Nigerians can bring claims against Shell in UK, supreme court rules

Ogale and Bille villagers say Shell oil operations have caused severe pollution including to their drinking water

Two Nigerian communities can bring their legal claims for a cleanup and for compensation against the oil company Shell and its Nigerian subsidiary in an English court, supreme court judges have said.

In what lawyers said was a “watershed moment” for the accountability of multinational companies, on Friday the court overturned a decision by the court of appeal, and ruled that the cases against Shell could proceed.

The judges said the court of appeal was wrong when it said the company was not responsible for the harm caused by oil extraction in the Niger delta, because it was merely a holding company for Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria (SPDC). It had also erred, the judges said, when it carried out a mini-trial of the facts before the disclosure of relevant documents.

“There are real issues to be tried,” the supreme court said.

The law firm Leigh Day, which represents the communities, successfully argued that Shell, one of the world’s 10 largest corporations by revenue with assets of more than $400bn (£290bn), must answer for the environmental failures of its subsidiary because the company is registered in London.

The villagers, from the Ogale and Bille communities, say they have been affected by oil pollution for years because of Shell’s operations in Nigeria, including the pollution of their drinking water.

Shell did not dispute that both communities had been severely polluted by its oil, or that there was yet to be an adequate cleanup of the pollution. Instead, it argued that Royal Dutch Shell plc could not be legally responsible for the harm caused to the communities, and so the cases should not be heard in England.

The communities have been fighting for five years to have their cases heard in the English courts. They are pursuing legal claims against Shell through the English courts because they say there is no prospect of obtaining justice in Nigeria.

Daniel Leader, a partner at Leigh Day, said: “This supreme court judgment gives real hope to the people of Ogale and Bille, who have been asking Shell to clean up their oil for years. We hope that now, finally, Shell will act.

“But it also represents a watershed moment in the accountability of multinational companies. Increasingly, impoverished communities are seeking to hold powerful corporate actors to account and this judgment will significantly increase their ability to do so.”

A report last year by Friends of the Earth, Amnesty International and other NGOs said the people of Ogoniland were still waiting for a thorough cleanup of the oil spills. The report said only11% of the total area contaminated was being cleaned up, and even in the area targeted the work had not been completed.

The report said: “In order to address its devastating legacy of pollution in Nigeria, Shell should also pay for cleanup of the rest of the Niger delta and compensate communities affected by its activities.

“The tragic and unresolved situation in Ogoniland demonstrates the urgency for governments – including those of the UK and the Netherlands where Shell is headquartered – to issue strong legislation mandating companies to respect human rights and environmental standards across their global operations.”

Nigerians from the Ogale and Bille communities say they have suffered decades of pollution, including the contamination of their water wells with potentially cancer-causing chemicals, as well as the devastation of mangrove vegetation, all of which was documented by the United Nations Environment Programme in a groundbreaking report in 2011.

The report said it could take 30 years to clean up the pollution caused by oil extraction and recommended an initial fund of $1bn (£800m) for the first five years to be paid by the oil companies that operate in Ogoniland, of which Shell is the largest.

Shell has been contacted for comment.

Contributors

Sandra Laville and Emmanuel Akinwotu in Lagos

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ogoni king: Shell oil is killing my people
King Emere was in a London court last week for the case that he hopes will allow him to sue Shell in the UK for polluting his tribal land

John Vidal

03, Dec, 2016 @7:45 PM

Article image
Nigerians could see justice over Shell oil spills after six decades
A landmark legal case is laying the groundwork for communities to sue parent companies for the damages of their subsidiaries

Maggie Andresen in Okogbe-Ahoada, Nigeria, for Floodlight

29, Sep, 2021 @10:15 AM

Article image
Nigerians given go-ahead to sue Shell in UK court over oil spills
Tens of thousands of fishermen and farmers from Niger delta region allege decades of uncleaned spills have polluted area

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

02, Mar, 2016 @7:39 PM

Article image
Shell faces payouts in Nigerian oil spill case
First ruling in environmental trial forces Shell to compensate communities affected by spills from firm's damaged pipelines

John Vidal

20, Jun, 2014 @7:04 PM

Article image
MPs spell out risks to Arctic if Shell restarts oil drilling | Letter from Joan Walley MP
Letter: The particular spill risks from drilling in the Arctic require a strong precautionary principle approach to drilling regulation

Letters

26, Mar, 2015 @7:39 PM

Article image
Shell verdict will determine whether other firms could be tried for oil spills | John Vidal

John Vidal: People affected in the Niger delta have come to Europe to ask for justice as multinationals dismiss their claims with impunity

John Vidal

29, Jan, 2013 @4:37 PM

Article image
Arctic oil rush will ruin ecosystem, warns Lloyd's of London

Insurance market joins environmentalists in highlighting risks of drilling in fragile region as $100bn investment is predicted

Julia Kollewe and Terry Macalister

11, Apr, 2012 @11:03 PM

Article image
Shell must face Friends of the Earth Nigeria claim in Netherlands
Shell expresses disappointment over Hague court ruling on compensation case over alleged pollution in Oruma, Nigeria

Terry Macalister

30, Dec, 2009 @10:00 PM

Article image
Double standards on oil spills in Nigeria must end | Letters
Letters: Oil companies must respect human lives and clean up the damage their industry does wherever they operate, say Dr John Sentamu, Baroness Amos, Prof Michael Watts, Njeri Kabeberi and James Thornton

Letters

26, Mar, 2019 @6:25 PM

Article image
Shell: Clean-up goes on for Niger Delta – and oil company's reputation

Shell's image is still mired by claims over oil spills, Ken Saro-Wiwa's hanging and WikiLeak's revelations of infiltration

John Vidal, environment editor

03, Feb, 2011 @7:07 PM