Loophole in ministers’ code allows lobbying to remain secret, says ex-civil servant

Some lobbying by companies such as Greensill Capital is not required to be reported in transparency filings

A loophole in the ministers’ code of conduct has allowed officials to keep the lobbying of companies like Greensill Capital off of public records, according to an ex-civil servant, who says ministers are not bound to report unofficial calls, texts and emails.

Gaps in the ministerial code are being scrutinised in the wake of the Greensill lobbying scandal, in which former prime minister David Cameron tried to secure the lender special access to the UK’s largest emergency Covid loans scheme by messaging ministers, including the chancellor Rishi Sunak, and Whitehall officials last year.

Those messages were not reported in transparency filings. An independent government investigation was launched on Monday, partly focusing on Cameron’s lobbying efforts on behalf Greensill, which appointed him as an adviser in 2018.

Alex Thomas, a former senior civil servant who spent 17 years working in the Cabinet Office, Department of Health, and Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, believes ministers did not breach any rules. However, he says the code itself is at fault.

“The fact that ministers do not declare telephone conversations or private meetings or text messages is, in a sense, a loophole,” said Thomas, who is now a director at the Institute for Government thinktank.

“It means that their contacts [with lobbyists] are not publicly available. And I think the threshold at the moment is too high, and a bit arbitrary,” he added.

The code, which was formalised in the 1990s, says ministers who meet and discuss official business without another official present, “for example at a social occasion or on holiday”, should pass any “significant content” back to the department as soon as possible afterward. Those meetings are meant to be published in transparency filings, released four times a year.

Tom Brake, a former Liberal Democrat MP who helped design the lobbying register while he was deputy leader of the House of Commons, has written to the cabinet secretary Simon Case, asking him to review what appears to be a “gaping hole” in the rules.

He has also urged Case to clarify whether Sunak and others including Jesse Norman – a junior Treasury minister who Cameron also contacted – should have reported their discussions with the former prime minister in quarterly meeting reports.

“Ministers have either broken ministerial code repeatedly by failing to log these contacts with [Cameron] and potentially any number of other ex-conservative ministers, or the ministerial code is so weak that it is meaningless,” Brake said.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

“The ability of ministers to evade the transparency rules by simply having a private phone conversation, means that the code is fundamentally defective” said Brake, who now works for the campaign group Unlock Democracy.

Cameron released a statement on Sunday, saying he accepted that he should have communicated with ministers “through only the most formal of channels” and there were “important lessons” to be learned.

A government spokesperson said: “The chancellor has acted in line with the ministerial code.”


Kalyeena Makortoff

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Civil servant advised Greensill while working in Whitehall, says watchdog
Bill Crothers became a director of finance firm months after leaving civil service, records show

Jessica Elgot, Kalyeena Makortoff and Rajeev Syal

13, Apr, 2021 @7:17 PM

Article image
UK ministers may face five-year lobbying ban after leaving office
Anti-corruption watchdog demands overhaul in wake of David Cameron Greensill scandal

Rajeev Syal

14, Jun, 2021 @12:29 PM

Article image
Greensill scandal: ex-civil servant had $8m stake in lender
Bill Crothers met Cabinet Office official several times after leaving post and becoming a director at failed lender

Kalyeena Makortoff, Ben Butler and Joseph Smith

13, Apr, 2021 @12:07 PM

Article image
Whitehall civil servants ordered to disclose all conflicts of interest
Cabinet secretary sets Friday deadline citing ‘acute concern’, as Tory MPs block broader inquiry

Peter Walker and Jessica Elgot

14, Apr, 2021 @7:50 PM

Article image
Greensill lobbying leaves your reputation in tatters, Cameron told
MPs grill former prime minister for four hours about his text message and WhatsApp campaign

Rupert Neate

13, May, 2021 @6:17 PM

Article image
Labour dismisses Tory claim of ‘robust’ lobbying rules
‘Cosy relationship’ between government and lobbyists ‘stinks of sleaze’, says Rachel Reeves

Andrew Sparrow Political correspondent

18, Apr, 2021 @2:05 PM

Article image
Greensill review calls for lobbying transparency and new code of conduct
Report launched in response to David Cameron’s lobbying suggests ministers curb supply chain finance

Kalyeena Makortoff Banking correspondent

16, Sep, 2021 @7:23 PM

Article image
Civil servant breached rules by failing to declare trustee role
Bill Crothers, embroiled in the Greensill scandal, did not inform watchdog about taking role after leaving Whitehall

Kalyeena Makortoff

15, Apr, 2021 @9:46 PM

Article image
Greensill lobbying scandal: the full list of inquiries
David Cameron and Rishi Sunak could give evidence as slew of investigations ordered into failed supply chain firm

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor and Peter Walker

16, Apr, 2021 @12:12 PM

Article image
Second Cabinet Office adviser hired by Greensill while in civil service
David Brierwood joined David Cameron’s government in 2014 and two months later was recruited to Greensill Capital

Kalyeena Makortoff and Jessica Elgot

15, Apr, 2021 @7:56 PM