservative party conference wall last week and his advisers will spend this weekend hunkered down in No 10 hoping some of it will stick. Early signs are not good. Only hours after the prime minister stepped off the podium, the rightwing Adam Smith Institute thinktank called his rhetoric “bombastic but vacuous and economically illiterate”. It was typical of reaction throughout the business community.

According to Johnson-omics, Britain will emerge fitter, happier and more productive once the prime minister’s limits on foreign labour have forced domestic employers to ramp up wages. Never mind that academic research finds little correlation between immigration and average pay. More immediately, he is ignoring the factory owners who are slamming on the brakes in response to shortages of key components, and the building firms downing tools for lack of concrete and steel. And what of concerns that rising gas and food prices are likely to send inflation well above the 4%-4.5% peak expected by the Bank of England?

The babbling brook of words that tumbled from Johnson’s mouth obviously made sense to him and his aides in No 10. What is less clear is how and why it made sense to his next-door neighbour.

It falls to Rishi Sunak to explain how the efforts of ministers, civil servants and business owners themselves, have failed over six decades or more – decades characterised by Britain’s relative decline – to create the high-wage economy Johnson says is just around the corner.

The Sunak doctrine appears to rely on the same building blocks as Johnson-omics. Investment in skills training for the existing pool of labour, sponsored by the government, makes workers more productive. A more productive workforce leads to increased profits, allowing companies to afford higher wages and higher taxes. To complete the trick, there is also enough money left over to boost investment in new kit and to keep dividends flowing to shareholders.

In this new paradigm, only those who cannot work receive welfare. Everyone else will have a job that pays enough to live the good life. With the burden of welfare spending reduced, borrowing as a percentage of national income will fall.

In his conference speech, Johnson inevitably invoked the memory of one former leader to support his mission. “Margaret Thatcher would not have ignored this meteorite that has just crashed through the public finances,” he said. “She would have wagged her finger and said more borrowing now is just higher interest rates and even higher taxes later.”

Let’s set aside for a moment that big borrowing over the past 18 months has been accompanied by lower interest bills, and that there is every expectation that ultra-low interest rates will persist for many years. Focus instead on a parallel between Johnson and Thatcher that relates to the present day.

Thatcher came to power promising a new era of high wages and investment based on “sound money” and an end to inflation. Within months, her chancellor, Geoffrey Howe, said he needed to make the adjustment quickly. Referring to limiting public spending to bring down borrowing, Howe told parliament: “We shall continue to pursue those policies so long as it is necessary for them to prevail.”

By 1981, the euphoria surrounding Thatcher’s victory had evaporated and she was the most unpopular prime minister of the postwar era. Riots swept the UK.

Her tumbling poll ratings were tied to the enormous pain she inflicted on society while waiting for the monetarist theories of Milton Friedman to work their magic. Many historians agree it is unlikely she would have won the 1983 election without the boost of winning the Falklands war.

Economists who liken the UK’s current situation to the 1970s argue mostly, and wrongly, that today’s economy bears some resemblance to the economy back then. It doesn’t, on almost every level.

Politically though, Johnson has embarked on a similar road to the one mapped out by Thatcher – an almost Maoist long march to the sunny uplands. In Johnson’s case, a mix of central planning and laissez--faire policies is already struggling to put so much as a home-grown turkey on the Christmas table.

In his budget this month, Sunak may prove more supple than Howe. With Covid lingering and inflation-adjusted wages already stalled, he could and should reverse welfare cuts before they begin to bite. It is also too early in the recovery for planned rises in income tax, national insurance, council tax and corporation tax. If he resists, he may have riots of his own to contend with.


Phillip Inman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Reforming Lawson or austerity Osborne: how will Sunak’s budget go?
A chancellor bent on trimming the deficit will face opposition from MPs, business and more this week

Phillip Inman

23, Oct, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Debt may be cheap, but the UK's poor productivity will cost us dear
Thinktanks urging cuts in business taxes seem to forget that many industries which once powered growth are now dying

Phillip Inman

10, Oct, 2020 @4:00 PM

Article image
Rishi's dinners won't stop businesses feeling empty by autumn
Eat out to help out saw busy restaurants and extra spending generally, but looming job losses could mean the whole nation tightening its belt

Richard Partington

29, Aug, 2020 @11:05 PM

Article image
Budget 2021: Sunak softens universal credit cuts to tackle squeeze on families
Chancellor announces measures to help households, with lower alcohol and fuel duties

Richard Partington and Jessica Elgot

27, Oct, 2021 @1:07 PM

Article image
Sunak isn’t planning for business – he’s budgeting for the next election
The chancellor is politically astute, but there is less substance in his investment plans than it appears

31, Oct, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Sunak will say things are looking up, but OBR has less faith in a rebound
With bad news on jobs, and ongoing risk from Covid-19, hopes for a V-shaped recovery look misplaced

Richard Partington

12, Jul, 2020 @6:09 AM

Article image
With debt heading for £2tn, Sunak will need to get imaginative about tax rises
He must reassure the country that austerity will not return: a tax on property assets, however unpopular, would be an answer

15, Nov, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Rishi Sunak isn’t gloating about the UK’s economic recovery. He is wise not to
The Treasury understands that shutdowns and reopenings can seriously distort growth and joblessness figures

23, May, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
‘Scrooge’ Sunak could spoil the party for Boris Johnson
The prime minister’s expansive vision for Britain faces many hurdles, the most awkward of which is his chancellor

Phillip Inman

28, Aug, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
The real message of Rishi Sunak’s budget will be laying groundwork for next election | Richard Partington
Chancellor will want to show government is looking to future despite supply crisis and Covid

Richard Partington

24, Oct, 2021 @1:10 PM