Gina Rinehart takes issue with climate change ‘propaganda’ in speech to private girls’ school

Mining magnate complains students were made to watch Al Gore documentary in video that was edited by her former school

The mining billionaire Gina Rinehart has taken aim at what she called climate “propaganda” during a speech to high school students, which was later partially edited out by the principal because a historic assembly was “not the context or the time” for it.

Rinehart was asked to give a video address to students for the 125th anniversary of St Hilda’s Anglican School for Girls in Perth, her former school.

The school said the speech was only supposed to go for five minutes, but it ran for 16.

In it, the iron ore miner and Australia’s richest person targeted climate change “propaganda” in the education system, and complained about being told that students had once been made to watch Al Gore’s 2006 documentary An Inconvenient Truth.

She boasted that she had once helped to convince students climate change was not human-induced by organising a talk at the school by climate skeptic Lord Christopher Monckton and Prof Ian Plimer.

“The first thing Lord Monckton asked the senior students, being aware [An Inconvenient Truth] had been shown repeatedly to students, was to put their hands up if they believed that climate change was human-induced,” she said.

“About 70% or more of students put their hands up. Lord Monckton and Prof Plimer were only given a comparatively short time to speak … at the end of their speeches, the question [about] human-induced climate change was re-asked, and the hands changed, about 30% put their hands up.”

Rinehart called for the school to “strongly guard against propaganda intruding on real education and rational thinking”, and told students to “do their own independent research” on “which comes first – global warming, or an increase in carbon?”.

She concluded the speech by extensively quoting the former British prime minister Margaret Thatcher, including the line that the “problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people’s money”.

But the speech was not run in full by the school, prompting claims of censorship by spokespeople for the mining billionaire.

In a statement to the West Australian newspaper, her spokesperson said it was “very unusual for Mrs Rinehart to be asked to give the keynote speech, then the morning of the speech be told it would in effect be censored”.

“It’s very, very sad to see after the school’s fine history of education over more than a century [that it is now] subject to the political views of its new headmistress,” the spokesperson reportedly said.

But the school said the video sent by Rinehart had been “much longer than the allotted five minutes” and the school was “only able to play the first five minutes which shared her recollections of her time at the school”.

“I can confirm that the messaging in the video was not shared in its entirety with the students at this assembly,” a school spokesperson said in a statement.

“The School encourages our students to think critically and analyse all facts presented to them, particularly in this age of the internet. The School does not endorse the personal views shared in the full video.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

“We encourage critical thinking and discussion on controversial topics, ensuring that there are opposing views to motivate purposeful conversation. An historical birthday celebration assembly was not the context or the time.”

The spokesperson said the school’s science curriculum “follows the guidelines set out by the West Australian School Curriculum and Standards Authority”.

Rinehart’s speech has been criticised by climate change experts, including the Climate Council spokesperson and ANU emeritus professor Will Steffen, who said “the science is settled on climate change”.

“Australia prides itself on having a quality education system – one of the best in the world. It is important that schools stick to the most reputable science about climate change, as embodied in the latest IPCC report,” he said.

“In this case, the school stuck to the science-based curriculum, which is increasingly important with the amount of misinformation flying around.

“Young people have so much moral authority because it’s their future that we’re risking by pumping greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.”

“A few weeks out from Cop26, the rest of the world, our states and territories, farmers, industries, parents, and most importantly, the young people of Australia want to see stronger action on climate change. That means committing to strong and urgent emissions cuts this decade.”


Michael McGowan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Gina Rinehart company revealed as $4.5m donor to climate sceptic thinktank
Billionaire’s company gave significant donations to the Institute of Public Affairs in 2016 and 2017

Graham Readfearn

20, Jul, 2018 @10:05 PM

Article image
Australia’s biggest landholder is Gina Rinehart, controlling 9.2m hectares
Others with substantial holdings include Andrew and Nicola Forrest in WA, SA’s MacLachlan family and the Brook and McDonald families in Queensland

Ben Butler

16, May, 2021 @8:00 PM

Article image
Australia’s rarest tortoises get new home to save them from climate change
Natural range of critically endangered western swamp tortoise increasingly untenable owing to reduced rainfall

Calla Wahlquist

16, Aug, 2016 @8:31 PM

Article image
Sawfish deaths on Gina Rinehart station kept quiet by WA government, FOI reveals
Emails show WA department wanted to prevent news of the protected sawfish deaths being reported by the media

Calla Wahlquist

05, Aug, 2019 @7:50 AM

Article image
Is Gina Rinehart planning to use Fairfax to push her climate scepticism? | Leo Hickman

Climate sceptic mining billionaire's bid for control of Fairfax Media threatens its journalists' editorial independence

Leo Hickman

27, Jun, 2012 @2:44 PM

Article image
AFR takes up the cause of ‘unfairly maligned billionaire’ Gina Rinehart | The Weekly Beast
Mining magnate praised for her ‘life-changing generosity’ in a series of flattering portraits. Plus: ABC’s board tussle

Amanda Meade

10, Feb, 2023 @6:21 AM

Article image
Gina Rinehart and the not very good adventures of the dead sawfish | First Dog on the Moon
It is unlikely there will be an investigation or if there is it will be inconclusive. And nobody will be surprised

First Dog on the Moon

19, Aug, 2019 @7:51 AM

Article image
Sophie Mirabella appointed to senior role at Gina Rinehart's company
Mining billionaire praises the former Liberal MP’s work ethic and says new government relations role has become necessary due to growth of the business

Bridie Jabour

12, Aug, 2016 @4:29 AM

Article image
News Corp is going ‘only positive’ on climate but did Gina Rinehart miss the memo? | The Weekly Beast
It seems the billionaire is not convinced by the Murdoch empire’s new Mission Zero campaign, and neither are its star commentators; Plus: Tomalaris rides off

Amanda Meade

15, Oct, 2021 @1:46 AM

Article image
Adam Giles, former NT chief minister, hired by Gina Rinehart
Ex-leader of CLP to focus on pastoral side of Hancock’s business in the wake of acquisition of S Kidman & Co

Helen Davidson in Darwin

25, Jan, 2017 @7:59 AM