Football’s super league fiasco underlines the need for levelling up everywhere

The bid by top clubs to break away was globalisation at its worst – and emblematic of the UK’s problems beyond sport

Four weeks on from what is turning out to be one of the biggest self-inflicted errors by any members of the business elite, the owners of the supposedly top six English football clubs must be wondering how on earth they got themselves into this mess. They are also probably, wishfully, thinking: “Head down, this will all blow over.”

Among the numerous fascinating aspects of the European Super League debacle, designed to ram through non-competitive staged events for Europe’s top teams, is that it arrived in the UK – England, specifically – at a time when the government is trying to resurrect its domestic mantra of “levelling up” after 14 months of challenges over Covid-19.

As a sign of perhaps growing confidence that, at least in the UK, the pandemic is starting to become endemic, No 10 announced the appointment of the MP Neil O’Brien as an adviser on levelling up. From my own deep involvement with the “northern powerhouse”, the related theme of devolution, and much else in this space, it is highly welcome.

I doubt that O’Brien would immediately think of the European Super League as something that fell into his territory, but it completely symbolises why the rough edges of globalisation need to be shaved. The idea of an oligopolistic entity being imposed on the top of European football, resulting in even less money cascading down the so-called pyramid of domestic football, is right up there with the worst attempted rigs of any market in the world of business.

Of course, in this instance, it was laughable: some of the declared “top” 12 clubs had never won the European Cup or the Champions League, simply serving to underline the stupidity of it.

I am not sure I can recall anything quite as blatant as this since I was studying for my PhD and commentators talked at length about the Opec cartel supposedly controlling crude oil supplies. That view never had any legs, due to the emergence of other oil and other energy producers, as well as the behaviour of Saudi Arabia, but the establishment of the organisation in the early 1970s had the same audacity about it.

What is so beautiful about this latest colossal error of judgment is that it shines a strong light on the instincts that exist in parts of the business world, despite the staggering pandemic we have gone through, and the catastrophic personal challenges it has created for so many people. As a result, it has induced all sorts of reactions, some of which are not going to be put back in their boxes any time soon.

Last weekend saw the enforced postponement of the biggest annual football match in the English calendar: Manchester United v Liverpool. Of course, the violence that occurred in Manchester should not be condoned, but the role of the club’s current owners in the failed Super League has unleashed 16 years of pent-up anger. As Roy Keane, the club’s former captain, said that day, this could be just the beginning.

Within three days, the Premier League had issued what for it seemed like a surprisingly tough statement, indicating that an owner’s charter, incorporating a code of conduct and commitment to key principles, would now need to be signed, with significant penalties for failure to comply.

Cynics – not surprisingly, given the history of football governance – dismiss this as a crude attempt to pacify the masses and government. But I doubt the other 14 Premier League clubs that had to sit uncomfortably in on that Zoom call would agree; nor do I suspect would the government, given its efforts three weeks ago to hurry through a football governance review.

Hopefully that will lead to much-needed reforms, and call for two basic requirements in particular: one, an independent regulator that sets the rules within which each of the English organisations conduct themselves, Premier League included; and two, some kind of legislated move to enforce proper representation of fans’ needs and desires.

It certainly would be difficult to introduce the much-discussed German “50+1” common ownership model, and that might not translate to the English game. But the enforcement of proper boards with true independent directors would be an extremely easy step, and a beginning.

Whether some of the current owners of the failed breakaway group still see any purpose in owning these precious assets remains to be seen, but unless they have drunk the Kool-Aid of ESG (Environment, Social and Governance) and profit with a purpose, I rather doubt it.

Lord O’Neill is a former commercial secretary to the Treasury and the current chair of Chatham House. Phillip Inman is away


Jim O'Neill

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A glance across the Atlantic would show Sunak what real tax reform looks like
Joe Biden is about to shake up US taxation policy. The UK must hope that the chancellor feels a need to emulate him

25, Apr, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
European Super League clubs promised €200m-€300m ‘welcome bonus’
JP Morgan commits €3.25bn to getting breakaway competition off the ground

Rupert Neate, Mark Sweney and Graeme Wearden

19, Apr, 2021 @3:34 PM

Article image
The low-paid need Britain to reopen. But this outbreak isn’t over
Many of the country’s poorest workers are shut out of their workplaces; but fears for public health remain real

28, Jun, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
JP Morgan ‘misjudged’ football fans over European Super League
US bank’s involvement in ESL funding prompted sustainability downgrade for ethical performance

Jasper Jolly

23, Apr, 2021 @10:16 AM

Article image
It’s time for centibillionaires to help pay the cost of Covid
In a dramatically unequal society, a one-off wealth tax provides a clear and decisive route to balancing the Treasury’s books

09, Aug, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Feeling the pinch? The super-rich certainly aren’t
Credit Suisse’s ‘wealth’ report will show how higher prices and rising inflation are hitting ordinary Brits – and make fast-growing differences in wealth even starker

Shane Hickey

12, Nov, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Pérez says Super League clubs ‘cannot leave’ as Manchester United fans protest
The Real Madrid president said ‘this project will move forward’ as United fans demand owners quit the club in Old Trafford demo

John Brewin

24, Apr, 2021 @3:45 PM

Article image
European Super League will pour €400m into grassroots football, says new chief
Anas Laghari claims elite competition will reignite love of game and end ‘madness’ of big money transfers

Rupert Neate and Peter Walker

20, Apr, 2021 @4:44 PM

Article image
JP Morgan given lower sustainability rating after funding failed European Super League
Standard Ethics downgrades US bank from ‘adequate’ to ‘non-compliant’ in light of ESL backing

Jasper Jolly

21, Apr, 2021 @3:17 PM

Article image
The European Super League is the perfect metaphor for global capitalism | Larry Elliott
Our lives are increasingly governed by ‘free’ markets that turn out to be rigged, says Guardian columnist Larry Elliott

Larry Elliott

22, Apr, 2021 @5:00 AM