After six months of turmoil, John Lewis can only hope for better

The retailer had ‘lost its way’ even before Covid-19 forced stores to close. So this week’s results will not be pretty

It has been a torrid year for middle-class favourite John Lewis, and this week the retailer, which is in the midst of a revolution under new boss Sharon White, will lay bare the damage coronavirus is wreaking on its finances.

A heavy first-half loss is anticipated from its department stores, which were struggling before the pandemic struck. As a reminder, the shops were closed for three of the six months under scrutiny. In July, White confirmed that eight of the group’s 50 outlets, including its sprawling Birmingham branch, were closed for good.

White, who arrived in February from the communications regulator Ofcom, is shaking up the employee-owned business that is also behind the Waitrose supermarket chain.

An economist by training, she pulled no punches, stating matter-of-factly in a recent interview that “we lost our way” under the previous management. She also sketched a radical new vision that it is hoped will arrest declining profitability. Last year, the retailer’s profits slumped 23% to £123m. Three years ago it was making £360m.

Building affordable housing, selling financial products, such as Isas and equity-release loans, and even landscape gardening are among the ideas to have emerged from White’s brainstorming as the business seeks to reduce its reliance on a diminishing high street.

She will set out her vision in full next month, but recent announcements – including enlisting Deliveroo riders to deliver Waitrose groceries, and a new furniture rental service at John Lewis – point to the direction of travel.

The stakes are high. White has already warned the group’s 80,000 employees – or partners – that the tumultuous economic backdrop means they are unlikely to receive a staff bonus next year. The annual payout, the same percentage for everyone from the chairman to shelf stackers, is an integral part of the group’s culture.

Its famous “never knowingly undersold” price promise is also under threat. Retail analysts argue the sentiment, which does not extend to online-only retailers, has become irrelevant in a year when 60-70% of John Lewis’s sales will come from the internet.

Waitrose also has a big fight on its hands after the end of its long-running partnership with delivery group Ocado, which has switched to a partnership with Marks & Spencer. The cost of beefing up its web operation will have weighed on profits, as will the higher costs of operating throughout the pandemic.

It will be worth paying attention on Thursday, as we don’t hear from the mutual as much as we used to. In January, John Lewis canned its weekly sales updates, which were watched closely by rivals and used by City analysts as a gauge of high street conditions.

The update will also be the first glimpse of the business’s all-new leadership team. It has poached Pippa Wicks – instrumental in the turnaround of the Co-op, another mutual that had fallen on hard times – to steer the department store chain. Another new face, following last year’s restructuring, is former Sainsbury’s director James Bailey, now at Waitrose.

Back in April, White said the pandemic meant the group was looking at worst-case scenarios of a full-year sales decline of 35% at John Lewis and 5% at Waitrose. John Lewis’s online sales boomed during the lockdown, but independent retail analyst Nick Bubb says this tilt to the web will have been “ruinous” for its finances because of the extra delivery and distribution costs, coming on top of the bill for the upkeep of its stores.

And all that was before Boris Johnson potentially cancelled Christmas, a time of year when John Lewis and Waitrose usually clean up, with his new “rule of six”. But will the picture be that gloomy? Even the Grinch couldn’t stop Christmas.


Zoe Wood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sharon White gets set to live the troubled John Lewis dream
The ex-Ofcom boss takes over this week – at a time when the partnership’s cherished traditions are under heavy pressure

Zoe Wood

02, Feb, 2020 @12:05 AM

Article image
John Lewis staff brace for a life with little or no bonus
The employee-owned partnership reveals what staff will receive this week. After a hard year, it may not be much

Zoe Wood

03, Mar, 2019 @6:59 AM

Article image
John Lewis treads a fine line between staying special and staying alive
The retailer’s results this week will look ugly, but too drastic a course change could hurt its image forever

Sarah Butler

07, Mar, 2021 @12:05 AM

Article image
John Lewis prepares to drop 'never knowingly undersold' pledge
95-year-old price match vow makes way as new chief plots path out of coronavirus crisis

Joanna Partridge

23, Aug, 2020 @4:24 PM

Article image
John Lewis may turn surplus stores into affordable homes
Partnership also plans to close some supermarkets and sell own-label food at other retailers

Zoe Wood

30, Jul, 2020 @3:14 PM

Article image
John Lewis to close more stores as Covid crisis wipes out profits
Department store group records £517m loss and does not expect to reopen all stores in April when retail lockdown ends

Sarah Butler

11, Mar, 2021 @4:40 PM

Article image
Suffering John Lewis stands at a crossroads on the high street
The retailer is eyeing a more online future. But as the last big department store standing, could it expand in the real world?

Sarah Butler and Zoe Wood

19, Sep, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Does John Lewis warning of closures mean department stores are doomed?
Changing shopping habits are hurting even the biggest brands, and fuelling redevelopment of unloved retail space

Zoe Wood

08, Feb, 2020 @4:00 PM

Article image
Nina Bhatia: the woman taking John Lewis from homewares to housing
The store’s strategy director aims to be making 40% of profits from outside retail – including rental properties – by 2030

Sarah Butler

18, Jun, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
John Lewis scraps staff bonus and warns of job cuts after £234m loss
Warning follows group’s second ever full-year loss, and 3% fall in sales at Waitrose

Sarah Butler

16, Mar, 2023 @3:54 PM